Study

Curated
Baxter et al., 2023
Genetic correlation between aggressive signals and fighting
[10.1098/rsbl.2022.0616]

Description

Wing threat and fighting were scored in 10-min trials of pairs of F1 males from DGRP_83 females crossed to 24 DGRP lines, with a mated female present (16 lines) or absent (24 lines). Threat and fighting were highly genetically correlated (rG = 0.80 and 0.74).

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the authors' data and code repository on figshare (doi:10.6084/m9.figshare.21565722, version 1, a snapshot of the GitHub repository DworkinLab/CB_RD_Aggression2022; journal page, also on PMC):
- data/CB_RD_MF.csv: experiment 1, males with a female (443 trials, 16 genotypes).
- data/CB_RD_M.csv: experiment 2, males only (361 trials, 24 genotypes).
These are the files read by the authors' R script (scripts/CB_RD_Aggression.Rmd). They hold the same values as the two sheets of the original Excel file (data/CB_RD_DataFinal_Threat_Fighting.xlsx).

These are F1 phenotypes, not phenotypes of the inbred DGRP lines: to lessen inbreeding effects, males of 24 Wolbachia-free DGRP lines were crossed to virgin females of a single line, DGRP_83, and the F1 hybrid males were tested. Each value is assigned to the DGRP father line (the DGRP column of the files), and the cross is given in the phenotype names (_x83). The F1 males carry the X chromosome of DGRP_83. Flies were raised at 25 °C, 50% relative humidity and 12:12 h light:dark on a sucrose-cornmeal-yeast medium, at a controlled larval density, collected as virgins within 8 h of eclosion and kept singly in food vials.

Males were tested at 4 days of age, within 2 h of lights on, in 35-mm arenas whose walls and ceiling were coated with Surfasil, with a central food patch (yeast and grapefruit juice). Each trial had two males of the same genotype from different vials. In experiment 1 (females present), a female of the same genotype, mated once just before the test, was added (the authors excluded 2 trials in which she remated); in experiment 2 (females absent), only the two males. After 5 min of acclimation, the flies were filmed for 10 min, and observers blind to genotype scored the videos with BORIS: wing threat (a male raising his wings at 45° toward his opponent) and fighting (lunging, holding, boxing and tussling).

raw_1 (experiment 1, suffix _wFem_x83, 16 lines) and raw_2 (experiment 2, suffix _noFem_x83, 24 lines) have one row per trial (pair of males), sex M, with the values as published:
- Threat_ and Fight_: wing threat and fighting in seconds per minute (unit s/min), the authors' standard measure and the two traits of the paper (Fig. 1, Table 1): the total duration in the trial divided by the 10 min of recording. Fighting sums the fighting durations (experiment 1: aggr_dur_1male + aggr_dur_2males; experiment 2: aggr_dur_1male + boxing + tussling). The wing-threat durations in seconds of the files are not uploaded, since they are exactly 10 × Threat.
- The other columns of the files, which the paper does not analyse: numbers of lunges and holds (both experiments) and of tussles (experiment 1) in the 10 min (unit counts/10min); fighting durations in seconds (by one male and by both males in experiment 1; by one male, boxing and tussling in experiment 2); durations of courtship of the female by one male or by both males (experiment 1); and time spent on the arena ceiling (column ceiling_dur, not described in the paper).
- Design columns, kept as obsolete: replicate (A/B), test day within replicate and set of trials (experiment 1); observer (A/J) and test day (experiment 2, taken from the trial ID as in the authors' script). Trial IDs, arena numbers and video names are not uploaded.
Zeros are real values (no aggression), not missing data: 37% of the threat and fighting values are 0 in experiment 1 and 8% in experiment 2, as in the authors' script output.

The authors analysed threat and fighting jointly with Tweedie generalized linear mixed models (glmmTMB, log link) with genotype, test day (within replicate in experiment 1), observer (experiment 2) and trial as random effects. They found high genetic correlations between threat and fighting (rG = 0.80 with females, 0.74 without) and broad-sense heritabilities of 0.27-0.47 on the latent scale (Table 1). Their per-genotype values are model-based conditional means, shown only in Fig. 1 (not uploaded); the line means computed by DGRPool are simple means of the trials and differ from them.

Of note:
- In experiment 2, trials D4-113 (DGRP_235), D4-114 (DGRP_502) and D4-115 (DGRP_508) are each in the file twice, scored by both observers with different values (e.g. fighting 1.2752 vs 0.2499 s/min for D4-113). Both rows are kept, as in the authors' analysis, whose 361 trials include them.
- In experiment 1, trial A-D9-105 (DGRP_208) has a ceiling duration of 600.945 s, slightly more than the 10-min recording.

Not uploaded: the model estimates (outputs/OutputsEstimates.xlsx, the values of Table 1). Aggression of the inbred DGRP lines, with other assays, is in DGRPool study 29 and study 30.

Other external data available

10.6084/m9.figshare.21565722 figshare snapshot of the authors' GitHub repository DworkinLab/CB_RD_Aggression2022 (per-trial threat and fighting data of both experiments, R analysis code and outputs)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 10 phenotypes
AggrDur1M_wFem_x83 AggrDur2M_wFem_x83 CeilingDur_wFem_x83 CourtDur1M_wFem_x83 CourtDur2M_wFem_x83 Fight_wFem_x83 Holds_wFem_x83 Lunges_wFem_x83 Threat_wFem_x83 Tussles_wFem_x83
16 DGRP lines
DGRP_026
DGRP_177
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_235
DGRP_301
DGRP_332
DGRP_373
DGRP_375
DGRP_385
DGRP_391
DGRP_427
DGRP_502
DGRP_508
DGRP_799
DGRP_808
Download
Raw dataset #2 8 phenotypes
AggrDur1M_noFem_x83 BoxDur_noFem_x83 CeilingDur_noFem_x83 Fight_noFem_x83 Holds_noFem_x83 Lunges_noFem_x83 Threat_noFem_x83 TussleDur_noFem_x83
24 DGRP lines
DGRP_026
DGRP_045
DGRP_057
DGRP_085
DGRP_177
DGRP_195
DGRP_208
DGRP_235
DGRP_301
DGRP_332
DGRP_373
DGRP_375
DGRP_385
DGRP_391
DGRP_392
DGRP_427
DGRP_443
DGRP_491
DGRP_502
DGRP_508
DGRP_517
DGRP_799
DGRP_808
DGRP_894
Download
Back to studies