Study

Curated
Zhang et al., 2026
Sexual size dimorphism increases with body size at the intraspecific level in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1111/een.70149]

Description

Adult body mass at emergence, larval development time and growth rate were measured on individual females and males of 10 DGRP lines reared at 25 °C and 28 °C. Female-biased size dimorphism increased with body size, driven by faster female growth.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data come from the authors' Dryad deposit (doi:10.5061/dryad.jsxksn0sb, CC0): Sample_Sizes.csv (despite its name, one row per fly) and Trait_Means.csv (per line and temperature), which accompany the paper (Ecological Entomology; preprint on bioRxiv). The lines are labelled by their Bloomington stock numbers.

Design: flies of DGRP lines were kept at 25 °C (16:8 h light:dark, 70% relative humidity; food with 40 g dry yeast, 70 g cornmeal, 70 g sugar, 10 g agar and 5 mL propionic acid per litre of water). For each line, three pairs of 5-day-old virgin females and males laid eggs in vials (20 x 75 mm, 5 mL of food), and the offspring developed at 25 °C or 28 °C. Emergence was recorded hourly, and each newly emerged fly was anaesthetized by freezing and weighed. The larval development time is the time from the midpoint of the 4-hour oviposition period to pupation (Dryad README; the preprint says the parents laid eggs for one day), and the growth rate is the adult body mass divided by the larval development time, computed per fly by the authors. The sexual size dimorphism of a line is SSD = mean female body mass / mean male body mass - 1 (Lovich & Gibbons 1992; positive values: females larger), and the growth-rate dimorphism (SGRD) is defined the same way. The authors standardized them (mean 0, SD 1) for their analyses; the files give the unstandardized values.

Results (linear mixed models with genotype as random effect, lme4): body mass, larval development time and growth rate differed among genotypes (P < 0.001). Females were heavier and grew faster than males, with the same larval development time. At 28 °C, body mass decreased (more in females), the larval stage was shorter, and growth rate decreased in females but increased in males. SSD was female-biased at both temperatures and increased with body size (standardized major axis slope > 1, a reversal of Rensch's rule within the species), and it was strongly correlated with SGRD (R2 = 0.83 at 25 °C, 0.78 at 28 °C), whereas development time did not differ between the sexes.

Raw dataset 1 (Sample_Sizes.csv): one row per fly, 2,899 flies of 10 DGRP lines, all measured at both temperatures (1,456 at 25 °C: 757 females, 699 males; 1,443 at 28 °C: 804 females, 639 males), with the body mass (BodyMass_25C, BodyMass_28C; µg), the larval development time (LarvalTime_25C, LarvalTime_28C; hours) and the growth rate (GrowthRate_25C, GrowthRate_28C; µg/h) and the vial (Vial_25C, Vial_28C, obsolete design columns). Flies reared at 25 °C and at 28 °C are different individuals: they are stacked side by side, i.e. row k of a line and sex holds the k-th fly of each temperature, and the two halves of a row are not related. Values are as in the file. The preprint mentions at least ten replicate vials per line; the file has 4 to 15 vials per line and temperature. For 22 flies of DGRP_105 at 25 °C, the growth rate in the file differs by more than 1% from body mass / larval time (growth rate x larval time / body mass from 0.89 to 1.13); it is kept as published.

Genotype not uploaded: the files hold an eleventh genotype labelled 18132 (129 flies: 84 at 25 °C, 45 at 28 °C; and its two rows of Trait_Means.csv). This is not the Bloomington stock number of any DGRP line, so its data are not uploaded.

Summary dataset (Trait_Means.csv): the authors' per-line dimorphisms mn_SSD_25C, mn_SSD_28C, mn_SGRD_25C, mn_SGRD_28C (sex NA), as published. They equal mean female / mean male - 1 of the authors' line means in the same file, but not exactly of the means computed from the per-fly data (by up to 0.031), because the authors' means of 6 line x sex x temperature groups are not reproduced by Sample_Sizes.csv: DGRP_559 females at 28 °C (104 flies in the file), DGRP_804 females at 28 °C (182 flies in the file), DGRP_804 males at 25 °C (96 flies in the file), DGRP_804 males at 28 °C (151 flies in the file), DGRP_900 males at 25 °C (135 flies in the file), DGRP_908 males at 28 °C (68 flies in the file). They were probably computed on a slightly different set of flies: the body masses are integers, and for 5 of these groups the authors' mean is a mean of integers only for 1 to 5 more flies than the file holds. The authors' line means of body mass and growth rate are therefore also uploaded as published: mn_BodyMass_25CAuth, mn_BodyMass_28CAuth, mn_GrowthRt_25CAuth, mn_GrowthRt_28CAuth. The development-time dimorphism (SDTD) is not in the files; it can be computed as the mean female / mean male larval development time - 1 of each line.

Of note: the preprint says that the mixed models used "17 genotypes (11 genotypes at 28 °C)" (residual df about 3,619 in its Table 1), while the Dryad deposit has 11 genotypes, all at both temperatures, and 3,028 flies; 10 of these lines are uploaded here. The published version could not be consulted.

Other external data available

10.5061/dryad.jsxksn0sb Dryad deposit of the paper (per-fly body mass, larval development time and growth rate; per-line means, SSD and SGRD)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 8 phenotypes
mn_BodyMass_25CAuth mn_BodyMass_28CAuth mn_GrowthRt_25CAuth mn_GrowthRt_28CAuth mn_SGRD_25C mn_SGRD_28C mn_SSD_25C mn_SSD_28C
10 DGRP lines
DGRP_105
DGRP_142
DGRP_319
DGRP_381
DGRP_559
DGRP_563
DGRP_796
DGRP_804
DGRP_900
DGRP_908
Download
Raw dataset #1 6 phenotypes
BodyMass_25C BodyMass_28C GrowthRate_25C GrowthRate_28C LarvalTime_25C LarvalTime_28C
10 DGRP lines
DGRP_105
DGRP_142
DGRP_319
DGRP_381
DGRP_559
DGRP_563
DGRP_796
DGRP_804
DGRP_900
DGRP_908
Download
Back to studies