Comments from curator
Phenotyping data come from the authors' Dryad repository (
doi:10.5061/dryad.j9kd51cj9, mirrored on
Zenodo), file
Patlar_Civetta_PaternityData.txt: one row per female of the sperm competition assay, with the DGRP line and larval density of her second male, the block and replicate, the offspring counts of each vial and the relative paternity success of the second male (P2). The two other data files of the repository (Patlar_Civetta_data_SP.txt and Patlar_Civetta_data_Acp36de.txt) are outputs of the DGRP2 GWAS web tool and contain no phenotype.
Design: males of 11 DGRP lines (DGRP_208, 301, 303, 304, 313, 324, 335, 357, 358, 360 and 362) were reared at low larval density (100 eggs in a 250 ml bottle with 50 ml of food) or at high larval density (200 eggs in a 36 ml vial with 4-5 ml of food), at 22 °C on cornmeal-yeast-molasses-agar food. Virgin females of an isofemale line from Winnipeg (Wpg02) were first mated for 24 h to males expressing GFP in the eyes and ocelli (BDSC 32175), then kept alone for 2 days (vial 1), paired overnight with one DGRP male in a new vial (vial 2), moved 3 days later to vial 3 and discarded 4 days later. Offspring were counted until the last fly hatched. P2 is the proportion of wild-type offspring (sired by the DGRP male) among all the offspring of vials 2 and 3. The phenotypes are those of the DGRP male, so the sex is M.
Raw dataset 1, one row = one female (each female was paired with her own DGRP male): P2 (
P2_LowDens,
P2_HighDens, copied as given in the file), the number of wild-type offspring sired by the DGRP male (
NOffDGRP_) and of GFP offspring sired by the first male (
NOffGFP_) in vials 2 and 3, whether the female remated with the DGRP male (
Remated_, 1 or 0), and the authors' replicate (
Rep_, obsolete design column). The suffix gives the larval density at which the DGRP male was reared. Males reared at low and at high density are different males: row k of a line holds the k-th female of each density (in the order of the file), and the shorter series is padded with NA.
Excluded females, as in the paper: the 6 females (out of 368) without offspring in vial 1 had not been inseminated by the first male; the authors discarded them, and they are left out. Of the remaining 362 females, the 149 that produced no wild-type offspring and whose second mating was not seen (column secmate = n) were assumed by the authors not to have mated with the DGRP male and were excluded from their analyses: their P2 and offspring counts are NA, and Remated is 0. The 7 females whose second mating was seen but that produced no wild-type offspring were kept by the authors, with P2 = 0. This leaves 213 females for P2 (123 at low and 90 at high density, 4 to 15 per line and density), as in the paper.
Remated is the authors' column secmate (y = 1, n = 0), which is y exactly when the female produced wild-type offspring or the mating was seen (column seen). It is not analysed in the paper, and a 0 can also mean a mating without fertile sperm transfer. The offspring counts of each vial (vial 1, 2 and 3), the female and male IDs, the female bottle and the block (first letter of the replicate) are not uploaded.
Checks: P2 equals NOffDGRP / (NOffDGRP + NOffGFP) for every female, and the numbers of females (368, of which 6 without offspring in vial 1, and 149 of the remaining 362 excluded) match the Methods. The authors analysed P2 with a binomial GLMM on the numbers of wild-type and GFP offspring, with female ID and replicate as random factors (electronic supplementary material, Table S4: significant genotype and genotype-by-density effects, no density effect), and related the line means of P2 at each density to the line means of gene expression (Table S5, 22 line-by-density means). The line means of P2 are only shown in Figure 2, so they could not be compared with the values computed here (overall mean P2: 0.4435 at low and 0.4438 at high density).
Not available: the paper also measured, on 34 DGRP lines reared at the two larval densities, the wing centroid size of 10 males per line and density (as a proxy for body size), and the expression in the male reproductive tract (qPCR, ΔCq relative to
RpS18; 4 biological replicates per line and density) of the sperm competition genes
Sex Peptide (
SP),
Acp36DE and
CG9997. These data are not in the Dryad repository, and the
electronic supplementary material only gives the statistical tests; the 34 lines are not listed. The GWAS of the paper did not use these measurements: it was run with the DGRP2 web tool on the
SP and
Acp36DE expression of 185 DGRP lines from the DGRP2 website (adult males reared at 25 °C; Huang et al. 2015 and 2020).