Study

Curated
Perez et al., 2026
Wolbachia-induced Cytoplasmic Incompatibility drives epigenetic and maternally-influenced post-embryonic defects
[10.1371/journal.ppat.1014180]

Description

Egg-to-larva, larva-to-adult and egg-to-adult survival of the progeny of females of 13 DGRP lines crossed to Wolbachia-infected or uninfected Oregon-R males, and the resulting cytoplasmic incompatibility (CI) strength. The maternal genotype modulated CI-induced lethality.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from S1 Data (ppat.1014180.s002.xlsx, the figure data file) in the Supporting information of the paper (journal page, also on PMC): a single sheet with one block of columns per figure panel. Only the Fig 5 blocks use DGRP lines; the other experiments (Figs 2-4) use the Oregon-R (OreR) lab stock and were not uploaded. S1 Table (ppat.1014180.s001.docx) gives the numbers of eggs and larvae summed per line for Figs 5C, 5D and 5F.

These are phenotypes of the progeny of DGRP females crossed to a common tester, not of the inbred lines: virgin females of 13 DGRP lines (DGRP_021, 026, 028, 032, 093, 100, 136, 189, 313, 324, 350, 352 and 712, from the Bloomington stock center) were crossed to males of the OreR stock, either infected with Wolbachia (wMel) or cured of it with tetracycline. Three crosses were made:
- Control: uninfected DGRP females x uninfected OreR males;
- CI: uninfected DGRP females x wMel-infected OreR males, which causes cytoplasmic incompatibility (CI): embryonic lethality and, as this paper shows, larval lethality;
- Rescue: Wolbachia-infected DGRP females x wMel-infected OreR males (the maternal infection rescues CI), only for the six lines that were naturally infected in the authors' stocks (DGRP_028, 100, 136, 189, 352 and 712).
Each naturally infected line was split, and one subline was cured with tetracycline for three generations to provide the uninfected females of its Control and CI crosses. Values are stored under the DGRP mother line; the cross is given in the phenotype names (Ctrl, CI or Resc, and the suffix _xOreR for the common OreR father stock). Eggs, larvae and adults were not sexed, so sex is NA.

Assay: about 25-50 virgin females (1-2 days old) and as many males were mated for 24 h in a bottle with a food plate. The eggs laid during the following night (5 pm-9 am) were moved to a new food plate, and unhatched eggs were counted after 48 h at 25°C (egg-to-larva survival = hatched larvae / eggs). The plate was then kept in an empty bottle at 25°C, and emerging adults were counted over 3 days after the first emergence (larva-to-adult survival = adults / larvae; egg-to-adult survival = adults / eggs). The CI strength is the Sh index: 1 - (survival of the CI progeny / survival of the Control progeny), computed for the egg-to-larva and for the larva-to-adult stage.

The raw dataset has one row per replicate cross (eggs of the first night only; S1 Data, Figs 5A and 5F), 32 rows: 6 replicates for DGRP_032 and DGRP_352, 5 for DGRP_093, 3 for DGRP_100, 2 for DGRP_021, DGRP_189 and DGRP_712, and 1 for the other six lines. Row k of a line holds the k-th Control, CI and Rescue replicate of S1 Data:
- EggLarva_, LarvAdult_ and EggAdult_ followed by Ctrl_xOreR, CI_xOreR or Resc_xOreR: egg-to-larva, larva-to-adult and egg-to-adult survival (proportions, 0-1) of the progeny of each cross.
- ShEggLarva_xOreR and ShLarvAdult_xOreR: the authors' Sh values for the pair of CI and Control replicates on the same row (S1 Data, Fig 5F; they equal 1 - CI/Control of the row for all 32 pairs). Negative values mean that the CI progeny survived better than the Control progeny.
- Eggs_ and Larvae_ followed by the cross (obsolete): numbers of eggs scored and of hatched larvae in each replicate, i.e. the sample sizes of the survival values.
Figs 5D (Sh of DGRP_032, 093, 100 and 352) and 5E (survival of DGRP_100 and 352) show subsets of these rows.

The summary dataset has the CI strength of the authors' initial screen (Fig 5C), in which the eggs of one Control and one CI cross per line were collected over three successive nights: mn_ShEggLarv3N_xOreR and mn_ShLarvAd3N_xOreR, Sh values computed by the authors from the counts summed over the three nights (13 lines). They are pooled values (one per line), uploaded with the summary type mean. S1 Table gives the summed numbers of eggs and larvae, which reproduce the egg-to-larva Sh of all 13 lines (the adult counts were not published). They agree poorly with the line means of the first-night Sh of the raw dataset (Spearman rho = 0.16 for egg-to-larva and 0.34 for larva-to-adult); the authors used only first-night collections after the screen because CI strength decreases with time.

Checks: the raw dataset reproduces the statistics of the paper: the Fig 5A means ± SD among replicates (for example egg-to-adult survival: Control 71.5 ± 14.7%, CI 51.9 ± 16.0%, Rescue 86.6 ± 11.9%, vs 71 ± 15%, 52 ± 16% and 87 ± 12% in the text) and Dunn's test p-values, the Fig 5E means and p-values, the Fig 5D Kruskal-Wallis tests (p = 0.635 and 0.032, vs 0.64 and 0.032) and the Fig 5F correlation between the two Sh values (r = 0.130, p = 0.479, vs R = 0.13, p = 0.48). The only difference is the mean egg hatch of the CI crosses, 78.6% vs 77% in the text.

Of note, three replicate rows of S1 Data have errors, kept as published (the authors' statistics and Sh values use the survival values as given):
- DGRP_028, CI: 122 larvae, but its survival values (0.707 = 106/150) and S1 Table give 106 (122 is the number of the Control replicate).
- DGRP_032, second CI replicate: its 100 eggs, 55 larvae and egg-to-adult survival of 0.36 (36 adults) agree with each other and with S1 Table, but not with its egg-to-larva (0.827 = 124/150) and larva-to-adult (0.492 = 61/124) survival, which give an egg-to-adult survival of 0.407 and are the values used for its Sh.
- DGRP_352, Control: the 4th and 6th replicates are identical (150 eggs, 148 larvae); both are counted in S1 Table.

The Wolbachia status is the one of the authors' stocks (checked by PCR). The Methods also list DGRP 93 among the infected stocks, but the Results name six infected lines and no Rescue cross was made with DGRP 93. In the DGRP annotation, DGRP_021 is infected and DGRP_028 is not.

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 2 phenotypes
mn_ShEggLarv3N_xOreR mn_ShLarvAd3N_xOreR
13 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_028
DGRP_032
DGRP_093
DGRP_100
DGRP_136
DGRP_189
DGRP_313
DGRP_324
DGRP_350
DGRP_352
DGRP_712
Download
Raw dataset #1 11 phenotypes
EggAdult_CI_xOreR EggAdult_Ctrl_xOreR EggAdult_Resc_xOreR EggLarva_CI_xOreR EggLarva_Ctrl_xOreR EggLarva_Resc_xOreR LarvAdult_CI_xOreR LarvAdult_Ctrl_xOreR LarvAdult_Resc_xOreR ShEggLarva_xOreR ShLarvAdult_xOreR
13 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_028
DGRP_032
DGRP_093
DGRP_100
DGRP_136
DGRP_189
DGRP_313
DGRP_324
DGRP_350
DGRP_352
DGRP_712
Download
Back to studies