Study

Rejected
Scharenbrock et al., 2020
Interactions among Genetic Background, Anesthetic Agent, and Oxygen Concentration Shape Blunt Traumatic Brain Injury Outcomes in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.3390/ijms21186926][FBrf0246825]

Description

Rejected: no per-line data. Mortality and climbing after traumatic brain injury were measured in mixed-sex flies of 10 DGRP lines exposed to oxygen, isoflurane or sevoflurane, but per-line values are only shown in figures.

Comments from curator

Rejected: no per-line phenotype data are available for this study.

The authors selected ten DGRP lines from their earlier screen of 141 DGRP lines (Schiffman et al., 2020): the five lines with the highest excess mortality from a 1 h exposure to isoflurane in 100% oxygen after traumatic brain injury (TBI) (high Δ group: DGRP_373, DGRP_382, DGRP_491, DGRP_761 and DGRP_859) and the five lines with the lowest (low Δ group: DGRP_083, DGRP_332, DGRP_374, DGRP_707 and DGRP_818). Mixed-sex groups of 20 flies aged 1-8 days, raised on molasses food at 25 °C, were injured in room air with the High-Impact Trauma (HIT) device (four strikes, 5 min apart). They were then exposed for 1 h to 100% O2, to 2% isoflurane in 100% O2 (ISO/O2) or to 3.5% sevoflurane in 100% O2 (SEVO/O2), or left in room air (TBI alone). Uninjured flies were handled in parallel. Two phenotypes were scored 24 h and 48 h after TBI:
- Mortality index (MI24 and MI48): percent mortality of the injured flies, corrected for the mortality of the uninjured flies, from at least three biological replicates (each made of two vials of 20 flies) per line and condition.
- Percent impaired climbing: percent of the live flies that did not climb out of the lowest of four 2.5 cm zones of the container within 10 s after being tapped down (a modified rapid iterative negative geotaxis assay, RING), in uninjured and injured flies, with and without exposure.

Per-line values are only shown as plots in the paper (PMC version): bar plots of the mean MI24 (Figure 1) and MI48 (Figure A1) per line and condition, the percent impaired climbing at 24 h (Figure 5) and 48 h (Figure A14), and the distribution of the flies of each line over the four climbing zones (Figures A4-A13 of Appendix A). The legend of Figure 1 gives the mean ± SD MI24 of only four lines (DGRP_332, DGRP_373, DGRP_382 and DGRP_859), and for some conditions only. The article has no supplementary files and no data availability statement, and it cites no data repository, so per-line values could not be retrieved.

Of note, the MI24 after TBI alone was also measured on DGRP lines in Katzenberger et al., 2015. These are separate measurements, not the data of this study.

4 categories

Behaviour Resistance Toxicity Locomotion

No phenotype

No data

DGRP lines

None

Datasets

Back to studies