Study

Curated
Archer et al., 2018
Intralocus sexual conflict can resolve the male-female health-survival paradox
[10.1038/s41467-018-07541-y]

Description

Late-life (35-day-old) fertility of virgin males (offspring with Dahomey females) and health of virgin females (negative geotaxis climbing distance, recovery time from CO2 anaesthesia) were measured in 8 DGRP lines. Lines with more fertile males had females that climbed less.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the Dryad dataset 10.5061/dryad.p888tv2 (Data_Archive_Archer_et_al.xlsx, sheets Expt_2_Male_Fertility, Expt_2_Female_Geotaxis and Expt_2_Female_Co2), cited in the Data availability statement of the paper; the file was taken from the Dryad mirror on Zenodo (record 5001094, same checksum). The Expt_1 sheets (selection for late-life male fertility and the lifespan of the females) are Drosophila simulans selection lines, not DGRP, and are not uploaded.

Ten DGRP lines were set up (28, 101, 136, 360, 382, 443, 595, 737, 783, 796) at 25 °C, 12:12 h light:dark. Flies were collected as virgins on the day of eclosion and kept alone in vials until the assays at 35 days of age (late life). Lines with fewer than two surviving flies were excluded by the authors: DGRP_382 and DGRP_443 have no data and DGRP_783 has no CO2 recovery data, so 8 lines are uploaded (sample sizes in Supplementary Table 1 of the Supplementary Information).

Raw dataset 1 has one row per male (sex M), per geotaxis trial (sex F) and per CO2-tested female (sex F); the females of the two assays are different flies.
MaleFert_35d: each 35-day-old virgin DGRP male was kept for 48 h with two virgin females of the laboratory's wild-type Dahomey stock and then removed; the females were moved to a new vial for 48 h, and again for 48 h, and the adult offspring of each vial were counted 8 days after the first eclosion. MaleFert_35d_D1_2, _D3_4 and _D5_6 are the counts of the three vials (VialA, VialB, VialC of the file) and MaleFert_35d is their sum, the authors' measure ("Male fertility = sum of vial A, B, C"). Males that produced no offspring at all (perhaps unmated) were excluded by the authors and are not in the file: it has 27 males of 8 lines (2 to 5 per line), where Supplementary Table 1 counts 45 males including them.
Geotaxis_35d: distance (mm) climbed by a 35-day-old virgin female in the 2 min after the vial was dropped from 10 cm (filmed; scored blind by two observers, a third one when they differed by more than 3 mm), capped at 85 mm. Each female was tested twice, 2 min apart; one row is one trial (34 females, 29 with both trials; a trial is missing when the video could not be scored). Zero distances are kept, as in the authors' analyses. Geotaxis_FlyID (the authors' blind ID) and Geotaxis_Trial are obsolete design columns.
CO2Recovery_35d: time (s) until a 35-day-old virgin female stood upright after 30 s of CO2 (1 L/min); a long time is a poor performance (38 females of 7 lines). The file stores these times with floating-point noise (e.g. 166.99999999999963); they are written as Excel displays them, in whole seconds.

The authors averaged each trait per line (for geotaxis, all trials of all females), as DGRPool does, and correlated the line means. DGRPool's line means reproduce the correlations of Fig. 3 exactly: male late-life fertility vs female geotaxis distance r = -0.715 (t = -2.51, df = 6, P = 0.046), and vs CO2 recovery time r = 0.257 (t = 0.596, df = 5, P = 0.577). The Methods add that the geotaxis result is the same when zero distances are excluded; without the zeros, the correlation is r = -0.26 (P = 0.54).

Other external data available

10.5061/dryad.p888tv2 Dryad dataset with the per-fly data of all experiments (Data_Archive_Archer_et_al.xlsx)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 6 phenotypes
CO2Recovery_35d Geotaxis_35d MaleFert_35d MaleFert_35d_D1_2 MaleFert_35d_D3_4 MaleFert_35d_D5_6
8 DGRP lines
DGRP_028
DGRP_101
DGRP_136
DGRP_360
DGRP_595
DGRP_737
DGRP_783
DGRP_796
Download
Back to studies