Study

Curated
Rzezniczak et al., 2023
Regulation at Drosophila’s Malic Enzyme highlights the complexity of transvection and its sensitivity to genetic background
[10.1093/genetics/iyac181]

Description

Malic enzyme (MEN) activity was measured on F1 males from crosses of 150 DGRP lines to three Men excision lines (wild-type MenEx3, promoter deletions MenEx76 and MenEx86) to quantify transvection, which varied widely with the genetic background.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the authors' repository, cited in the paper's Data availability (GitHub DworkinLab/TR2022_TransvectionDataScripts, static copy on figshare):
- data/transvection_rawdata_other.csv: MEN activity of each biological sample (4,248 samples: block, box, Men allele, DGRP line, weight, number of flies, 1-3 technical replicate activities and their average), used for the raw dataset.
- data/transvection_rawdata.csv: the same samples and activities without weight and number of flies, used by the authors for their quantitative genetic analyses (its block numbers differ, see below).
- misc/MenEx_DGRP_conditionalMeans.csv, misc/Men_76_ratio_post.csv and misc/Men_86_ratio_post.csv: per-line conditional means and relative MEN activities from the authors' mixed model, used for the summary dataset.

These are F1 phenotypes, not phenotypes of the inbred DGRP lines: five males of each DGRP line were crossed to five females of each of three lines carrying a P-element excision allele of Malic enzyme (Men) in the same background (w; 6326; MenEx/TM8): MenEx3 (precise excision, wild-type MEN activity), MenEx76 (669 bp deletion) and MenEx86 (2,239 bp deletion), both removing the promoter (no MEN activity). MEN activity was measured on the F1 males (w/Y; 6326/DGRP; MenEx/DGRP), whose X chromosome comes from the tester mother. With MenEx76 and MenEx86, only the DGRP Men allele is expressed, and its activity relative to the MenEx3 cross of the same line measures transvection (pairing-dependent regulation by the homologous chromosome): 50% of the MenEx3 activity means no transvection. Each value is stored under the DGRP father line, and the cross is given in the phenotype names (_xMenEx3, _xMenEx76, _xMenEx86).

Raw dataset: one row per biological sample (about 4 F1 males aged 3-5 days, frozen at −80 °C and homogenized at one fly per 100 µL of buffer), sex M. Most crosses have 10 samples (1 to 11). The three crosses are independent samples stacked in the same rows (row k of a line holds the k-th sample of each cross, ordered by block).
- MEN_xMenEx3, MEN_xMenEx76, MEN_xMenEx86: MEN activity of the sample (10 µL of homogenate in 100 µL of assay buffer with malate, NADP+ and MnCl2; absorbance at 340 nm every 9 s for 3 min at 25 °C). The value is the authors' average of the technical replicates (independent aliquots of the same homogenate: 2 for most samples, 3 for 215, only 1 for 122, although the paper says at least two). The paper expresses activity as "optical density (OD) units per min", but the values (3.6 to 28 over a 3-min read) can only be milli-OD units per min, hence the unit mOD/min.
- Weight_xMenEx3/76/86: weight of the pooled flies of the sample (mg; the unit is not stated, about 0.84 mg per fly). It is in the authors' file but not used in the paper.
- NFlies_xMenEx3/76/86 (obsolete): number of flies in the sample (4 for 87% of the samples, 2 to 5).
- Block_xMenEx3/76/86 (obsolete): experimental block (1-50) as numbered in transvection_rawdata_other.csv, where each block is one storage box. In transvection_rawdata.csv (the file of the authors' analyses), blocks 41-50 are numbered 40-49 (so its block 40 holds two boxes), and the block of 3 MenEx3 samples of DGRP_765 is missing, so the authors' model dropped these 3 samples. They are included here.

