Study

Curated
Champer et al., 2019
CRISPR Gene Drive Efficiency and Resistance Rate Is Highly Heritable with No Common Genetic Loci of Large Effect
[10.1534/genetics.119.302037][FBrf0242214]

Description

Performance of a CRISPR homing gene drive targeting yellow (drive conversion, embryo resistance and mosaicism, male wild-type rate) was measured in the background of 138 DGRP lines (F1 crosses, 856 vials). Embryo resistance varied over 10-fold, but GWAS found no common locus of large effect.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the Supplemental Material on GSA figshare (file Supplemental Material for Champer et al, 2019.xlsx):
- Data S2 (DGRP Vial Totals): the counts of each progeny phenotype class and the drive parameters for each of the 856 vials, used for raw dataset 1.
- Data S3 (White Drive): the same values for the drive targeting white, tested in 3 DGRP lines (5 vials each), used for raw dataset 2 (phenotype names suffixed _wD).
- Data S1 (DGRP Line Totals): the drive parameters per DGRP line, as published by the authors, used for the summary dataset (mn_*Auth phenotypes).

Cross design: the drive parameters are not measured on the DGRP lines themselves. Males carrying a CRISPR homing drive at the X-linked yellow locus (nanos-Cas9, 3xP3-dsRed, w1118 background) were crossed to virgin females of each DGRP line. Their F1 progeny (drive/wild-type heterozygous females and wild-type males, each carrying one DGRP genome and one w1118 genome) were mated together and placed into four to six vials per line (more for the 30 lines tested in several rounds), and the progeny of that second cross were scored for dsRed, yellow body and white eyes. Each value therefore describes the germline and the early embryos of F1 drive heterozygote females, and is assigned here to the DGRP mother line, as in the authors' GWAS.

One row = one vial. The sex is NA because every vial holds progeny of both sexes, and each rate is computed from the male progeny (MaleWTRate), the female progeny (EmbryoR2Rate, EmbryoMosaic, EmbryoR2Adj50, MosaicDiff) or all of them (DriveConvRate). The 12 progeny counts and the vial total (n_*), the experimental round and the vial number were kept as obsolete phenotypes, so that every rate can be traced back to the counts it was computed from.

EmbryoR2Rate, EmbryoMosaic and EmbryoR2Adj50 are exactly reproduced by the published formulas from the counts of the same row (856/856 vials and 138/138 lines). DriveConvRate and MaleWTRate are not: no combination of the published progeny counts gives the published values, which differ from the recomputed ones by +0.019 on average for the drive conversion rate (r = 0.975 over the 138 lines) and by -0.005 for the male wild-type rate (r = 0.986). The authors' values were kept as published, since those are the values they analysed.

Summary dataset. The line values of Data S1 are computed from the progeny counts pooled over all the vials of a line, not as the mean of the vial values: they differ from the means DGRPool computes from raw dataset 1 (no line matches exactly for five of the six parameters, 2 of 138 for MaleWTRate; up to 0.16 for EmbryoMosaic). They are therefore kept as a separate summary dataset (mn_*Auth), and the pooled counts of Data S1 are the sums of the vial counts of Data S2 (all lines except DGRP_818, see below).

Data S1 and S2 hold 138 DGRP lines, while the paper repeatedly says that 128 lines were phenotyped and used for the GWAS; 129 of the 138 lines are genotyped in DGRP2. All 138 lines are uploaded. The mean progeny per line (438 males and 402 females) and the ranges given in the paper (drive conversion 28.2-71.7%, embryo r2 7.2-79.4%, male wild-type 7 ± 4%) are reproduced from Data S1 over the 138 lines.

Oddities in the source, kept as published: the Total column excludes the mosaic males (n_m_M); for DGRP_804 vial 3 it is 1 higher than the sum of the counts of that row; the Data S1 counts of DGRP_818 differ from the sum of its Data S2 vials by a few flies in 8 of the 12 classes; and the experimental round and vial number do not identify a vial uniquely for DGRP_280, where 14 vials share the round label "280" and the vial numbers 1 to 5 are used up to three times. The only value that was changed is MaleWTRate for the one vial without male progeny (DGRP_502, round 502r2, vial 5), printed as 0 by the authors and set to NA here because the rate is undefined.

Data S4 and S5 are the GWAS hit tables, and Data S6 holds the shRNA knockdown experiments, which use TRiP and VDRC lines and not DGRP lines: neither was uploaded.

