Study

Curated
Hunter et al., 2016
The Genetic Architecture of Natural Variation in Recombination Rate in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1371/journal.pgen.1005951]

Description

Meiotic crossover frequency was measured in a 3R (e-ro) and an X (y-v) interval in F1 females from 204 DGRP lines crossed to marker stocks (3 replicates). Rates varied about 2-fold and were uncorrelated between intervals. Ovarian qPCR of 20 candidate genes was done in 120 lines.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the Supporting Information of the paper (journal page, open access, doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1005951):
- S2 Table (pgen.1005951.s010.xlsx): crossover frequency of each of the 3 replicate assays, and their average in cM, for the e ro (3R) and y v (X) intervals, for the 205 DGRP lines, with the lines' inversion karyotypes and Wolbachia status.
- S17 Table (s025): the 6 lines used for each of the 20 candidate genes of the ovarian qPCR.
- S19 and S20 Tables (s027, s028): qPCR Cq values per well, normalised to GAPDH and before normalisation.

Recombination (raw_1). These are F1 phenotypes: ten virgin females of each DGRP line were crossed to ten males of a doubly marked stock, e4 ro1 (3R, 20.4 cM apart) or y1 v1 (X, 33 cM apart), both substituted into an isogenic Samarkand background. Twenty doubly heterozygous virgin F1 females were backcrossed to twenty males of the same marker stock (25°C, 12:12 h), and the BC1 progeny of both sexes were scored for the two markers. The crossover frequency of a replicate is the number of recombinant progeny (carrying only one of the two markers) divided by the number of progeny scored (about 368 per replicate for e ro and 499 for y v); double crossovers are not detected. It measures recombination in the female meiosis of the F1 (DGRP/marker) females, so only at least partially dominant effects of the DGRP genomes are seen. The values are stored under the DGRP parent line with sex F, and the cross is given by the suffix of the phenotype names: Recomb_xero and Recomb_xyv.
Three replicate assays were made per interval, each with all lines crossed at the same time. The raw dataset has one row per line and replicate assay (design column Replicate, obsolete); the e ro and y v values on one row come from different crosses. Values are proportions (0-1), as in S2 Table. The authors' line averages in cM (S2 Table, the phenotype of their GWAS) are 100 x the DGRPool line means, which reproduce them for every line (difference below 1e-13 cM). Missing replicates (blank in S2 Table) are NA. DGRP_189 has no data at all (also no progeny in S1 Table) and is not in the dataset, so 204 lines have data: 204 for e ro and 202 for y v (none for DGRP_256 and DGRP_812).

Of note:
- 49 lines carry an inversion on 3R (In(3R)P, K, Mo or C) that spans at least part of the e ro interval. In the F1 females it suppresses crossing over in the interval (median 7.9 cM, 22 of these lines below 5 cM). The authors excluded these lines from all their e ro analyses (GWAS on 156, 130 or 112 lines), but their values are in S2 Table and are uploaded. Two lines without an annotated 3R inversion also have very low e ro values: DGRP_028 (no recombinant among 714 progeny) and DGRP_239 (5.6 cM, standard karyotype).
- The paper's mean and range for the 112 lines with a standard karyotype (e ro: 20.9 ± 0.2 cM, 14.2 to 26.12 cM; y v: 31.2 ± 0.3 cM, 23.6 to 39.30 cM) are reproduced exactly from S2 Table when DGRP_239 (e ro) and DGRP_705 (y v, 12.5 cM, from replicates of 0.19 and 0.06) are left out; with them, the means are 20.8 and 31.0 cM. The line ANOVA F values of the text (1.34 and 3.00) are reproduced with all standard-karyotype lines, with one or two more degrees of freedom than in Table 1. The Wolbachia effect on y v is reproduced (31.8 vs 30.0 cM in infected vs uninfected standard lines); the means of the interchromosomal-effect test are not reproduced exactly (y v: 34.4 vs 31.0 cM in lines with any inversion vs standard lines; the paper gives 35.1 vs 31.0 cM).
- S1 Table (pgen.1005951.s009.xlsx) gives, per line, the progeny counts summed over the 3 replicates (males, females, the two parental and the two recombinant classes, with G-tests). It was used for checks only, since S2 Table has the per-replicate values. Its totals (211,534 progeny for e ro and 288,774 for y v) differ from those of the paper (217,525 and 288,520), and for DGRP_589, DGRP_786 and DGRP_820 the e ro males + females exceed the sum of the four marker classes (by 12, 5 and 5).

