Study

Curated
Eugénio et al., 2023
Effects of Wolbachia on Transposable Element Expression Vary Between Drosophila melanogaster Host Genotypes
[10.1093/gbe/evad036]

Description

Expression of 14 transposable elements was measured by qPCR (Cq, with the reference gene EF1) in 10-day-old females of 25 Wolbachia-infected DGRP lines and of the same lines cured of Wolbachia by tetracycline. Wolbachia removal changed expression in 21% of line-TE pairs.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the Supplementary data of the paper (journal page, also on PMC; file ATE_Wolb&TEs_STables_revised.xlsx in evad036_supplementary_data.zip):
- Supplementary Table S2 ("TE expression data", the table named in the data availability statement): qPCR Cq of each transposable element (TE) and of the reference gene EF1, for each biological replicate, TE, line and Wolbachia status (5,496 rows).
- Supplementary Table S5: "raw Effect Size" of Wolbachia removal per line and TE (350 values).
Table S4 (primers and efficiencies) was used to check the data. Table S3 (ANOVA and Kruskal-Wallis tests per line and TE) and Table S1 (PCR validation of predicted TE insertions) are not phenotypes and are not uploaded.

Design: 25 DGRP lines naturally infected with Wolbachia (wMel; all annotated as infected in the DGRP, none with Spiroplasma) were used as such (Wolb+) and as a Wolbachia-free version (Wolb−), obtained by rearing on tetracycline (0.05 mg/mL) for two generations, restoring the gut microbiota with an inoculum from the untreated line, and keeping the flies for at least five generations before the experiments (cure confirmed by wsp PCR). Flies were reared at 25 °C, 12:12 h light:dark, on cornmeal-molasses food; newly eclosed adults were kept in vials of 10 females and 6 males, and the females were collected at 10 days of age. For each line and status, RNA was extracted from 8 replicate pools of 10 whole females, and the cDNA was quantified by qPCR (SYBR Green) with primers for 14 TEs (412, 1360, blastopia, blood, copia, Cr1a, gypsy5, Idefix, Juan, mdg1, opus, P-element, pogo, Quasimodo) and for EF1. Each Cq is the mean of two technical replicates; biological replicates whose technical replicates differed by an SD > 0.5 were discarded by the authors (104 of the 5,600 TE measurements; NA in the upload). The lines are given as RAL-xx (= DGRP_0xx). All values are from females (sex F).

raw_1 has one value per biological replicate (pool of 10 females) in a compact layout: row k of a line holds replicate k (Table S2 "Replicate", kept as the obsolete design column Replicate) of every TE and status. For each TE (P-element written P_element):
- Cq_<TE>_Wolb and Cq_<TE>_NoWolb: Cq of the TE in Wolb+ and Wolb− females (PCR cycles; a lower Cq means more transcript);
- EF1_<TE>_Wolb and EF1_<TE>_NoWolb: Cq of EF1 in the same sample, as given on the same Table S2 row (one EF1 reaction often served several TEs, so several EF1_ columns hold the same values).
A TE Cq and its EF1 Cq (same TE and status) on one row come from the same sample. Other values on a row do not necessarily: Wolb+ and Wolb− are different pools, and Table S2 numbers the replicates 1 to n after discarding some, so replicate k of one TE is often not the same RNA pool as replicate k of another TE (the EF1 values show it).

Normalised expression is not uploaded (it is derived): the authors used the Pfaffl method, log2 ratio = (Cqcal,TE − CqTE) × log2(ETE) − (Cqcal,EF1 − CqEF1) × log2(EEF1), with E = 1 + efficiency/100 (Table S4; EF1 98.10%) and the mean of the line's Wolb+ samples as calibrator (cal). It can be computed row by row from Cq_<TE>_<status> and EF1_<TE>_<status>.

The summary dataset has mn_WolbRm_<TE>: the effect of Wolbachia removal on the expression of each TE, Table S5 "raw Effect Size", as published. These values are the mean log2 expression of the Wolb− samples minus that of the Wolb+ samples (recomputed from Table S2 to 1e-6 for 346 of the 350 line × TE pairs), so a positive value means higher expression without Wolbachia.

