Study

Curated
Garcia et al., 2020
Distinct cold tolerance traits independently vary across genotypes in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1111/evo.14025]

Description

Short- and long-term cold survival, chill coma recovery, critical thermal minimum (CTmin) and climbing before and after cold were measured in males and females of 12 DGRP lines, with the cold-induced expression of Hsp70 and Frost. Few traits correlated across lines.

Comments from curator

The data of this study come from the authors' Dryad dataset (doi:10.5061/dryad.9kd51c5dn, also on Zenodo), file Genetic_Variance_Master_Data_File.xlsx: one sheet per assay with the raw data (per vial, per fly or per qPCR sample), and a Data Compiled sheet with line means and SEM. The DGRP line of each code (1-12) is taken from Suppl. Table 1 of the Supporting Information (1 = DGRP_208, 2 = DGRP_313, 3 = DGRP_786, 4 = DGRP_852, 5 = DGRP_380, 6 = DGRP_399, 7 = DGRP_375, 8 = DGRP_379, 9 = DGRP_437, 10 = DGRP_517, 11 = DGRP_555, 12 = DGRP_365).

Design: 12 lines of the DGRP Core 40, chosen for their high, average or low cold-shock survival in Teets & Hahn 2018 (DGRPool study 182; 4 lines per category, Suppl. Table 1), males and females assayed separately. Survival was scored in vials of about 20 flies after a short-term (a 1-h cold shock at -2 °C) and a long-term (24 h at 4 °C) cold exposure. Chill coma recovery (CCR) time after 4 h at 0 °C and critical thermal minimum (CTmin, in a column cooled by 0.25 °C/min) were measured on individual flies. Climbing (RING negative geotaxis assay: height climbed in 4 s, third of three trials) was recorded per fly in vials of up to 20 flies before and after 12 h at 4 °C (and 24 h of recovery). The expression of Hsp70 and Frost (Fst) was measured by qPCR relative to Rp49 in groups of 20 flies, control (25 °C) or cold-exposed (4 h at 0 °C followed by 2 h of recovery at 25 °C).

raw_1 (one row per fly): CCR_Time (s) as in the CCR sheet, including the 41 flies marked as censored (column Censor = 1, kept as the obsolete column CCR_Censor): 40 flies that had not recovered at the end of the 60-min observation (time 3600 s, treated as censored in the authors' Cox regressions) and one fly censored at 315 s; the authors' compiled means include these times. CTmin (°C; whole degrees in the file, although the methods say that the collection vials were changed every 0.5 °C). ClimbHt_Pre and ClimbHt_Post: height climbed by each fly before and after the cold exposure (0 = did not climb; the authors' mean heights include these 0), with the vial in the obsolete column ClimbVial; the same vials were tested before and after cold, but the flies were not followed individually: row k of a vial holds its k-th value before and its k-th value after cold. The flies of the different assays are independent and stacked (row k of a line and sex holds the k-th fly of each assay).

raw_2 (one row per vial, assays stacked): ColdSurv_Short and ColdSurv_Long, proportion of the flies of the vial alive after the short- and long-term cold exposure (= alive / initial, as in the file), with the number of flies of the vial (NFlies_Short, NFlies_Long) and the vial number (LongVial, 1-2) as obsolete columns; ClimbProp_Pre and ClimbProp_Post, proportion of the flies of a climbing vial that climbed (the authors' "motivation"), with the number of flies (NFlies_ClimbPre, NFlies_ClimbPost) and the vial (ClimbVialNo) as obsolete columns.

raw_3 (qPCR): dCT_Hsp70_Ctrl, dCT_Hsp70_Cold, dCT_Fst_Ctrl and dCT_Fst_Cold: ΔCT of the gene (CT of the gene minus CT of Rp49; higher = lower expression) in control (C) and cold-exposed (E) samples, as in the file; the CTs of the three genes are kept as obsolete columns (CT_Rp49_*, CT_Hsp70_*, CT_Fst_*). Three samples per line, sex and treatment; row k holds the k-th control and the k-th cold-exposed sample (independent samples).

Of note: the per-sex means of the Data Compiled sheet differ from the raw sheets in a few places, while the raw sheets are internally consistent. For the short-term survival, the female and male means of 4 lines are exchanged (or, for one line, mixed) relative to the Short-Term sheet; the line means agree, and the female survival figure of the paper (Fig. S5A) follows the Short-Term sheet. The compiled CCR means of 2 lines differ by one fly that the raw sheet assigns to another line, and a few other compiled means (CCR, CTmin, proportion climbed) differ slightly. The raw sheets are uploaded as they are. 180 CCR times stored with floating-point noise (e.g. 1026.0000000000002) are written as whole seconds. In 7 climbing vial phases (vials 81-84) the number of flies given for the vial differs by 1-2 from the number of heights recorded. The file holds fewer flies than the methods state for CCR (33-65 flies per line vs 80) and CTmin (40-65 vs 80), and about 4 climbing vials per line and sex (97 in all) vs 8. In Suppl. Table 1 the Bloomington numbers of DGRP-208 (25147) and DGRP-517 (25179, the number of DGRP-307) differ from those of the DGRP lines (25174 and 25197); the genotype names of the table are used.

Not uploaded: the line means and SEM of the Data Compiled sheet (DGRPool computes the means from the raw data), and the induction of Hsp70 and Frost (ΔΔCT, cold minus control), which can be derived from the ΔCT phenotypes. The paper correlates line means of the cold-induced change in climbing (Δ performance = mean height after minus before cold, per vial; Δ willingness = the same for the proportion climbing), which can be derived from the uploaded phenotypes. Related DGRPool studies from the same lab: 182 (Teets & Hahn 2018: cold-shock survival of 36 DGRP lines, from which these 12 lines were chosen), 195 (CTmin and CTmax of 100 lines) and 290 (diet and cold tolerance of 6 of these lines: 208, 313, 379, 399, 555 and 852).

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 4 phenotypes
CCR_Time CTmin ClimbHt_Post ClimbHt_Pre
12 DGRP lines
DGRP_208
DGRP_313
DGRP_365
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_399
DGRP_437
DGRP_517
DGRP_555
DGRP_786
DGRP_852
Download
Raw dataset #2 4 phenotypes
ClimbProp_Post ClimbProp_Pre ColdSurv_Long ColdSurv_Short
12 DGRP lines
DGRP_208
DGRP_313
DGRP_365
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_399
DGRP_437
DGRP_517
DGRP_555
DGRP_786
DGRP_852
Download
Raw dataset #3 4 phenotypes
dCT_Fst_Cold dCT_Fst_Ctrl dCT_Hsp70_Cold dCT_Hsp70_Ctrl
12 DGRP lines
DGRP_208
DGRP_313
DGRP_365
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_380
DGRP_399
DGRP_437
DGRP_517
DGRP_555
DGRP_786
DGRP_852
Download
Back to studies