Ovarian qPCR (raw_2): for each of 20 candidate genes of the GWAS, 3 DGRP lines with the major allele and 3 with the minor allele of the associated variant(s) were chosen (S17 Table; 120 different lines, each used for one gene only). Ovaries were dissected from virgin females aged 3 days in vials with yeast paste, in 4 biological replicates of 10 pairs of ovaries per line, and each RNA sample was run in 4 qPCR wells (SYBR Green, Bio-Rad CFX384). The raw dataset has one row per well, with the design columns BioRep (1-4) and TechRep (wells A-D coded 1-4), both obsolete; each line has values only in the two columns of its gene:
- Cq_<gene>: quantification cycle of the gene before normalisation (S20 Table). A lower Cq means more mRNA.
- CqRel_<gene>: the same Cq divided by the mean GAPDH Cq of the line, the authors' normalisation (S19 Table). The GAPDH Cq values are not published, but the ratio of the two tables gives the mean GAPDH Cq of each line (20.3 to 28.6).
Hyphens are removed from gene names (bru-2 is bru2). The group means, standard errors and counts of S19 and S20 Tables are reproduced from these values, and Student's t-tests of the major vs minor allele wells reproduce the published P-values within rounding, except for the normalised lola values (P = 0.084 vs 0.0418 published, so lola is not significant from S19 Table) and small differences for cdi and CG10864. The paper describes the genes whose major-allele lines have the larger normalised Cq (CG4440, CG15365, CG33970, Ptp61F) as having the higher expression; since a larger Cq means less mRNA, these statements, and the opposite ones for the 7 other significant genes, appear inverted.
Also of note, in S19 Table: DGRP_730 (bru-2, minor allele) has no normalised value; for DGRP_382 (pk, minor allele) the normalised values are not proportional to the Cq of S20 Table (the implied GAPDH Cq varies from 19.6 to 25.3 within the line, while it is constant within every other line); and 7 single wells have a Cq but no normalised value. All values are kept as published.

Not uploaded: the DGRP inversion and Wolbachia annotations of S2 Table; the GWAS results (S6-S14 Tables); the genotypes of the qPCR lines (S18 Table); and the recombination rates of the P-element insertions, deletions and RNAi lines used to test the candidate genes (S15 and S16 Tables; not DGRP lines).