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 6 phenotypes
mn_DriveConvRateAuth mn_EmbryoMosaicAuth mn_EmbryoR2Adj50Auth mn_EmbryoR2RateAuth mn_MaleWTRateAuth mn_MosaicDiffAuth
138 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_045
DGRP_049
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_069
DGRP_080
DGRP_083
DGRP_085
DGRP_088
DGRP_091
DGRP_101
DGRP_105
DGRP_109
DGRP_129
DGRP_136
DGRP_138
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_161
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_181
DGRP_208
DGRP_223
DGRP_228
DGRP_235
DGRP_237
DGRP_239
DGRP_272
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_304
DGRP_309
DGRP_310
DGRP_317
DGRP_318
DGRP_319
DGRP_321
DGRP_336
DGRP_338
DGRP_350
DGRP_352
DGRP_356
DGRP_357
DGRP_358
DGRP_360
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_370
DGRP_373
DGRP_374
DGRP_377
DGRP_380
DGRP_381
DGRP_383
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_387
DGRP_391
DGRP_392
DGRP_393
DGRP_398
DGRP_399
DGRP_405
DGRP_406
DGRP_409
DGRP_427
DGRP_437
DGRP_440
DGRP_441
DGRP_443
DGRP_461
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_492
DGRP_502
DGRP_508
DGRP_513
DGRP_514
DGRP_535
DGRP_554
DGRP_555
DGRP_563
DGRP_584
DGRP_589
DGRP_595
DGRP_639
DGRP_642
DGRP_703
DGRP_705
DGRP_707
DGRP_712
DGRP_714
DGRP_716
DGRP_727
DGRP_732
DGRP_737
DGRP_738
DGRP_748
DGRP_750
DGRP_761
DGRP_771
DGRP_774
DGRP_776
DGRP_786
DGRP_787
DGRP_790
DGRP_796
DGRP_802
DGRP_804
DGRP_808
DGRP_810
DGRP_812
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_820
DGRP_821
DGRP_822
DGRP_832
DGRP_843
DGRP_849
DGRP_850
DGRP_853
DGRP_855
DGRP_859
DGRP_861
DGRP_892
DGRP_894
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_907
DGRP_913
Download
Raw dataset #1 6 phenotypes
DriveConvRate EmbryoMosaic EmbryoR2Adj50 EmbryoR2Rate MaleWTRate MosaicDiff
138 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_045
DGRP_049
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_069
DGRP_080
DGRP_083
DGRP_085
DGRP_088
DGRP_091
DGRP_101
DGRP_105
DGRP_109
DGRP_129
DGRP_136
DGRP_138
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_161
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_181
DGRP_208
DGRP_223
DGRP_228
DGRP_235
DGRP_237
DGRP_239
DGRP_272
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_304
DGRP_309
DGRP_310
DGRP_317
DGRP_318
DGRP_319
DGRP_321
DGRP_336
DGRP_338
DGRP_350
DGRP_352
DGRP_356
DGRP_357
DGRP_358
DGRP_360
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_370
DGRP_373
DGRP_374
DGRP_377
DGRP_380
DGRP_381
DGRP_383
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_387
DGRP_391
DGRP_392
DGRP_393
DGRP_398
DGRP_399
DGRP_405
DGRP_406
DGRP_409
DGRP_427
DGRP_437
DGRP_440
DGRP_441
DGRP_443
DGRP_461
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_492
DGRP_502
DGRP_508
DGRP_513
DGRP_514
DGRP_535
DGRP_554
DGRP_555
DGRP_563
DGRP_584
DGRP_589
DGRP_595
DGRP_639
DGRP_642
DGRP_703
DGRP_705
DGRP_707
DGRP_712
DGRP_714
DGRP_716
DGRP_727
DGRP_732
DGRP_737
DGRP_738
DGRP_748
DGRP_750
DGRP_761
DGRP_771
DGRP_774
DGRP_776
DGRP_786
DGRP_787
DGRP_790
DGRP_796
DGRP_802
DGRP_804
DGRP_808
DGRP_810
DGRP_812
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_820
DGRP_821
DGRP_822
DGRP_832
DGRP_843
DGRP_849
DGRP_850
DGRP_853
DGRP_855
DGRP_859
DGRP_861
DGRP_892
DGRP_894
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_907
DGRP_913
Download
Raw dataset #2 6 phenotypes
DriveConvRate_wD EmbryoMosaic_wD EmbryoR2Adj50_wD EmbryoR2Rate_wD MaleWTRate_wD MosaicDiff_wD
3 DGRP lines
DGRP_392
DGRP_409
DGRP_900
Download
Back to studies