Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from the
Supporting Information of the paper (
journal page, also on
PMC):
-
SI Appendix (pnas.2403450121.sapp.pdf),
Tables S1-S7: life span of the 27 DGRP lines of the study, F1 life spans of the
gclc overexpression experiment (4 lines), and dopamine neuron counts, head glutathione and H
2O
2 of 6 lines.
-
Dataset S01 (pnas.2403450121.sd01.xlsx): 147 head metabolites in 3 replicate samples of 6 lines.
No per-fly data were published: life span and the traits of Tables S5-S7 are in the summary dataset, as published (means rounded by the authors).
Design. The authors chose the 15 shortest- and the 15 longest-lived DGRP lines of
Ivanov et al. 2015 (
DGRPool study 18) and could grow 27 of them (RAL-83, 136, 177, 239, 310, 313, 335, 356, 360, 371, 373, 379, 382, 409, 426, 461, 502, 596, 639, 703, 714, 727, 765, 819, 820, 821 and 911). Flies were reared and aged at 25 °C, 60% humidity, 12:12 h light-dark, on standard food. For life span, 100 to 490 flies per line (0-3 days old) were kept 25 per vial and transferred to fresh food every 3-4 days, and dead or censored (escaped or stuck in food) flies were recorded at each transfer until all were dead. Mean and median life span and their standard errors are Kaplan-Meier estimates (SPSS).
Summary dataset (one row per line and sex):
-
mn_Lifespan,
se_Lifespan,
md_Lifespan,
se_MdLifespan (standard error of the median) and
MaxLifespan (maximum life span), in days: mated females (Table S1, sex F) and mated males (Table S4, sex M), 25 flies per vial.
- The same five phenotypes with the suffix
_LowD: mated females kept at low density (8 flies per vial, food changed every Monday, Wednesday and Friday; Table S3).
-
mn_PPL1/
se_PPL1 (number of tyrosine hydroxylase-positive dopamine neurons in the PPL1 cluster, 9-10 brains),
mn_GSH/
se_GSH (head total glutathione, pmol/µg protein, 4 groups of 25 heads) and
mn_H2O2/
se_H2O2 (head H
2O
2, Amplex Red, pmol/µg protein, 3 groups of 10 heads), for the 6 core lines (short-lived RAL-727, 911 and 356; long-lived RAL-335, 379 and 821): mated males (Table S5, sex M, no suffix), low-density mated females (Table S6, suffix _LowD) and virgin females (Table S7, suffix
_Virgin). The tables do not give the ages (in the main experiment on mated females, neurons were counted at 30 days, glutathione measured at 1 week and H
2O
2 at 10 days).
-
F1 crosses (Table S2, Fig. 4C): mean life span and SE of the F1 progeny of 4 lines (RAL-727, 911, 356 and 821) crossed to
elavC155-GAL4 (suffix
_xElavG4), to
UAS-gclc (
_xUASgclc), or to
elavC155-GAL4/UAS-gclc (
_xElavGclc: pan-neuronal overexpression of
gclc, the rate-limiting enzyme of glutathione synthesis). These are phenotypes of F1 flies, not of the inbred lines, stored under the DGRP parent line. Table S2 does not give the sex: they are assigned to females, since the paper says that the experiments before Fig. 6 used mated females at 25 flies per vial. The log-rank P values of Table S2 are not uploaded.
Raw dataset 1 (metabolomics; Dataset S01, sheet "all metabolites (P value sort)"): targeted LC-MS/MS of aqueous metabolites (Northwest Metabolomics Research Center) in 3 replicate pools of 25 heads of 3-week-old females (sex F) of each of the 6 core lines, 18 samples. Each row is one sample; the letter of the authors' sample id (e.g. 356_A) is kept as the obsolete design column
Replicate. There is one phenotype per metabolite (147), described by the metabolite's name; the authors' labels (with the m/z of the targeted ion in parentheses), HMDB ids and pathways are in Dataset S01. Values are copied as published: log2 of the peak area, median-normalised. The authors removed metabolites with 20% or more missing values or 30% or more CV in the quality-control samples, and imputed the remaining missing values by QRILC (imputed values are not flagged). The line means computed from these values reproduce the authors' average abundance and log fold-change (short- minus long-lived lines) for all 147 metabolites. The limma statistics are not uploaded: 64 metabolites differ at FDR < 0.1, oxidized and reduced glutathione being the most decreased in the short-lived lines.
Checks. The correlations of mean life span between conditions of Fig. 6A are reproduced from Tables S1, S3 and S4 (e.g. mated females vs mated males r = 0.778, P = 1.8 × 10
-6; paper 0.77, 2 × 10
-6), and with the virgin female life span of DGRPool study 18 (r = 0.570, P = 0.0019; paper 0.57, P = 0.002, Fig. S1A). The Fig. 6B correlations are reproduced from Tables S5 and S7 (mated males and virgin females) within 0.01; for the low-density females (Table S6) they differ slightly (e.g. glutathione vs H
2O
2: r = -0.92 from the table, -0.80 in the figure).
Of note, the values are uploaded as published, including these likely errors:
- Table S1, RAL-177: median life span 54 days, larger than its maximum (44 days) and far from its mean (35 days).
- Table S3, RAL-727: mean 37 days, out of the increasing order of the table (between 42 and 43 days) and below its median (46 days).
- Table S4, RAL-727: median life span equal to the maximum (44 days), with an SE of 0.
- The text gives a mean mated female life span "ranging from 21 d (RAL-757) to 86 d (RAL-821)", but RAL-757 is not one of the 27 lines, and the shortest mean of Table S1 and Fig. 1B is 29 days (RAL-911 and RAL-409).
- Dataset S01 has a "Glutamic acid (148)" value, although the text says that glutamate was not detected.
Not uploaded (only plotted in figures): PPL1 neuron counts of the 27 lines at 30 days (Fig. 1C) and of some lines at 1 day (Fig. 1E-F), the other dopamine neuron clusters (Fig. S1B-F), negative geotaxis at 30 days (Fig. 1G), head glutathione of the 27 lines at 1 week (Fig. 3D) and of 13 lines at 4 weeks (Fig. S3C), qPCR of
gclc,
gclm,
Gss and
Ggt-1 (Fig. 3F, Fig. S7), brain vacuoles and serotonin neurons (Fig. 2, Fig. S3B), H
2O
2 at 2 and 10 days and survival on H
2O
2 food (Fig. 5A-C), and the crosses to
w1118,
TH-GAL4,
UAS-gclc and
parkin RNAi (Fig. 4A-B, Fig. 5B and D-E, Figs. S4-S6). The virgin female life spans of Fig. 6 are those of Ivanov et al. 2015 (DGRPool study 18).