Summary dataset (the authors' per-line values, sex M), from their mixed model fitted with MCMCglmm to all samples and technical replicates (fixed effect: Men allele; random effects: block, DGRP line by allele with an unstructured 3 × 3 covariance, biological sample by allele; residual variance by allele):
- mn_MENAuth_xMenEx3/76/86: posterior mean of the conditional mean MEN activity of the line in each cross (mOD/min). The means computed by DGRPool from the raw dataset differ (r = 0.92 to 0.95 with these, differences up to 3.4 mOD/min), because the model adjusts for block and shrinks the line effects.
- mn_RelMEN_xMenEx76 and mn_RelMEN_xMenEx86: relative MEN activity, the paper's measure of transvection (Fig. 4a): posterior mean of the ratio of the line's conditional mean in the MenEx76 (or MenEx86) cross to that in the MenEx3 cross. 0.5 means no transvection, more than 0.5 pairing-dependent up-regulation, 1 a full rescue of wild-type activity. The paper's "transvection value" (Fig. 5) is 2 × relative MEN activity − 1. The 95% HPD intervals of the ratios are in the source files and were not uploaded.
These values reproduce the paper: relative MEN activity from 0.39 to 0.99 (MenEx76) and 0.35 to 0.96 (MenEx86), as in the text ("39 to 99%", "35 to 96%"); transvection value above 0.1 for 94.0% and 83.3% of the lines (paper: 94% and 84%); about +1 for DGRP_392, DGRP_555 and DGRP_705 with MenEx76 and DGRP_555 and DGRP_730 with MenEx86 (paper: three and two lines, DGRP555 in both); 23 lines without transvection (value within ±0.1) in at least one data set (paper: 23), 6 in both (paper: 7); correlation between the MenEx76 and MenEx86 conditional means r = 0.86 (paper: 0.86).

The authors' GWAS (PLINK, 2,778,429 SNPs with MAF ≥ 2%) used the MenEx76 and MenEx86 conditional means as phenotypes, with the MenEx3 conditional mean, two nonsynonymous Men SNPs, Wolbachia status and 5 inversion and 5 genomic principal components as covariates. Their GWAS input files (data/pheno_men76.txt, data/pheno_men86.txt, data/covar_mengwas.txt) come from another run of the same MCMC model: these conditional means differ from the uploaded ones by at most 0.10 mOD/min (r ≥ 0.9998), and they exclude DGRP_730.

Lines: the data hold 150 DGRP lines; the paper mentions 149 lines (and 150 once). DGRP_730 has no MenEx76 sample (3 MenEx3 and 2 MenEx86 samples): its MenEx76 conditional mean and relative activity in the source files are model predictions without data (16.3 and 0.95), so they were set to NA. Its other values were kept.

Of note, the paper says that DGRP721 had a transvection value of +0.06 with MenEx76 and +0.55 with MenEx86; the source files give the reverse (+0.54 with MenEx76, +0.06 with MenEx86). The other lines cited in the text (e.g. DGRP309, DGRP357, DGRP757, DGRP884) agree with the files.

Not uploaded: the GWAS covariates (DGRP annotations: Wolbachia, inversions, Men SNPs, genomic PCs) and the GWAS results. Paper: Genetics 223(2):iyac181 (PMC version).

