Study

Curated
Peterson et al., 2019
Intraspecific Genetic Variation for Lead-Induced Changes in Reproductive Strategies
[10.1007/s00128-019-02650-w]

Description

Copulation latency and duration of single same-line pairs (18 DGRP lines) and female fecundity (adult offspring, 21 lines) were measured on flies reared on control or 500 µM lead acetate food. Lead decreased fecundity and increased copulation duration.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from Table 1 and Table 2 of the paper (journal page; Table 1, Table 2; not open access, no supplementary material):
- Table 1: strain means ± standard error of the mean (overall N) of copulation latency and copulation duration, control and Pb, for 18 DGRP lines.
- Table 2: strain means ± standard error (overall N) of fecundity, control and Pb, for 21 DGRP lines.
Only these per-line values were published (no per-fly data), so the study has a summary dataset only. Lines are given by their number in the tables (e.g. 31 = DGRP_031); 23 lines in total, all DGRP lines of DGRPool.

Design: 100 randomly chosen DGRP lines (three replicate populations each) were allowed to lay eggs for 5 days on control medium (Carolina Biological Instant Drosophila Medium formula 4-24, distilled water and yeast) or on lead medium (the same medium made with a 500 µM lead acetate (PbAc) solution instead of water). The offspring developed on these media, were sexed at eclosion and kept in same-sex groups on the matching medium, and were moved to control medium 7 days after eclosion for 24 h of depuration. At 8 days, one female and one male of the same line, treatment and replicate population (homotypic pair) were paired in a vial with control medium and observed for up to 1 h: copulation latency (pairing to start of copulation) and copulation duration (start to end of copulation) were recorded in 5-min intervals, for the pairs that mated within the hour. Each female was then kept for fecundity: 4 days in the same medium and 7 days on fresh control medium; her offspring were reared on control medium and the mature adult offspring were counted from photographs (SpotAFly). Females that had not mated within the first hour were left with the male to increase the fecundity sample. The paper reports a final sample of 31 control and 29 lead-treated lines (some lines and replicates could not be assayed because of differences in maturation and lower survival on lead); the tables give the lines with data in both treatments (the authors' ANOVA omitted the others): 18 lines for latency and duration (1-5 pairs per line) and 21 lines for fecundity (1-6 females per line). Replicate populations are combined. Lead accumulation (Figure 2) was measured on a Canton-S strain, not on DGRP lines, and is not included.

Summary dataset (12 phenotypes): mn_ (strain mean) and se_ (standard error) of CopLat and CopDur (minutes) and Fecundity (number of adult offspring per female), each for the control (_Ctrl) and lead (_Pb500) treatments. Copulation latency and duration are traits of a pair of flies of the line, so their sex is NA; fecundity is stored as F. Values are copied as printed. The tables give an SE of 0 for 57 of the 58 cells with N = 1 (a single pair or female): the SE is undefined there and was set to NA, so that the remaining 0 values (4 cells with 2-3 identical values) are real. The N of each line and treatment is not uploaded (it is in Tables 1-2): 58 of the 114 cells are based on a single pair or female, so many line means are single observations.

Checks and inconsistencies: the line means reproduce the correlations given in the text exactly: control vs lead means r = 0.50 (latency), 0.53 (duration) and 0.59 (fecundity); the control minus lead difference vs the lead mean r = -0.64 (latency) and -0.91 (duration), and vs the control mean r = 0.56 (fecundity). Three cells of Table 1 do not fit 5-min intervals and were kept as published: DGRP_031 lead duration (17.5 ± 3.54 with N = 1, while the latency of the same pairs has N = 3; it fits 2 pairs at 15 and 20 min, with 3.54 their SD), DGRP_383 control latency (10 ± 0.06 with N = 5, impossible since the smallest non-zero SE is 1.58), and DGRP_356 control duration (6.58, i.e. the SE 6.575 rounded twice).

The authors' genetic correlations used a "difference" variable per line, the control mean minus the lead mean (e.g. mn_Fecundity_Ctrl - mn_Fecundity_Pb500); it can be derived from the uploaded means and was not uploaded.

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 12 phenotypes
mn_CopDur_Ctrl mn_CopDur_Pb500 mn_CopLat_Ctrl mn_CopLat_Pb500 mn_Fecundity_Ctrl mn_Fecundity_Pb500 se_CopDur_Ctrl se_CopDur_Pb500 se_CopLat_Ctrl se_CopLat_Pb500 se_Fecundity_Ctrl se_Fecundity_Pb500
23 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_031
DGRP_235
DGRP_306
DGRP_336
DGRP_356
DGRP_374
DGRP_383
DGRP_390
DGRP_563
DGRP_566
DGRP_584
DGRP_589
DGRP_634
DGRP_703
DGRP_716
DGRP_776
DGRP_787
DGRP_801
DGRP_804
DGRP_818
DGRP_890
DGRP_913
Download
Back to studies