Study

Curated
Serrato-Capuchina et al., 2020
Paternally Inherited P-Element Copy Number Affects the Magnitude of Hybrid Dysgenesis in Drosophila simulans and D. melanogaster
[10.1093/gbe/evaa084]

Description

Hybrid dysgenesis was scored in F1 daughters of 7 DGRP males crossed to Canton-S (M) or DGRP385 (P) females: number of non-atrophied ovaries and ovarioles per ovary, at 23 and 29 °C and (4 lines) over 17-29 °C. Dysgenesis increased with the paternal P-element copy number at 29 °C.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data come from the authors' Dryad dataset (doi:10.5061/dryad.w3r2280mr, CC0; files used: PE_copy_melanogaster.csv, averages_PEs_temps_POSMel.csv, averages_copy_temp_mel.csv, copy_number_plots.csv, pecopies_temp_interaction_mel.csv). The supplementary data of the paper only list the lines (Tables S1-S2) and model results.

Design (paper, Materials and Methods): males of 21 D. melanogaster lines, 7 DGRP P lines (DGRP_208, DGRP_301, DGRP_303, DGRP_304, DGRP_315, DGRP_324 and DGRP_385; "BCM-DGRP" lines of Table S1) and 14 African isofemale lines, were crossed to females of an M line (Canton-S, no P element) and of a P line (DGRP385). Virgin F1 daughters aged 4-9 days were dissected: number of non-atrophied ovaries (0, 1 or 2; an atrophied ovary has no ovarioles) and mean number of ovarioles per ovary, at 23 and 29 °C (the Methods say 50 females per cross; the file has 20). In a temperature series, 10 paternal lines (0 to 20.39 P-element copies) were crossed to the same two mothers at 17, 19, 21, 23, 25, 27 and 29 °C (20 females per cross). P-element and hobo copy numbers of each paternal line were estimated from Illumina read coverage (mean coverage of the element / mean genome coverage; published DGRP reads for the DGRP lines). The D. simulans half of the paper does not use DGRP lines.

Upload: only the crosses with a DGRP father are kept (the African lines and Canton-S as a father are not DGRP lines and were dropped). One row per F1 female, sex F; the values are stored under the DGRP father, and the suffix of the phenotype names gives the mother: _xCS = Canton-S (M) mothers, _x385 = DGRP385 (P) mothers (for DGRP_385 itself, the _x385 values are those of the pure line, not of an F1). Ovaries = number of non-atrophied ovaries (0-2); Ovarioles = mean number of ovarioles per ovary, as in the file. Inconsistency of the source: 22 (raw_1) and 31 (raw_2) females with 0 non-atrophied ovaries have a positive ovariole number in the file, although the Methods define an atrophied ovary as one without ovarioles and say that these females were excluded from the ovariole analyses. The authors' averages (Figure 7 heatmaps, Dryad averages files) and their R models include these values, so they are kept as published. The file also gives the mean ovariole numbers rounded to integers (columns *_approx, used for the authors' Poisson models); they are not uploaded. Both traits of a female are on the same row; row k of a line holds the k-th female of each mother x temperature condition, so values in different conditions on the same row come from different females.
- raw_1: crosses at 23 and 29 °C (140 rows, 7 DGRP fathers).
- raw_2: temperature series (names with _TS<temperature>), the 4 DGRP fathers among its 10 paternal lines (DGRP_208, DGRP_303, DGRP_304, DGRP_315).
- summary: PE_CopyNumber and hobo_CopyNumber, the authors' copy-number estimates of the DGRP lines (genome values of the line, sex NA), as given in the per-female file.

Checks: 20 females per DGRP father x mother x temperature in raw_1 (Methods: 50). The authors' averages of the temperature series with DGRP385 (P) mothers (averages_PEs_temps_POSMel.csv) equal DGRPool's means of raw_2 (28 values). The authors' averages of the temperature series with Canton-S (M) mothers (averages_copy_temp_mel.csv) equal DGRPool's means of raw_2 (28 values).

The paper relates these traits to the paternal P-element copy number per cross (multinomial and Poisson models): with M mothers at 29 °C, ovary and ovariole numbers decrease as paternal copy number increases; with P mothers they do not.

Related DGRPool study: study 31 (Srivastav and Kelleher 2017, paternal induction of hybrid dysgenesis across the DGRP).

Other external data available

PRJNA622255 Illumina and Nanopore genome sequencing of the non-DGRP lines of the study
Back to studies