Study

Curated
Sabarís et al., 2025
A mechanistic basis for genetic assimilation in natural fly populations
[10.1073/pnas.2415982122]

Description

Ectopic wing vein penetrance was scored in females of four DGRP lines without and after a pupal heat shock (40 °C), at the start of a Waddington genetic assimilation experiment. The trait was assimilated in DGRP_907 and in a mix of the four lines, not in DGRP_208.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from Dataset S6 ("Number of flies scored in the recapitulation of the Waddington selection experiment", file pnas.2415982122.sd06.xlsx) of the PNAS Supporting Information (also in PMC11929479): sheets D (D907), G (D208) and I (D437 and D820) give, for each generation of the heat-shock selection line of each DGRP line, the number of females scored, the number with ectopic wing veins (EV) and the % EV. The paper names the lines D208, D437, D820 and D907; their Bloomington numbers in Dataset S5 (25174, 25194, 25208, 28262) are those of DGRP_208, DGRP_437, DGRP_820 and DGRP_907.

Phenotypes: the authors recapitulated Waddington's genetic assimilation experiment with the ectopic vein phenocopy. Flies were reared on cornmeal-yeast food at 25 °C. Pupae were heat-shocked at 40 °C for 4 h (0 to 27 h after puparium formation) and then developed at 25 °C; adults were scored for EV during their first 2 days, females only. Only the first two rows of each line are measurements of the DGRP line itself, and only they are uploaded: EctopicVein_NoHS, the starting population (P0) without heat shock, and EctopicVein_HS, the first generation of the heat-shock selection. The paper does not say whether the P0 parents of generation 1 were selected for EV.

Raw dataset 1, one row = one female (sex F): 1 if she had ectopic veins, 0 if not, reconstructed from the published counts (the n females with EV coded 1 and the others 0; their order within a line is arbitrary). The two conditions are different females, stacked in the same rows (row k holds the k-th female of each condition, NA where a condition has fewer females). DGRPool's line mean is the proportion of females with EV, i.e. the authors' % EV divided by 100, for all 8 line x condition values (e.g. DGRP_907: 27.5% without and 60.5% after heat shock). 402 females were scored without and 659 after heat shock (80 to 284 per line and condition).

Not uploaded: the later generations of the heat-shock selection (2 to 11 for D208 and D907; 2 and 3 for D437 and D820, which went extinct after three generations of heat shock), the assimilated and non-assimilated selection lines derived from D208 and D907, and the outbred Mix population made from the four lines (Dataset S6, sheets A to H), because they are selected populations rather than the DGRP lines; the EV expressivity scores (0 to 8 per fly, figures only); the crossveinless phenocopy (SI Fig. S1B, figure only); the RNAi and CRISPR experiments of Dataset S5 (not DGRP lines). The EV trait was assimilated in the Mix population and in D907, but never in D208.

Source oddities: in sheet A, the P0 counts of the Mix population (experiment 1: 93 females, 14 with EV) are identical to those of D437, possibly a copy error; the D437 values are kept as published. The text says that "D438 and D820" went extinct; Dataset S6 and SI Fig. S2I show that it is D437.

The sequencing data of the selection lines (RNA-seq, CUT&RUN, Hi-C and Pool-seq) are in GEO SuperSeries GSE255496.

Other external data available

GSE255496 RNA-seq, CUT&RUN, Hi-C and Pool-seq of the Mix, D907 and D208 selection lines (SuperSeries)

4 DGRP lines 4 genotyped

DGRP_208 DGRP_437 DGRP_820 DGRP_907

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 2 phenotypes
EctopicVein_HS EctopicVein_NoHS
4 DGRP lines
DGRP_208
DGRP_437
DGRP_820
DGRP_907
Download
Back to studies