Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from
Supplementary Table S1 of the paper (
Electronic supplementary material, file
10709_2018_26_MOESM1_ESM.docx). Table S1 is embedded in the Word file as two vector images: its values were read exactly from the text of these images (no OCR) and checked against the paper (see below). Only line means were published (no per-fly or per-pair data), so the study has a summary dataset only.
Design: the five DGRP lines with the lowest average rank across published DGRP phenotypes (paraquat resistance,
study 36; starvation resistance and chill-coma recovery,
study 21; negative geotaxis,
study 19; longevity,
study 18), DGRP_021, DGRP_042, DGRP_176, DGRP_177 and DGRP_765 ("recipient" populations), were each crossed to six genetically close and six genetically distant "donor" DGRP lines (genomic relationship matrix, Table S2), with the recipient line as father in half of the crosses and as mother in the other half. Starvation resistance and reproductive output were measured on the parental lines and on the F1 and F3 hybrids. After lines and crosses without complete data were discarded, Table S1 has 52 crosses (26 of short and 26 of long genetic distance) between 36 DGRP lines. The parental lines were measured once, in the F1 generation, at 23 °C, 50% relative humidity and 12:12 h light:dark.
The summary dataset has the parental line means (columns M and F of Table S1; a line has the same value in every cross where it appears):
-
mn_StarvResist (Hours, sex M): starvation resistance, survival time of single males (52 ± 4 h old) in vials with 2% agar, 10 vials of one male per line, checked every 8 h until all flies had died.
-
mn_ReprodOutput (counts/day, sex NA): reproductive output, number of adult offspring per day produced by one male and one virgin female of the line, moved to a fresh vial every 72 h for 9 days, 13 pairs per line. When a fly died early, the total was divided by the number of days with data, or the pair was discarded (rules in the Supplementary methods).
Values are as published (2 decimals).
Not uploaded: the hybrid offspring means (F1 and F3 of each cross), the mid-parent values and the mid- and best-parent heterosis (MPH and BPH, in %) of Table S1, which are values of crosses between two DGRP lines; they are available in Table S1. The genomic relationship matrix (Table S2) is not a phenotype.
Of note:- The paper says 37 parental lines and 52 crosses were assessed, but Table S1 has 36 parental lines (the 60 planned crosses involved 41 lines).
- The legend of Table S1 gives reproductive output "in eggs laid per day", but the methods and the Supplementary methods count the emerged offspring (flies per day); the methods' definition is used.
- Table S1 reproduces the paper: MP = (M+F)/2, and MPH and BPH match the parental and offspring means. The numbers of crosses with significant heterosis (starvation resistance: 41 MPH and 28 BPH in F1, 18 and 9 in F3; reproductive output: 51 and 46 in F1, 42 and 28 in F3) and the mean MPH (29% and 5% for starvation resistance, 218% and 132% for reproductive output) are those of the Results.
- The starvation resistance of the parental males correlates with the male starvation resistance of
study 21 (Spearman rho = 0.40, P = 0.015, 36 lines).