Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from the
Supplementary Information of the paper (
journal page, also on
PMC):
-
Supplementary Table 1 (41598_2021_84534_MOESM5_ESM.csv): weight of each tube of flies, for 35 DGRP lines, both sexes, control and exercised flies. Used for the first raw dataset.
-
Supplementary Table 5 (41598_2021_84534_MOESM9_ESM.xlsx): body composition (QMR) of groups of 10 flies, for 5 of these lines. Used for the second raw dataset.
-
Supplementary Table 6 (41598_2021_84534_MOESM10_ESM.xlsx): wing measurements, 10 wings per line and sex, for the same 5 lines. Used for the third raw dataset.
No per-line values were published other than in figures. The line means computed by DGRPool from these raw data reproduce all the values given in the paper, so there is no summary dataset.
Body weight and exercise (raw dataset 1). Virgin flies aged 3-5 days were kept in groups of 20 per vial (five vials per line, sex and treatment). Exercised flies were rotated on the TreadWheel at 4 rotations per minute for 2 h per day (12:00 to 14:00, after 1 h of acclimatisation) for five days. Control flies were placed on a platform attached to the TreadWheel (same vibrations and noise, no rotation). The day after the last session, all flies went through a climbing assay (RING) and were then anaesthetised with CO
2, sorted into microcentrifuge tubes of 10 flies by line, sex and treatment, and weighed on a microscale (typically 10 tubes per line, sex and treatment).
Each row is one tube.
FlyWeight_Ctrl and
FlyWeight_Exer are the weight per fly (mg): the mass of the flies in the tube divided by their number (source column per_fly_weight, copied as published). Tubes of control and exercised flies are independent: they share rows (row k holds the k-th tube of each treatment for that line and sex) but are
not paired. The number of flies in the tube (5 to 10; 10 for 684 of the 935 tubes) is kept as the obsolete phenotypes NFlies_Ctrl and NFlies_Exer. The tube tare and gross masses of the source were not uploaded (their difference is the mass of the flies, which equals the per-fly weight times the number of flies). The source has no tube or vial identifier (its rows are sorted by weight within each line, sex and treatment). There are 1 to 11 tubes per line, sex and treatment, and no tubes at all for control females of DGRP_714 and control males of DGRP_317 and DGRP_859.
The authors' GWAS (DGRP2 webtool) used the means of the per-fly weights per line and sex of the control ("average control weight") and exercised flies ("average treatment weight"): these are the means DGRPool computes from FlyWeight_Ctrl and FlyWeight_Exer. Their third GWAS used the exercise-induced weight change of Fig. 7, which can be derived per line and sex as (mean FlyWeight_Exer - mean FlyWeight_Ctrl) / mean FlyWeight_Ctrl × 100. The legend of Fig. 7 writes (control - treatment) / control × 100, but the values given in the text (for example +11.0% for the females of line 727, which gain 0.108 mg) are (treatment - control) / control × 100.
The raw data reproduce the paper: the means ± SE quoted for lines 324, 310 and 730 (e.g. 0.502 ± 0.017 mg for control males of line 324), the correlations of Fig. 3 and their p-values (control vs exercised: r = 0.94 in females, 34 lines, and 0.90 in males, 33 lines; females vs males: r = 0.80 in both treatments), the Kruskal-Wallis test of the treatment (p = 0.8395) and the range of weight changes (females: -0.080 mg for line 859 to +0.108 mg for line 727; males: -0.068 mg for line 374 to +0.079 mg for line 486). The paper left out groups of fewer than three tubes only when naming the lightest and heaviest lines; its other analyses use all tubes, and all are uploaded.
Of note, the paper says that 38 DGRP lines were used, but Supplementary Table 1 (which, according to its legend, lists all the strains of the study), the figures and the statistics have 35 lines. The other three could not be identified.
Body composition (raw dataset 2). Virgin flies aged 0-4 days, reared on Jazzmix food and not exercised, were scanned in groups of 10 with an EchoMRI 3-in-1 (biopsy setting, nine primary accumulations) at the UAB Small Animal Phenotyping Core. Each row is one group of 10 flies:
QMR_Weight,
QMR_FatMass and
QMR_LeanMass are the weight, fat mass and lean mass of the group (mg), as published. There are four groups per line and sex, each measured on a different date (1, 2, 7 and 8 July 2020), kept as the obsolete text phenotype QMR_Date. The percentages of fat and lean mass shown in Fig. 5 are QMR_FatMass / QMR_Weight × 100 and QMR_LeanMass / QMR_Weight × 100 for each group. They reproduce the paper: 15.9 to 22.3% fat and 67.9 to 76.7% lean mass per line and sex, and correlations with the weight of r = 0.572 (fat) and -0.632 (lean) over the 40 groups.
Wing size (raw dataset 3). Wings were taken from other flies grown at the same time and under the same conditions as the QMR flies, mounted in 1× TBST under a cover slip, imaged with a Nikon AZ100 microscope (4×) and measured with FijiWings. Each row is one wing (10 wings per line and sex; the source Replicate_number is kept as the obsolete phenotype WingReplicate).
WingArea is the total wing area (source column Total_area) used in the paper. Its means reproduce the paper (143 to 200 in males and 183 to 232 in females; r = 0.845 with the QMR weight over the 10 line and sex means). The areas of the six wing cells (marginal, submarginal, discal, and first, second and third posterior cells),
TrichomeArea and
TrichomeDensity are in the authors' table but are not used in the paper. The paper describes wing area as a number of pixels, but the values (119 to 264 for a whole wing) cannot be raw pixel counts at 4× magnification, and no scale is given, so no unit is set. TrichomeDensity equals TrichomeArea / WingArea for 92 of the 100 wings (the other 8 differ by up to 1.5), and for one wing (DGRP_535, female, replicate 8) the six cell areas add up to more than the total area. These values are kept as published.
Not uploaded: Supplementary Table 2 (quantitative genetic parameters; broad-sense heritability 0.773 for control and 0.758 for exercised flies), the GWAS results (Supplementary Table 3) and the GO enrichment (Supplementary Table 4). Figures S1 and S3 compare the weights with the basal and exercise-induced activity of Watanabe et al. 2020 (
DGRPool study 78), and Figure S2 with published female lifespans (Durham et al. 2014, Ivanov et al. 2015). The climbing performance of exercised and control flies of the same lab and TreadWheel protocol is in
DGRPool study 41 (Watanabe et al. 2021; 33 lines in common with this study).