Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from the
Supplementary Materials of the paper (
journal page, also on
PMC; archive medicines-13-00024-s001.zip, file medicines-4163825-supplementary.pdf). The authors published only model-estimated values per line (post hoc estimated marginal means with their standard errors, 95% CIs and letters); the raw data are "available upon request". The study therefore has a summary dataset only (one row per line and sex, mn_ = estimated marginal mean, se_ = its standard error, copied exactly as printed; the CIs and letters are not uploaded).
Lines: Table S1 gives Lines 1-5 (L1-L5) = DGRP_195, DGRP_379, DGRP_362, DGRP_517 and DGRP_358 (Bloomington 28153, 25189, 25187, 25197 and 25185), kept about two years in the laboratory at 19 °C, then two generations at 25 °C before the experiment.
Design (generational experiment, 25 °C, 12:12 h light:dark): five treatments:
C control;
J20 and
J40: 20 or 40 mM paracetamol in the larval food (50 eggs per vial);
A40 and
A80: 40 or 80 mM paracetamol in the food for 5 days, starting about 3 days after eclosion.
F0 = the exposed flies;
F1 and
F2 = their unexposed offspring and grand-offspring (eggs laid more than 3 days after the end of exposure), named after the F0 treatment of their lineage. Phenotype names are <statistic>_<trait>_<generation>_<treatment>. F0 flies were tested 3 days after the end of the adult exposure: males at 9-13 days, females at 11-15 days.
-
PMove (Tables S5, females, and S8, males): spontaneous locomotor activity of single flies filmed in arenas at 25 °C and tracked with EthoVision (2 points per second); the first 10 min were discarded and the distance was averaged per minute; a minute counts as active above 0.018 cm. Probability that a fly moves in a given minute (binomial mixed model Activity ~ Treat*Gen + Line*Gen + Treat*Line + (1|fly); 1185 females and 1275 males). Unit Proportion / Ratio.
-
Dist (Tables S11, females, and S14, males): distance moved in the active minutes (beta regression for females, linear model for males, same terms), in cm as given in the paper ("distance moved per minute"; per the Methods, the average of the tracked distances, 2 per second, within each minute). One male estimate is slightly negative (DGRP_362, F2, A40: -0.000772), as published.
-
StarvTime (Table S20, see below): time to death of females on 2% agar (water, no food), photographed every hour; accelerated failure time model (Weibull) with the same terms and clustering by Petri dish (1875 females, 128 dishes); flies dying within 10 h and females surviving more than 80 h were censored by the authors. Unit Hours.
Of note:-
Table S8 (male probability of moving) is printed with the generation and line labels of the other tables (generation, then line), but its 15 blocks of 5 values are in the order line, then generation (L1 F0, L1 F1, L1 F2, L2 F0...). The values were assigned in that order: they then match main-text Table 4 in all 75 cells (letters included, one rounding difference) and their average over lines (on the logit scale) reproduces the line-averaged Table S7 (relative difference < 10
-7), while with the printed labels 60 of the 75 cells disagree with Table 4.
-
Starvation tables: Table S20, captioned as the male lognormal model, holds the values of the female Weibull model: their geometric mean over the 5 lines equals the female line-averaged means of Table S16 in all 15 generation x treatment cells (relative difference < 10
-8), whereas the male Table S19 values are about half (e.g. F0 control: 54.5 h in S16, 27.5 h in S19); they agree with the female results of the text (only L5 differs from L1, β = -0.325: 41.4 vs 57.3 h in F0 controls; in F1, A80 shorter than A40 in L3). Table S17, captioned female, repeats the same means and standard errors but with 95% CIs (70 of 75 do not contain their mean) and letters of the male model (the CI centres average to Table S19; the letters match the male results of the text). The S20 values are uploaded as female starvation times and Table S17 is not used; the male per-line starvation values are not published (the male line-averaged values of Table S19 and main-text Table 6 are not per line).
- Small differences between the supplementary tables (uploaded) and main-text Tables 3 and 4, probably rounding or typing errors of the main text: female probability of moving (S5 vs Table 3): F0 L2 A40 0.03827797 vs 3.87% (a), F1 L1 J40 0.93288917 vs 93.2% (b), F2 All A80 0.131361089 vs 12.1% (a); female distance (S11 vs Table 3): F0 L1 C 0.14597053 vs 0.145 (b), F2 L1 A80 0.09244056 vs 0.072 (ab), F0 L2 A80 letters b vs ab, F2 L2 J20 letters ab vs b; male probability of moving (S8 vs Table 4): F0 L1 C 0.79574263 vs 79.5% (a); male distance (S14 vs Table 4): F1 L4 A40 0.15430513 vs 0.156 (a), F2 L3 A40 -0.000772 vs 0.000 (a).
Not uploaded: the dose-response experiment (egg-to-adult survival of 50 eggs per vial at 0-75 mM paracetamol, 19 and 25 °C, 3 vials per line and dose), shown only in Figure 1 and as model coefficients (Tables 1 and S2); the line-averaged tables (S4, S7, S10, S13, S16, S19, main-text Tables 3, 4 and 6).