Comments from curator
Phenotyping data of this paper are in its
Dryad deposit (
doi:10.5061/dryad.g1jwstr08, CC0), cited in the Data accessibility section of the paper (
journal page, full text on
PMC):
-
FitnessAssay.csv: eggs and hatched larvae of the female mated to each male, 1 and 5 days after the adult heat treatment (29 lines);
-
ReproductiveOrgan.csv: sperm presence, seminal vesicle and accessory gland areas and thorax length of each dissected male (10 lines);
-
SpermViability.csv: live and dead sperm counts of each male (10 lines).
The authors' R Markdown scripts are on
Zenodo, and the
electronic supplementary material holds only the model tables (Tables S1-S21).
Design: 29 DGRP lines were used: 15 with a "high" and 14 with a "low" thermal tolerance of male fertility after development at 29 °C (classes from Zwoinska et al. 2020,
DGRPool study 194; the 30-line set of Canal Domingo et al. 2022,
study 199, minus one low-tolerance line that did not produce enough eggs). Eggs (50 per vial) developed at a constant 24.5 °C (control) or 28 °C (developmental heat stress). One day after emergence, virgin males were given a 4-h adult treatment in groups of 10 in a water bath at 24.5, 28 or 36.5 °C (2 vials × 10 males per line and treatment, 3,480 males), then transferred to vials with standard food.
-
Fitness assay (all 29 lines): the day after the adult treatment, each male was paired for 24 h with one virgin Canton-S female (3-4 days old), which then laid eggs for 24 h on grape-juice agar; eggs and hatched larvae were counted. On day 4 the male was given two virgin females for a day to deplete his stored sperm, rested a day, and the assay was repeated 5 days after the treatment (with sperm that matured after the heat stress). The traits are fertility (at least one larva), the proportion of hatched eggs (fertilization success) and the number of larvae (male-mediated female fecundity).
-
Reproductive organs (10 lines, 5 high and 5 low; adult treatment 24.5 or 36.5 °C only): 10-15 naive males per line and treatment were frozen 1 and 5 days after the adult treatment, plus, at day 5, males that had been paired with two virgin females for 24 h on the 3rd day and left a day to replenish their sperm. Thorax length was measured with a reticle eyepiece, and the males were dissected and photographed at 32× (Leica stereomicroscope): presence of sperm in the seminal vesicle, seminal vesicle area (proxy of the mature sperm reserves) and accessory gland area (ImageJ).
-
Sperm viability (same 10 lines and cohorts): 4-5 males per line and treatment, 1 and 5 days after the adult treatment; the sperm of one seminal vesicle were stained (LIVE/DEAD sperm viability kit) and live (green) and dead (red) sperm counted (ImageJ).
Heat stress at both stages reduced fertility, hatching and larval production, with cumulative effects that persisted (or worsened) after 5 days; the adult 36.5 °C treatment had the strongest effect, and low-tolerance lines tended to suffer more.
Datasets (one row per male, all males, sex M). The conditions are in the phenotype names: _J24/_J28 = developmental temperature 24.5/28 °C; A24/A28/A36 = adult treatment at 24.5/28/36.5 °C; _d1/_d5 = 1 or 5 days after the adult treatment (Day 2 and Day 6 of the files, i.e. the age in days). Independent males of different conditions are stacked: within a line and block, row k holds the k-th male of each condition, so the values of one row do not belong to one male, except the day-1 and day-5 values of the fitness assay, which are those of the same male. Block (experimental block) is kept as an obsolete design column.
-
raw_1 (fitness assay, 29 lines; DGRP_491 of the 30-line set is the low-tolerance line that was not used):
Fertile (1 = at least one egg hatched),
HatchProp (Hatched / (Hatched + Unhatched)),
Larvae (number of hatched eggs) and
Eggs (total eggs laid), per condition and day (48 phenotypes). As in the authors' analyses, Fertile and Larvae are NA when the female laid no egg, and HatchProp is NA when she laid fewer than 5 eggs; Eggs keeps every pair (it is not analysed as such in the paper). Non-NA values: Fertile 1,859 on day 1 and 1,883 on day 5, HatchProp 1,595 and 1,735 (paper: 1,859, 1,883, 1,595 and 1,735). The file has 2,642 MaleIDs, written as 2,650 males: 6 records repeat a day already recorded for the same MaleID and are kept as separate males, as are the records of MaleIDs 1278 and 3412, whose two days have different temperatures. Not uploaded: the columns ProportionHatched (Hatched / TotalEggs, the same ratio as HatchProp), MaleID and ObservationID.
-
raw_2 (reproductive organs, 10 lines):
SpermPres (sperm in the seminal vesicle, 1/0),
SVArea (seminal vesicle area, mean of the two vesicles),
AGArea (accessory gland area) and
Thorax (thorax length), per developmental and adult temperature and group: _d1v (naive males, day 1), _d5m (males mated on day 3, day 5: the paper's day-5 group) and _d5v (naive males at day 5: in the file, but not in the paper's analyses). Males: 415 d1v, 336 d5m and 349 d5v. Areas in mm² (README); the left and right areas of the file are not uploaded (SVArea and AGArea are their means). Thorax is column thorax_4x as in the file (3.2 to 4.2), without a unit: the README gives it in mm "adjusted for magnification", but the values are about 4 times the thorax length of a fly (about 0.9 mm), so they are probably reticle readings at 4×.
-
raw_3 (sperm viability, 10 lines):
SpermViab (live / (live + dead), per male),
LiveSperm and
DeadSperm (counts), per condition and day. Males: 119 on day 1 and 116 on day 5; 53 of them have "null" counts (no sperm found, README): they are NA and not written, as the authors excluded them (n = 100 and 82). The day-5 males of this file have no mating status.
HatchProp and SpermViab are computed per male from the counts of the files (the paper analyses the counts with binomial models). The paper's figures show model estimates per treatment and tolerance class, so the DGRPool line means cannot be compared to published per-line values (there are none).
Lines (tolerance class given in the Dryad files, from Zwoinska et al. 2020; not uploaded, since it is not measured here): high DGRP_059, DGRP_208, DGRP_227, DGRP_228, DGRP_256, DGRP_360, DGRP_362, DGRP_374, DGRP_375, DGRP_379, DGRP_439, DGRP_440, DGRP_584, DGRP_822, DGRP_861; low DGRP_021, DGRP_195, DGRP_229, DGRP_235, DGRP_319, DGRP_352, DGRP_365, DGRP_409, DGRP_437, DGRP_530, DGRP_627, DGRP_808, DGRP_819, DGRP_900. Reproductive organs: DGRP_195, DGRP_228, DGRP_319, DGRP_362, DGRP_409, DGRP_437, DGRP_439, DGRP_440, DGRP_819, DGRP_861. Sperm viability: DGRP_195, DGRP_228, DGRP_319, DGRP_362, DGRP_409, DGRP_437, DGRP_439, DGRP_440, DGRP_819, DGRP_861.
Related DGRPool studies from the same group and lines:
study 194 (Zwoinska et al. 2020, 127-line screen of male fertility after development at 25, 27 and 29 °C, which defined the tolerance classes),
study 199 (Canal Domingo et al. 2022, fluctuating developmental temperatures, same 30 lines) and
study 58 (Rodrigues et al. 2022). The data of this paper are not in these studies.