Study

Curated
Zwoinska et al., 2020
Phenotypic Responses to and Genetic Architecture of Sterility Following Exposure to Sub-Lethal Temperature During Development
[10.3389/fgene.2020.00573]

Description

Fertility (presence of larvae after pairing with Canton-S) of DGRP flies developed at 25, 27 or 29 °C was measured for males of 127 lines and females of 40 lines. Development at 29 °C strongly reduced male fertility, and female fertility much less.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data come from the authors' Figshare deposit (10.17045/sthlmuni.12248576.v1), which holds the same data as Supplementary Table S1 of the paper (Supplementary Material, Data Sheet 1):
- Zwoinska20_malerawdata.csv and Zwoinska20_femalerawdata.csv (tabs "Male data raw" and "Femal data raw"): one row per focal DGRP fly, used for raw dataset 1.
- Zwoinska20_maledata.csv (tab "Male data"): per-line counts, and the line intercepts and slopes of the authors' model, used for the summary dataset.
- Zwoinska20_femaledata.csv (tab "Female data"): per-line counts of the female experiment, used for checks only.

Design: groups of about 50 eggs of each DGRP line developed at a constant 25, 27 or 29 °C (12:12 h light:dark, cornmeal medium). Virgin focal flies were then kept singly at 25 °C, and the day after eclosion each one was paired for 3 days with a virgin Canton-S (CS) fly of the opposite sex (reared at 25 °C, 3-6 days old). The vial was scored 2 days after the pair was removed: the focal fly was fertile if at least one larva was present. Males of 127 lines were tested in 13 blocks of 7-11 lines (each line in a single block, with its three temperatures), on average 24.8 males per line and temperature (median 28). Females of 40 of these lines were then tested in 3 blocks of 12-15 lines (on average 27.4 females per line and temperature): 19 "high" lines, whose males were fertile at all temperatures, and 21 "low" lines, whose male fertility dropped as temperature increased (chosen mainly from the male response at 29 °C and the slope below).
- High lines: DGRP_059, 075, 208, 228, 237, 256, 320, 356, 360, 362, 374, 390, 439, 559, 584, 630, 732, 855, 859.
- Low lines: DGRP_021, 109, 138, 149, 195, 229, 235, 280, 301, 319, 338, 365, 409, 502, 530, 627, 808, 818, 819, 820, 900.
This line status is a classification derived from the male phenotypes, so it was not uploaded.

Raw dataset 1 (9,219 males and 3,287 females): one value per focal fly, i.e. per pair kept in one vial. The sex column is the sex of the focal DGRP fly (M = male experiment, F = female experiment); its partner was a Canton-S fly. Fertility_25C, Fertility_27C and Fertility_29C are 1 if larvae were present and 0 if not (column Larvae), for flies developed at 25, 27 or 29 °C, so the DGRPool mean of a line is its proportion of fertile flies. The three temperatures are independent groups of flies: values on the same row but in different temperature columns come from different flies (row k of a line and sex holds the k-th vial of each temperature). Block (column Batch: 1-13 in the male experiment, 1-3 in the female experiment) is kept as an obsolete design phenotype. The vial numbers of the files were not uploaded (they are not unique within a line and temperature). 396 male vials without a score (Larvae = NA) were left out, as in the authors' per-line counts. The Canton-S controls (tested at 25 and 29 °C in each block to monitor block effects; tabs "Canton S male data" and "Canton S female data") are not DGRP lines and were not uploaded.

The means computed by DGRPool from this dataset reproduce the authors' per-line counts (fertile flies / flies tested) for all 120 female line × temperature combinations and for 370 of the 372 male ones. Two male combinations differ and are kept as in the raw file: DGRP_319 at 29 °C has 3 fertile males of 28 in the raw file but 1 of 26 in the per-line table (proportion 0.107 vs 0.038), and DGRP_235 at 25 °C has 30 of 30 vs 29 of 29 (same proportion). Nine male line × temperature combinations have no data in either file (DGRP_038, 083, 395 and 707 at 29 °C, DGRP_727 at 27 and 29 °C, DGRP_897 at 27 °C, DGRP_911 at 25 and 27 °C). DGRP_356 has about twice the usual number of females (58-60 per temperature, vial numbers 1-30 used twice), and so does DGRP_338 at 29 °C (57), as in the authors' per-line table.

Summary dataset (males, 127 lines, copied as published in Zwoinska20_maledata.csv):
- mn_FertIntercept_25C, mn_FertIntercept_27C and mn_FertIntercept_29C: the line's fertility at that developmental temperature on the logit scale.
- mn_FertSlope_25to29: the change in logit fertility per °C between 25 and 29 °C (thermal plasticity; negative = fertility decreases as temperature increases).
They are the line-specific coefficients (fixed effect + line random effect, coef() in lme4) of the authors' binomial random-slope model cbind(fertile, sterile) ~ Temperature + (1|Block) + (Temperature|DGRP line), with temperature as a continuous variable centred on 25, 27 or 29 °C. They were the phenotypes of the authors' GWAS (GMMAT, with Wolbachia status and five major inversions as covariates), in which no variant passed the genome-wide threshold. Refitting this model on the authors' per-line counts reproduces the published values for all 127 lines (max |diff| 1.1e-4); a refit on counts from the raw file differs only for DGRP_319 (e.g. intercept at 29 °C -1.06 instead of -1.49). The paper's "intercept means of 5.36, 2.87 and 0.38" and slope of -1.25 are the fixed effects of the model (Supplementary Table 3), not the averages of the line values (5.21, 2.83, 0.46 and -1.19). No such estimates were published for the females.