Other external data available

10.6084/m9.figshare.21605598 static copy of the authors' GitHub repository DworkinLab/TR2022_TransvectionDataScripts (MEN activity per sample, per-line conditional means and ratios, GWAS input files, analysis scripts)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 5 phenotypes
mn_MENAuth_xMenEx3 mn_MENAuth_xMenEx76 mn_MENAuth_xMenEx86 mn_RelMEN_xMenEx76 mn_RelMEN_xMenEx86
150 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_028
DGRP_031
DGRP_032
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_045
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_069
DGRP_075
DGRP_083
DGRP_085
DGRP_088
DGRP_091
DGRP_093
DGRP_100
DGRP_101
DGRP_105
DGRP_109
DGRP_129
DGRP_136
DGRP_142
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_181
DGRP_189
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_217
DGRP_228
DGRP_235
DGRP_237
DGRP_239
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_301
DGRP_303
DGRP_304
DGRP_306
DGRP_307
DGRP_309
DGRP_310
DGRP_313
DGRP_315
DGRP_317
DGRP_318
DGRP_319
DGRP_320
DGRP_324
DGRP_335
DGRP_336
DGRP_338
DGRP_350
DGRP_357
DGRP_358
DGRP_359
DGRP_360
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_370
DGRP_373
DGRP_374
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_383
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_390
DGRP_391
DGRP_392
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_399
DGRP_405
DGRP_406
DGRP_426
DGRP_427
DGRP_437
DGRP_439
DGRP_440
DGRP_441
DGRP_443
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_502
DGRP_517
DGRP_528
DGRP_530
DGRP_531
DGRP_535
DGRP_551
DGRP_555
DGRP_559
DGRP_563
DGRP_584
DGRP_630
DGRP_639
DGRP_703
DGRP_705
DGRP_707
DGRP_712
DGRP_714
DGRP_716
DGRP_721
DGRP_730
DGRP_732
DGRP_737
DGRP_738
DGRP_748
DGRP_757
DGRP_765
DGRP_774
DGRP_776
DGRP_783
DGRP_786
DGRP_790
DGRP_796
DGRP_799
DGRP_802
DGRP_808
DGRP_810
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_820
DGRP_822
DGRP_837
DGRP_843
DGRP_849
DGRP_850
DGRP_852
DGRP_853
DGRP_855
DGRP_857
DGRP_859
DGRP_861
DGRP_879
DGRP_882
DGRP_884
DGRP_890
DGRP_894
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_907
DGRP_908
DGRP_911
Download
Raw dataset #1 6 phenotypes
MEN_xMenEx3 MEN_xMenEx76 MEN_xMenEx86 Weight_xMenEx3 Weight_xMenEx76 Weight_xMenEx86
150 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_028
DGRP_031
DGRP_032
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_045
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_069
DGRP_075
DGRP_083
DGRP_085
DGRP_088
DGRP_091
DGRP_093
DGRP_100
DGRP_101
DGRP_105
DGRP_109
DGRP_129
DGRP_136
DGRP_142
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_181
DGRP_189
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_217
DGRP_228
DGRP_235
DGRP_237
DGRP_239
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_301
DGRP_303
DGRP_304
DGRP_306
DGRP_307
DGRP_309
DGRP_310
DGRP_313
DGRP_315
DGRP_317
DGRP_318
DGRP_319
DGRP_320
DGRP_324
DGRP_335
DGRP_336
DGRP_338
DGRP_350
DGRP_357
DGRP_358
DGRP_359
DGRP_360
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_370
DGRP_373
DGRP_374
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_383
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_390
DGRP_391
DGRP_392
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_399
DGRP_405
DGRP_406
DGRP_426
DGRP_427
DGRP_437
DGRP_439
DGRP_440
DGRP_441
DGRP_443
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_502
DGRP_517
DGRP_528
DGRP_530
DGRP_531
DGRP_535
DGRP_551
DGRP_555
DGRP_559
DGRP_563
DGRP_584
DGRP_630
DGRP_639
DGRP_703
DGRP_705
DGRP_707
DGRP_712
DGRP_714
DGRP_716
DGRP_721
DGRP_730
DGRP_732
DGRP_737
DGRP_738
DGRP_748
DGRP_757
DGRP_765
DGRP_774
DGRP_776
DGRP_783
DGRP_786
DGRP_790
DGRP_796
DGRP_799
DGRP_802
DGRP_808
DGRP_810
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_820
DGRP_822
DGRP_837
DGRP_843
DGRP_849
DGRP_850
DGRP_852
DGRP_853
DGRP_855
DGRP_857
DGRP_859
DGRP_861
DGRP_879
DGRP_882
DGRP_884
DGRP_890
DGRP_894
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_907
DGRP_908
DGRP_911
Download
Back to studies