Study

Curated
Everman et al., 2018
Costs of cold acclimation on survival and reproductive behavior in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1371/journal.pone.0197822]

Description

Survival after 1 h at -6 °C, with or without prior acclimation at 4 °C (rapid cold-hardening), was measured in both sexes of 19 DGRP lines, with courtship latency, courtship duration and mating success of acclimated or control pairs, and male courtship song in 5 lines.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from S1 File (raw data, pone.0197822.s005.xlsx) in the Supporting information of the paper (also on PMC). S1 Table (pone.0197822.s004.docx) gives the sample sizes. The 19 DGRP lines (RAL_93 to RAL_849) were chosen for their variation in cold tolerance and rapid cold-hardening (RCH) capacity in Gerken et al. 2015 (PNAS), and were measured again in this study. Flies were reared at 25 °C on cornmeal/molasses/agar food. The study has three raw datasets.

raw_1: cold tolerance (sheet "Cold Tolerance Data", 19 lines, both sexes). Vials of 10 non-virgin flies of one sex, 5-7 days old, were exposed to -6 °C for 1 h, either directly (ColdSurv_Basal, basal cold tolerance) or after 2 h at 4 °C (ColdSurv_Acc, cold tolerance after acclimation by RCH). Survival is the proportion of the vial alive after 24 h of recovery at 25 °C (a few vials had 7-11 flies). There are 4 vials per line, sex and treatment. Each row of the file pairs one acclimated vial with one basal vial, and RCH_Capacity is the authors' difference between the two (acclimated - basal) for that row. Its mean per line and sex is the paper's RCH capacity (mean acclimated survival - mean basal survival). Its SD depends on the arbitrary pairing of the vials and should not be used.

raw_2: mating latency assay (sheet "Mating Latency Data", 534 single-pair trials, 5-8 per line and treatment combination, 19 lines). Virgin males and females of a line, 7 days old, were either acclimated (2 h at 4 °C, then 1 h of recovery at 25 °C) or kept at 25 °C (control). They were then paired in the four combinations of male and female treatment (phenotype suffixes _mCtl_fCtl, _mCtl_fAcc, _mAcc_fCtl, _mAcc_fAcc) and observed for 4 h at 25 °C in a vial with food. Each value comes from a male-female pair of the line, so the sex is NA.
- CourtLat: courtship latency (s), the time until the male started courting. Males that never courted have 14,400 s (4 h), as in the file (44 pairs), because the authors included this value in their courtship latency analysis.
- CopLat: copulation latency (s), the time from pairing to copulation. It is NA when the pair did not mate within 4 h (14,400 s in the file, 193 pairs). It is not analysed in the paper.
- CourtDur: courtship duration (s), copulation latency - courtship latency. It is NA for the unmated pairs, as in the authors' second courtship duration column. It is also NA for the 48 mated pairs whose duration is 0 in the file (courtship start recorded at the time of copulation), because the authors excluded them too. The S1 Table counts match the pairs with a positive duration (293 pairs vs 294 in S1 Table; DGRP_367 differs by one). The paper's line-level regressions are also reproduced only without these 48 pairs.
- Mated: 1 if the pair copulated within the 4 h, 0 otherwise. The mean per line is the proportion of pairs that mated.
Pairs of different treatment combinations are independent. To keep the dataset compact, row k of a line holds the k-th pair (in the order of the file) of each combination. On a row, the four phenotypes of one combination come from the same pair.

