Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from the
Supplementary information of the paper (
journal page, also on
PMC):
-
Table S1 (biolopen-15-062342-TableS1.csv): protein content of each tube of flies (820 tubes), for 32 DGRP lines, both sexes, control and exercised flies. Used for the raw dataset.
-
Table S2 (biolopen-15-062342-TableS2.xlsx): line means per sex used for the authors' GWAS, for control and exercised flies and for their difference ("change"). Used for the summary dataset (change values only).
The technical replicates, tube masses and the authors' R scripts are in their
GitHub repository (riddlenc/Walts_2025); they were used only to check Table S1.
Design. The flies are those of the exercise and weight study of Watanabe & Riddle 2021 (
DGRPool study 198; climbing performance in
DGRPool study 41). Virgin flies aged 3-5 days (10 vials of 10 flies per line, sex and treatment) were either exercised on the TreadWheel 2 h per day for 5 consecutive days (
_Exer) or handled the same way without exercise (
_Ctrl). The day after the last session, the flies went through a climbing assay, were weighed in tubes of 10 and frozen at -80°C. Each tube was later homogenised in 75 µL of lysis buffer, and protein was measured with a Bradford assay (BSA standard), in three technical replicates averaged per tube by the authors (Table S1 values).
Raw dataset. Each row is one tube of flies. Tubes of control and exercised flies are independent: they share rows (row k holds the k-th tube of each treatment for that line and sex, in the authors' vial-number order) but are
not paired. Values are copied as published:
-
ProtSample_Ctrl/_Exer: protein in the tube (µg; column prot_conc). The legend of Table S1 calls it a concentration in µg/ml, but the authors' scripts (01_BradfordStandardCurve.R, 02_ProteinNormalization.Rmd) multiply the homogenate concentration by its 75 µL volume and convert ng to µg, so it is the amount of protein in the sample. It depends on the number of flies in the tube.
-
ProtPerFly_Ctrl/_Exer: protein per fly (µg; prot_conc / number of flies), the main measure of the paper.
-
ProtPerMg_Ctrl/_Exer: protein per mg of body weight (µg/mg; prot_conc / mass of the flies in the tube).
- Obsolete design columns:
SampleWt_Ctrl/_Exer (mass of the flies in the tube, mg; already published by study 198 for 30 of the 32 lines, all but DGRP_091 and DGRP_142: 756 of the 766 tubes of these lines have the same weight and number of flies there),
NFlies_Ctrl/_Exer (7 to 10 flies; 10 in 622 of the 820 tubes) and
Vial_Ctrl/_Exer (the authors' tube number, 1-1280, which links to the GitHub files).
Following the authors, tubes with six or fewer flies (21 tubes) and two tubes without mass data are not included, and 437 of the 1,280 planned tubes were never assayed, so there are 1 to 10 tubes per line, sex and treatment (fewer than 3 for 15 of the 128 groups). For two tubes (vials 262 and 372), the authors dropped a negative technical replicate before averaging.
Summary dataset. mn_ProtSample_Chg,
mn_ProtPerFly_Chg and
mn_ProtPerMg_Chg are the changes with exercise (mean of exercised minus mean of control flies, per line and sex) published in Table S2. The per-fly and per-weight changes were used in the authors' GWAS (DGRP2 webtool; "Change" rows of Table 1). The control and exercised line means of Table S2, the other GWAS phenotypes, are exactly the means DGRPool computes from the raw dataset (64/64 line and sex means for each of the six raw phenotypes, differences below 1e-7), so they were not uploaded again. The webtool's "combined" and "difference between sexes" analyses use the same male and female means.
The raw data reproduce the paper: the highest and lowest group means (65.1 ± 6.2 µg/fly for exercised females of DGRP_142, 16.9 ± 3.8 µg/fly for control males of DGRP_315, 70.4 ± 3.9 and 16.4 ± 2.9 µg/mg), the correlations of Fig. 1C-D and Fig. S1B-C (e.g. r = 0.936 between control and exercised females) and the Kruskal-Wallis tests (no overall effect of the treatment: P = 0.7766 per fly, 0.7995 per mg).
Of note, the text swaps the lines with the lowest protein per fly in females: the data give DGRP_315 for control and DGRP_304 for exercised females (the text says the reverse).
Not uploaded: Table S3 (generalised linear models), Table S4 (quantitative genetic parameters; H
2 0.791 and 0.788 per fly, 0.722 and 0.673 per mg, for control and exercised flies), the GWAS results (Tables S5, S6) and GO terms (Table S7). The correlations with lifespan use published data of DGRPool studies
1,
12,
18,
40 and
100, and those with climbing and activity use data of studies 41 and
78.