Study

Curated
Hunter et al., 2014
Do males matter? Testing the effects of male genetic background on female meiotic crossover rates in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1111/evo.12455]

Description

Female meiotic crossover frequency in the X y-v interval was measured in a 10 x 10 diallel of DGRP lines: F1 (line x y v) females mated to males of each line, early and late broods. Female, not male, background affected crossing over. Within-line crosses are uploaded.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the Dryad deposit of the paper (doi:10.5061/dryad.gk42k; same file on Zenodo): ID 14-0134.R1.xlsx, the progeny counts of each of the 4,000 vials of the experiment by phenotypic class. The paper (doi:10.1111/evo.12455) only gives ANOVA tables and figures.

Design. These are F1 phenotypes: 20 virgin females of each of 10 DGRP lines (DGRP_021, 026, 038, 040, 045, 057, 059, 073, 075 and 136) were crossed to 20 y1 v1 males (marked X chromosome in an isogenic Samarkand background). Groups of 10 virgin F1 (+ +/y v) females were then mated for 6 h to 10 males of each of the 10 DGRP lines: a full 10 x 10 diallel of "Female Line" x "Male Line", in 2 blocks of 2 replicate vials. The females were transferred daily to fresh vials for 10 days (25°C). Only the sons show the maternal X markers: recombinant sons carry a single marker (y + or + v); daughters were only counted. The crossover frequency of a vial is the number of recombinant sons divided by the number of sons scored (33 cM interval; double crossovers are not detected). It measures crossing over in the meiosis of the F1 (DGRP/y v) females, like Recomb_xyv of study 167 (Hunter et al. 2016, PLoS Genet, same lab, 204 lines). Study 278 (Hunter et al. 2016, G3) followed five of these lines over maternal age.

Uploaded: the within-line crosses only, i.e. F1 females mated to males of their own DGRP line (the diagonal of the diallel, 400 of the 4,000 vials), stored under that line with sex F and the suffix _xyv. The 90 other combinations mate the F1 females of one line with males of another DGRP line and are not uploaded; the paper's main per-line result, the female-background means over all 10 male lines (28.3 to 37.6 cM), comes from all of them.
The raw dataset has one row per vial of 10 F1 females and day. The authors split the 10 days into an early (days 1-5) and a late brood (days 6-10), a significant factor of their model (over all crosses, 31.4 cM early vs 34.0 cM late), so each phenotype exists for both broods: Recomb_xyv_Early/Late (crossover frequency, 0-1; x100 = cM), NMale_xyv_Early/Late (sons scored) and NFem_xyv_Early/Late (daughters). A row holds the vials of day k (early) and day k+5 (late) of the same 10 females; Block (1-2), Replicate (A-D coded 1-4) and BroodDay (k, 1-5) are obsolete design columns. The crossover frequency is NA for the 17 vials without any son (3 early, 14 late); counts are as published. DGRPool's line means are means of vial frequencies; the authors' pooled frequency (all recombinant sons / all sons) is the mean of Recomb weighted by NMale.

Checks: the file reproduces the totals of the paper exactly (152,547 progeny, 73,870 sons, 12,356 y + and 11,604 + v recombinants), and the pooled crossover frequencies of the female lines over all crosses range from 28.35 to 37.61 cM (paper: 28.3 to 37.6 cM, a 9.26 cM range). The within-line crosses alone give pooled frequencies of 18.5 cM (DGRP_045, 406 sons) to 37.1 cM (DGRP_026).

Of note: DGRP_026, DGRP_038 and DGRP_136 carry autosomal inversions; the authors also ran their models on the 7 other lines. Male genetic background had no effect on crossing over (P = 0.69) but affected the number of daughters (P = 0.004).

Other external data available

10.5061/dryad.gk42k Dryad deposit of the paper (progeny counts of every vial of the 10 x 10 diallel)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 6 phenotypes
NFem_xyv_Early NFem_xyv_Late NMale_xyv_Early NMale_xyv_Late Recomb_xyv_Early Recomb_xyv_Late
10 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_038
DGRP_040
DGRP_045
DGRP_057
DGRP_059
DGRP_073
DGRP_075
DGRP_136
Download
Back to studies