Not uploaded: the inversion genotypes and Wolbachia status of Zwoinska20_maledata.csv (DGRP annotations), the Canton-S data and the GWAS results (Supplementary Table 5, nominally significant variants). Supplementary Table 2 compares the male fertility of 40 high and low lines with two later blocks of a second experiment, whose data are not in this deposit. DGRPool study 58 (Rodrigues et al. 2022, same laboratory and design) measured mating success, fertility and productivity at the same three temperatures on 40 high and low lines selected from this screen.

Other external data available

10.17045/sthlmuni.12248576 Figshare deposit with the per-fly male and female fertility data and the per-line model estimates (= Supplementary Table S1)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 4 phenotypes
mn_FertIntercept_25C mn_FertIntercept_27C mn_FertIntercept_29C mn_FertSlope_25to29
127 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_031
DGRP_032
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_042
DGRP_045
DGRP_048
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_073
DGRP_075
DGRP_083
DGRP_085
DGRP_091
DGRP_101
DGRP_105
DGRP_109
DGRP_136
DGRP_138
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_181
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_217
DGRP_227
DGRP_228
DGRP_229
DGRP_235
DGRP_237
DGRP_239
DGRP_256
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_301
DGRP_303
DGRP_309
DGRP_317
DGRP_319
DGRP_320
DGRP_321
DGRP_324
DGRP_335
DGRP_336
DGRP_338
DGRP_340
DGRP_350
DGRP_352
DGRP_354
DGRP_356
DGRP_357
DGRP_359
DGRP_360
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_371
DGRP_373
DGRP_374
DGRP_375
DGRP_377
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_382
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_390
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_399
DGRP_405
DGRP_406
DGRP_409
DGRP_437
DGRP_439
DGRP_440
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_502
DGRP_517
DGRP_530
DGRP_531
DGRP_551
DGRP_555
DGRP_559
DGRP_563
DGRP_584
DGRP_627
DGRP_630
DGRP_634
DGRP_707
DGRP_714
DGRP_727
DGRP_730
DGRP_732
DGRP_737
DGRP_774
DGRP_787
DGRP_796
DGRP_801
DGRP_802
DGRP_804
DGRP_805
DGRP_808
DGRP_810
DGRP_812
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_820
DGRP_821
DGRP_822
DGRP_852
DGRP_853
DGRP_855
DGRP_857
DGRP_859
DGRP_861
DGRP_882
DGRP_890
DGRP_892
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_908
DGRP_911
Download
Raw dataset #1 3 phenotypes
Fertility_25C Fertility_27C Fertility_29C
127 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_031
DGRP_032
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_042
DGRP_045
DGRP_048
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_073
DGRP_075
DGRP_083
DGRP_085
DGRP_091
DGRP_101
DGRP_105
DGRP_109
DGRP_136
DGRP_138
DGRP_149
DGRP_153
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_181
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_217
DGRP_227
DGRP_228
DGRP_229
DGRP_235
DGRP_237
DGRP_239
DGRP_256
DGRP_280
DGRP_287
DGRP_301
DGRP_303
DGRP_309
DGRP_317
DGRP_319
DGRP_320
DGRP_321
DGRP_324
DGRP_335
DGRP_336
DGRP_338
DGRP_340
DGRP_350
DGRP_352
DGRP_354
DGRP_356
DGRP_357
DGRP_359
DGRP_360
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_371
DGRP_373
DGRP_374
DGRP_375
DGRP_377
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_382
DGRP_385
DGRP_386
DGRP_390
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_399
DGRP_405
DGRP_406
DGRP_409
DGRP_437
DGRP_439
DGRP_440
DGRP_486
DGRP_491
DGRP_502
DGRP_517
DGRP_530
DGRP_531
DGRP_551
DGRP_555
DGRP_559
DGRP_563
DGRP_584
DGRP_627
DGRP_630
DGRP_634
DGRP_707
DGRP_714
DGRP_727
DGRP_730
DGRP_732
DGRP_737
DGRP_774
DGRP_787
DGRP_796
DGRP_801
DGRP_802
DGRP_804
DGRP_805
DGRP_808
DGRP_810
DGRP_812
DGRP_818
DGRP_819
DGRP_820
DGRP_821
DGRP_822
DGRP_852
DGRP_853
DGRP_855
DGRP_857
DGRP_859
DGRP_861
DGRP_882
DGRP_890
DGRP_892
DGRP_897
DGRP_900
DGRP_908
DGRP_911
Download
Back to studies