Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from
Supplementary Table 1 of the paper (
Supplementary Material section, file Table_1.xlsx, also on
figshare): the mean critical thermal minimum (CT
min) and maximum (CT
max) of males and females of 100 DGRP lines. The lines are given as bare numbers (e.g. 208 = DGRP_208). Only these line means were published (no per-fly data, standard errors or numbers of flies), so the study has a summary dataset only.
Design: DGRP lines from Bloomington were reared at 25 °C (12:12 h light:dark, cornmeal/soy flour food) at controlled density (15 females and 10 males laying eggs for 4 days per vial); the progeny were sexed and kept in single-sex groups of 20, and were 4-9 days old when tested. Both limits were measured with a dynamic ramp until loss of motor function:
-
CTmin: about 20 males and 20 females of a line were placed together in a vertical jacketed column cooled from 25 °C to 10 °C at 0.5 °C/min, then to -10 °C at 0.25 °C/min. Flies that lost motor function fell out of the column and were collected in 0.25 °C intervals, each fly being given the upper temperature of its interval.
-
CTmax: about 18 males and 18 females were placed individually in 2 mL vials in the horizontal column, heated from 25 °C to 35 °C at 0.5 °C/min, then to 45 °C at 0.25 °C/min. CT
max is the temperature at which a fly was motionless and no longer responded to stimulus (checked every 0.2 °C).
The value of a line and sex is the mean of all flies tested in two independent cohorts: 15-44 males and 9-38 females per line for CT
min, 23-53 males and 24-51 females for CT
max.
The summary dataset has
mn_CTmin and
mn_CTmax (°C), for both sexes, as published (2 decimals). They reproduce the paper: CT
min ranges from 0.81 to 8.55 °C in males and from 2.29 to 8.64 °C in females, CT
max from 38.63 to 40.72 °C in males and from 38.51 to 40.80 °C in females; the correlation between sexes is r = 0.85 for CT
min and r = 0.52 for CT
max; and the sex-averaged CT
min and CT
max are not correlated across lines (r = 0.06), as reported. The ranges of the abstract (CT
min 1.81 to 8.60 °C, CT
max 38.74 to 40.64 °C) are those of the averages of the two sexes. The authors' GWAS (DGRP2 web server, both sexes, average mixed P-value) used these line means; the server removed DGRP_208, so the GWAS had 99 lines. DGRP_208 is uploaded. The broad-sense heritabilities (0.25 for CT
min, 0.29 for CT
max) were estimated from per-fly data that were not published.
Of note: Supplementary Table 2 correlates these line means with published DGRP data, among them CT
min from Ørsted et al. 2018 (
DGRPool study 47, males; r = 0.60 and 0.61 with the males and females of this study) and CT
max from Rolandi et al. 2018 (
study 107; r = 0.59 and 0.55 between its males and the males and females of this study). Its P-values imply that each correlation was computed on only about 21-24 lines (a subset that the paper does not specify). On all the shared lines, the correlations computed from the DGRPool data are weaker: r = 0.27 (males) and 0.26 (females) with the 26 °C CT
min of study 47 (87 lines), and r = 0.24 and 0.43 with the male CT
max of study 107 (33 lines). Restricted to the lines of
study 168 (Rohde et al. 2016, also in Supplementary Table 2), they are close to the published ones: r = 0.60 and 0.54 with study 47 (27 lines), 0.55 and 0.50 with study 107 (24 lines). This supports the line numbers of Supplementary Table 1.
Not uploaded: the correlations with other DGRP studies (Supplementary Table 2), the GWAS results (Supplementary Tables 3-5), and the RNA-seq of Canton-S females after a cold or heat shock (Supplementary Tables 6-7, SRA BioProject
PRJNA612361), which is not on DGRP lines. The apparatus is described in Awde et al. 2020 (
J Vis Exp e61186).