204 DGRP lines 204 genotyped

DGRP_021 DGRP_026 DGRP_028 DGRP_031 DGRP_032 DGRP_038 DGRP_040 DGRP_041 DGRP_042 DGRP_045 DGRP_048 DGRP_049 DGRP_057 DGRP_059 DGRP_069 DGRP_073 DGRP_075 DGRP_083 DGRP_085 DGRP_088 DGRP_091 DGRP_093 DGRP_100 DGRP_101 DGRP_105 DGRP_109 DGRP_129 DGRP_136 DGRP_138 DGRP_142 DGRP_149 DGRP_153 DGRP_158 DGRP_161 DGRP_176 DGRP_177 DGRP_181 DGRP_195 DGRP_208 DGRP_217 DGRP_223 DGRP_227 DGRP_228 DGRP_229 DGRP_233 DGRP_235 DGRP_237 DGRP_239 DGRP_256 DGRP_280 DGRP_287 DGRP_301 DGRP_303 DGRP_304 DGRP_306 DGRP_307 DGRP_309 DGRP_310 DGRP_313 DGRP_315 DGRP_317 DGRP_318 DGRP_319 DGRP_320 DGRP_321 DGRP_324 DGRP_325 DGRP_332 DGRP_335 DGRP_336 DGRP_338 DGRP_340 DGRP_348 DGRP_350 DGRP_352 DGRP_354 DGRP_355 DGRP_356 DGRP_357 DGRP_358 DGRP_359 DGRP_360 DGRP_361 DGRP_362 DGRP_365 DGRP_367 DGRP_370 DGRP_371 DGRP_373 DGRP_374 DGRP_375 DGRP_377 DGRP_379 DGRP_380 DGRP_381 DGRP_382 DGRP_383 DGRP_385 DGRP_386 DGRP_390 DGRP_391 DGRP_392 DGRP_395 DGRP_397 DGRP_399 DGRP_405 DGRP_406 DGRP_409 DGRP_426 DGRP_427 DGRP_437 DGRP_439 DGRP_440 DGRP_441 DGRP_443 DGRP_461 DGRP_486 DGRP_491 DGRP_492 DGRP_502 DGRP_505 DGRP_508 DGRP_509 DGRP_513 DGRP_517 DGRP_528 DGRP_530 DGRP_531 DGRP_535 DGRP_551 DGRP_555 DGRP_559 DGRP_563 DGRP_566 DGRP_584 DGRP_589 DGRP_595 DGRP_596 DGRP_627 DGRP_630 DGRP_634 DGRP_639 DGRP_642 DGRP_646 DGRP_703 DGRP_705 DGRP_707 DGRP_712 DGRP_714 DGRP_716 DGRP_721 DGRP_727 DGRP_730 DGRP_732 DGRP_737 DGRP_738 DGRP_748 DGRP_757 DGRP_761 DGRP_765 DGRP_774 DGRP_776 DGRP_783 DGRP_786 DGRP_787 DGRP_790 DGRP_796 DGRP_799 DGRP_801 DGRP_802 DGRP_804 DGRP_805 DGRP_808 DGRP_810 DGRP_812 DGRP_818 DGRP_819 DGRP_820 DGRP_821 DGRP_822 DGRP_832 DGRP_837 DGRP_843 DGRP_849 DGRP_850 DGRP_852 DGRP_853 DGRP_855 DGRP_857 DGRP_859 DGRP_861 DGRP_879 DGRP_882 DGRP_884 DGRP_887 DGRP_890 DGRP_892 DGRP_894 DGRP_897 DGRP_900 DGRP_907 DGRP_908 DGRP_911 DGRP_913

