Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from the authors'
Dryad dataset (
doi:10.5061/dryad.083f9, retrieved from its
Zenodo copy, byte-identical files) of the
article:
-
Egg_retention_counts.txt: for every replicate of the 91 DGRP lines, the number of unfertilized eggs, of embryos in five developmental categories and of freshly hatched larvae, counted on images of DAPI-stained eggs, and the ratio of unfertilized eggs (UNFERT).
-
Line_means.csv: the line means (± SE) of the retention score and of the ratio of unfertilized eggs.
-
README_for_Fiji_counting.txt: the scoring scheme (retention score of each developmental category).
Eggs laid by mated females of each line were collected in synchronized batches, dechorionated, fixed, stained with DAPI and imaged, and every egg was assigned by eye (Fiji Cell Counter) to a category: embryos at the cellular blastoderm stage (stage 5) were not retained (score 0); retained embryos were scored 30 (gastrulation, stages 6-7), 165 (germ band extension, stages 8-11), 400 (germ band retraction and head involution, stages 12-15), 840 (late segmented embryos, stages 16-17) or 1170 (freshly hatched larvae); eggs without DAPI staining (no DNA) were scored as unfertilized. Each replicate is a batch of eggs collected at the same time (replicates collected on different days): 1 to 5 replicates per line, 3 for most lines, 95,082 eggs in total. The values are entered with sex F, as traits of the mated females that laid the eggs.
The raw dataset has one row per replicate (289 rows, 91 lines):
-
EggRetention: retention score of the replicate, i.e. the mean score of its fertilized eggs (sum of score × number of embryos of each category, divided by the number of fertilized eggs). It was computed from the counts with the scores of the README: its means over the replicates of each line reproduce the authors' line means for all 91 lines, and their standard errors for the 90 lines with several replicates, to the published rounding.
-
UnfertEggRatio: ratio of unfertilized eggs to all eggs scored in the replicate (column UNFERT, as published), the authors' measure of fertilization success (higher values = lower fertilization success). Its line means and standard errors reproduce Line_means.csv.
- The counts behind these two phenotypes (Eggs_Unfert, Eggs_St5, Eggs_St6to7, Eggs_St8to11, Eggs_St12to15, Eggs_St16to17, Larvae_Hatched, Eggs_Total, Eggs_Fertilized) and the replicate number (Replicate) are kept as obsolete phenotypes: they depend on how many eggs were collected and imaged in each batch and are not phenotypes by themselves.
Of note:
-
DGRP_857 has a single replicate (17 eggs, 15 of them fertilized) and was excluded by the authors from the quantitative and GWA analyses for lack of replication (marked "1*" in Line_means.csv). It is uploaded as in the source, but the paper's analyses use 90 lines.
- The README of Line_means.csv gives 1-4 replicates per line, but DGRP_287 has 5 (also counted as 5 in Line_means.csv), and DGRP_492 has replicates 2 and 3 only.
- Over the 90 lines of the paper, the line means range from 1.27 (DGRP_069) to 331.72 (DGRP_732) for the retention score, and from 0.018 (DGRP_855) to 0.751 (DGRP_069) for the ratio of unfertilized eggs.
Not uploaded: the example images of the counting method (Fiji_counting.zip of the Dryad dataset).