Of note:
- The paper's text defines the effect size as the median log2 expression of Wolb+ minus that of Wolb− flies, i.e. with the opposite sign to Table S5: blood in DGRP_595 is "around 2.3" in the text and −2.26 in Table S5, and the medians over TEs of DGRP_021 and DGRP_712 are "around −1.1 and −0.9" in the text and 1.15 and 0.93 in Table S5. The counts in the text (24 line × TE pairs with expression more than doubled after removal, 3 with a strong decrease) match Table S5 (24 values above 1, 3 below −1).
- For P-element, Tables S3 and S5 were computed with a primer efficiency of 112.72%, not the 94.09% given in Table S4 (all 25 P-element values of Table S5 and the Table S3 F-values are reproduced with 112.72%).
- Four Table S5 values differ slightly from those recomputed from Table S2 (DGRP_321: blastopia 1.863 vs 1.928, Quasimodo 1.399 vs 1.363, Cr1a 1.4291 vs 1.4294; DGRP_237 Idefix: 0.077 vs 0.072), and so do their Table S3 F-values: a few Cq values analysed by the authors probably differ from Table S2. Table S5 is uploaded as published.
- Table S3 has 74 of the 350 line × TE pairs with P < 0.05 (ANOVA), as in the paper; 47 have a higher expression in Wolb− and 27 (26 in the text) in Wolb+ flies.

Not uploaded: the Wolbachia load (wsp/actin qPCR ratio) of 5 individual females per Wolb+ line, which is only shown in Fig. 1A (no table); the numbers of novel TE insertions of the lines (Fig. 1B), taken from Rahman et al. 2015 (TIDAL-FLY) and not measured in this study; and the TE insertion validations (Table S1).

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 14 phenotypes
mn_WolbRm_1360 mn_WolbRm_412 mn_WolbRm_Cr1a mn_WolbRm_Idefix mn_WolbRm_Juan mn_WolbRm_P_element mn_WolbRm_Quasimodo mn_WolbRm_blastopia mn_WolbRm_blood mn_WolbRm_copia mn_WolbRm_gypsy5 mn_WolbRm_mdg1 mn_WolbRm_opus mn_WolbRm_pogo
25 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_069
DGRP_136
DGRP_142
DGRP_149
DGRP_181
DGRP_237
DGRP_280
DGRP_320
DGRP_321
DGRP_338
DGRP_352
DGRP_370
DGRP_374
DGRP_440
DGRP_441
DGRP_535
DGRP_595
DGRP_712
DGRP_737
DGRP_738
DGRP_801
DGRP_820
DGRP_855
DGRP_882
Download
Raw dataset #1 56 phenotypes
Cq_1360_NoWolb Cq_1360_Wolb Cq_412_NoWolb Cq_412_Wolb Cq_Cr1a_NoWolb Cq_Cr1a_Wolb Cq_Idefix_NoWolb Cq_Idefix_Wolb Cq_Juan_NoWolb Cq_Juan_Wolb Cq_P_element_NoWolb Cq_P_element_Wolb Cq_Quasimodo_NoWolb Cq_Quasimodo_Wolb Cq_blastopia_NoWolb Cq_blastopia_Wolb Cq_blood_NoWolb Cq_blood_Wolb Cq_copia_NoWolb Cq_copia_Wolb Cq_gypsy5_NoWolb Cq_gypsy5_Wolb Cq_mdg1_NoWolb Cq_mdg1_Wolb Cq_opus_NoWolb Cq_opus_Wolb Cq_pogo_NoWolb Cq_pogo_Wolb EF1_1360_NoWolb EF1_1360_Wolb EF1_412_NoWolb EF1_412_Wolb EF1_Cr1a_NoWolb EF1_Cr1a_Wolb EF1_Idefix_NoWolb EF1_Idefix_Wolb EF1_Juan_NoWolb EF1_Juan_Wolb EF1_P_element_NoWolb EF1_P_element_Wolb EF1_Quasimodo_NoWolb EF1_Quasimodo_Wolb EF1_blastopia_NoWolb EF1_blastopia_Wolb EF1_blood_NoWolb EF1_blood_Wolb EF1_copia_NoWolb EF1_copia_Wolb EF1_gypsy5_NoWolb EF1_gypsy5_Wolb EF1_mdg1_NoWolb EF1_mdg1_Wolb EF1_opus_NoWolb EF1_opus_Wolb EF1_pogo_NoWolb EF1_pogo_Wolb
25 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_069
DGRP_136
DGRP_142
DGRP_149
DGRP_181
DGRP_237
DGRP_280
DGRP_320
DGRP_321
DGRP_338
DGRP_352
DGRP_370
DGRP_374
DGRP_440
DGRP_441
DGRP_535
DGRP_595
DGRP_712
DGRP_737
DGRP_738
DGRP_801
DGRP_820
DGRP_855
DGRP_882
Download
Back to studies