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 2 phenotypes
Recomb_xero Recomb_xyv
204 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_028
DGRP_031
DGRP_032
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_041
DGRP_042
DGRP_045
DGRP_048
DGRP_049
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_069
DGRP_073
DGRP_075
DGRP_083
DGRP_085
DGRP_088
DGRP_091
DGRP_093
DGRP_100
DGRP_101
DGRP_105
DGRP_109
DGRP_129
DGRP_136
DGRP_138
DGRP_142
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_158
DGRP_161
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_181
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_217
DGRP_223
DGRP_227
DGRP_228
DGRP_229
DGRP_233
DGRP_235
DGRP_237
DGRP_239
DGRP_256
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_301
DGRP_303
DGRP_304
DGRP_306
DGRP_307
DGRP_309
DGRP_310
DGRP_313
DGRP_315
DGRP_317
DGRP_318
DGRP_319
DGRP_320
DGRP_321
DGRP_324
DGRP_325
DGRP_332
DGRP_335
DGRP_336
DGRP_338
DGRP_340
DGRP_348
DGRP_350
DGRP_352
DGRP_354
DGRP_355
DGRP_356
DGRP_357
DGRP_358
DGRP_359
DGRP_360
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_370
DGRP_371
DGRP_373
DGRP_374
DGRP_375
DGRP_377
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_381
DGRP_382
DGRP_383
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_390
DGRP_391
DGRP_392
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_399
DGRP_405
DGRP_406
DGRP_409
DGRP_426
DGRP_427
DGRP_437
DGRP_439
DGRP_440
DGRP_441
DGRP_443
DGRP_461
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_492
DGRP_502
DGRP_505
DGRP_508
DGRP_509
DGRP_513
DGRP_517
DGRP_528
DGRP_530
DGRP_531
DGRP_535
DGRP_551
DGRP_555
DGRP_559
DGRP_563
DGRP_566
DGRP_584
DGRP_589
DGRP_595
DGRP_596
DGRP_627
DGRP_630
DGRP_634
DGRP_639
DGRP_642
DGRP_646
DGRP_703
DGRP_705
DGRP_707
DGRP_712
DGRP_714
DGRP_716
DGRP_721
DGRP_727
DGRP_730
DGRP_732
DGRP_737
DGRP_738
DGRP_748
DGRP_757
DGRP_761
DGRP_765
DGRP_774
DGRP_776
DGRP_783
DGRP_786
DGRP_787
DGRP_790
DGRP_796
DGRP_799
DGRP_801
DGRP_802
DGRP_804
DGRP_805
DGRP_808
DGRP_810
DGRP_812
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_820
DGRP_821
DGRP_822
DGRP_832
DGRP_837
DGRP_843
DGRP_849
DGRP_850
DGRP_852
DGRP_853
DGRP_855
DGRP_857
DGRP_859
DGRP_861
DGRP_879
DGRP_882
DGRP_884
DGRP_887
DGRP_890
DGRP_892
DGRP_894
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_907
DGRP_908
DGRP_911
DGRP_913
Download
Raw dataset #2 40 phenotypes
CqRel_CG10864 CqRel_CG1273 CqRel_CG15365 CqRel_CG33970 CqRel_CG4440 CqRel_CG7196 CqRel_CG9650 CqRel_Eip75B CqRel_MESR3 CqRel_Oaz CqRel_Ptp61F CqRel_Ubx CqRel_alph CqRel_bru2 CqRel_cdi CqRel_dpr6 CqRel_grp CqRel_jing CqRel_lola CqRel_pk Cq_CG10864 Cq_CG1273 Cq_CG15365 Cq_CG33970 Cq_CG4440 Cq_CG7196 Cq_CG9650 Cq_Eip75B Cq_MESR3 Cq_Oaz Cq_Ptp61F Cq_Ubx Cq_alph Cq_bru2 Cq_cdi Cq_dpr6 Cq_grp Cq_jing Cq_lola Cq_pk
120 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_040
DGRP_041
DGRP_042
DGRP_045
DGRP_049
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_073
DGRP_075
DGRP_083
DGRP_091
DGRP_101
DGRP_129
DGRP_142
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_158
DGRP_161
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_181
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_217
DGRP_223
DGRP_227
DGRP_228
DGRP_229
DGRP_233
DGRP_235
DGRP_239
DGRP_256
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_301
DGRP_304
DGRP_306
DGRP_307
DGRP_310
DGRP_315
DGRP_318
DGRP_319
DGRP_320
DGRP_321
DGRP_332
DGRP_340
DGRP_354
DGRP_355
DGRP_356
DGRP_357
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_370
DGRP_371
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_382
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_391
DGRP_392
DGRP_395
DGRP_399
DGRP_406
DGRP_427
DGRP_439
DGRP_441
DGRP_461
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_505
DGRP_508
DGRP_509
DGRP_513
DGRP_517
DGRP_530
DGRP_531
DGRP_535
DGRP_589
DGRP_596
DGRP_639
DGRP_703
DGRP_705
DGRP_716
DGRP_727
DGRP_730
DGRP_737
DGRP_757
DGRP_761
DGRP_765
DGRP_774
DGRP_783
DGRP_787
DGRP_790
DGRP_796
DGRP_799
DGRP_801
DGRP_804
DGRP_805
DGRP_808
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_822
DGRP_832
DGRP_843
DGRP_850
DGRP_853
DGRP_859
DGRP_879
DGRP_882
DGRP_887
DGRP_890
DGRP_892
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_911
Download
Back to studies