raw_3: courtship song (sheets "Song Summary Data" and "First and Last Min of Song Data"). The song was recorded for 148 males of 5 lines (DGRP_153, DGRP_195, DGRP_362, DGRP_365, DGRP_517), chosen for their high RCH capacity and their strongly negative behavioural plasticity, with 11-18 males per line and treatment. Virgin males, 7 days old, either acclimated (suffix _mAcc, as above) or kept at 25 °C (_mCtl), were each paired with a control virgin female. They were recorded with an Insectavox-type microphone and video until copulation, or for about 15 min. The sex is M, because these are male traits.
- SongIPI: mean interpulse interval of the song (ms), corrected to 25 °C (slope -1.0437 ms/°C). It is given only for songs with at least 15 IPIs.
- IPI1stMin and IPILastMin: mean IPI in the first and last minute of the song, for 88 songs. They are in S1 File but are not used in the paper.
- CourtIdx: courtship index, the proportion of the courtship duration during which the male was actively courting.
- SongIdx: song index, the proportion of the courtship duration spent singing. Like SongIPI, it is given only for songs with at least 15 IPIs.
- SongCourtDur: courtship duration in this assay (s). For unmated males, it runs until the end of the recording, as in the paper's analysis, which included mating status as a factor.
- SongMated: 1 if the pair copulated during the recording, 0 otherwise.
- Obsolete design columns: SongRecLen (recording length, s) and SongID (the authors' song ID). The SongID links each male to its individual IPIs in the "IPI Data" sheet, which is not uploaded.
The rows are compact, as in raw_2: row k of a line holds the k-th male of each treatment.

Derived values were not published per line, so they are not uploaded:
- The RCH capacity of a line is the mean of RCH_Capacity, or mean ColdSurv_Acc - mean ColdSurv_Basal.
- The paper's behavioural plasticity of a line is mean CourtDur_mCtl_fCtl - mean CourtDur_mAcc_fCtl.
- The paper's regressions of courtship latency on male cold tolerance used only the pairs that have a courtship duration: the mean of CourtLat_* over the rows where CourtDur_* of the same combination is not NA.
With these definitions, the uploaded data reproduce all the F values of the paper's line-level regressions. For example, control courtship duration vs male RCH capacity gives F(1,17) = 3.91 (paper: 3.9), and plasticity vs RCH capacity gives F = 0.18, P = 0.67, as in the paper.

Of note:
- The χ2 of mating success by male treatment computed from S1 File (25.7) differs from the paper's (20.2), but both are highly significant.
- In the song assay, S1 File has 70 control males, of which 50 mated (71.4%). The paper reports 72.5% and χ2 = 6.92, which correspond to one unmated control male fewer.
- The paper states that 74 songs had at least 15 IPIs, but S1 File has a mean IPI for 92 songs, which is consistent with the degrees of freedom in the paper's Table 2.

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 3 phenotypes
ColdSurv_Acc ColdSurv_Basal RCH_Capacity
19 DGRP lines
DGRP_093
DGRP_101
DGRP_136
DGRP_153
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_195
DGRP_304
DGRP_336
DGRP_352
DGRP_359
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_406
DGRP_440
DGRP_517
DGRP_849
Download
Raw dataset #2 16 phenotypes
CopLat_mAcc_fAcc CopLat_mAcc_fCtl CopLat_mCtl_fAcc CopLat_mCtl_fCtl CourtDur_mAcc_fAcc CourtDur_mAcc_fCtl CourtDur_mCtl_fAcc CourtDur_mCtl_fCtl CourtLat_mAcc_fAcc CourtLat_mAcc_fCtl CourtLat_mCtl_fAcc CourtLat_mCtl_fCtl Mated_mAcc_fAcc Mated_mAcc_fCtl Mated_mCtl_fAcc Mated_mCtl_fCtl
19 DGRP lines
DGRP_093
DGRP_101
DGRP_136
DGRP_153
DGRP_176
DGRP_177
DGRP_195
DGRP_304
DGRP_336
DGRP_352
DGRP_359
DGRP_361
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_367
DGRP_406
DGRP_440
DGRP_517
DGRP_849
Download
Raw dataset #3 14 phenotypes
CourtIdx_mAcc CourtIdx_mCtl IPI1stMin_mAcc IPI1stMin_mCtl IPILastMin_mAcc IPILastMin_mCtl SongCourtDur_mAcc SongCourtDur_mCtl SongIPI_mAcc SongIPI_mCtl SongIdx_mAcc SongIdx_mCtl SongMated_mAcc SongMated_mCtl
5 DGRP lines
DGRP_153
DGRP_195
DGRP_362
DGRP_365
DGRP_517
Download
Back to studies