Comments from curator
Data source: Table 1 of the article ("Measures of anesthetic potency (EC50) and speed of recovery (TtR50) for isoflurane (ISO) and sevoflurane (SEVO)"): one value per strain, mean ± SD for EC50 and TtR50, and the ISO/SEVO potency and recovery ratios with an SD obtained by propagation of error. The
supplementary file holds figures only, and the per-vial dose-response and recovery curves are only plotted (Fig. 5), so the study has a summary dataset only. Values are copied as printed (2 decimals).
Design: males aged 1-8 days of 4 DGRP lines (RAL161, RAL352, RAL774 and RAL892, from the Bloomington Stock Center, uploaded as DGRP_161, DGRP_352, DGRP_774 and DGRP_892), raised on molasses food at 25 °C, were anesthetised in the authors' Serial Anesthesia Array (tubes in series fed by calibrated vaporizers). The lines were chosen from the two ends of the mortality after traumatic brain injury measured on 179 DGRP lines by
Katzenberger et al., 2015: DGRP_352 and DGRP_774 at the low end, DGRP_161 and DGRP_892 at the high end. Both endpoints use the
Percent Active assay: the percentage of the 10 flies of a vial that climb above 2 cm within 1 min after the vial is tapped (startle-induced negative geotaxis).
-
mn_EC50_ISO,
mn_EC50_SEVO (and their SD, unit %): half-maximal effective concentration of isoflurane or sevoflurane, in % (v/v) of anesthetic in the air. Flies were exposed for 10 min to increasing concentrations and the Percent Active was measured in the presence of the anesthetic at each step until no fly climbed; n = 3-5 per line and agent. A lower EC50 means a higher sensitivity (potency).
-
mn_TtR50_ISO,
mn_TtR50_SEVO (and their SD, Minutes): time to 50% recovery after deep anesthesia (1 h at 2% isoflurane or 3.5% sevoflurane): after venting the anesthetic, the Percent Active was measured repeatedly, and the TtR50 is the time needed for 50% of the flies of a vial to climb above 2 cm in 1 min; n = 3-7 per line and agent.
-
mn_PotencyRatio (ISO EC50 / SEVO EC50) and
mn_RecoveryRatio (ISO TtR50 / SEVO TtR50), unitless: computed by the authors as the ratio of the two line means (e.g. 0.60 = 0.41/0.68 for w1118);
sd_PotencyRatio and
sd_RecoveryRatio are their error-propagated SDs. They are uploaded because Table 1 publishes them per line; the published ratios equal the ratios of the published means to within rounding.
The summary type of the ratios is "mean" because they are ratios of means. The paper does not give the n of each line (only the ranges above). Figures show the standard error of the mean; Table 1 gives the SD.
Not uploaded: the laboratory strains w1118 and Canton S and the mitochondrial mutant
ND2360114 (in the Canton S background), which are not DGRP lines and are also in Table 1 (the
ND2360114 TtR50 was not determined); the assay validation, sex and age effects (Early Recovery Time) and lifespan after anesthesia, measured on w1118 and Canton S only. The authors found that isoflurane was more potent than sevoflurane and that recovery from sevoflurane was faster in every line, but the potency ratio (0.32 for DGRP_774 to 0.53 for DGRP_352) and the TtR50 (15.4 min for DGRP_892 to 37.9 min for DGRP_161 with isoflurane) differed among lines, with no relation to the brain-injury mortality.