Study

Curated
Adhikari et al., 2025
Ovariole number does not predict reproductive output or trade-off with immunity in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1371/journal.pone.0333046]

Description

Ovariole number was counted in 14 DGRP lines. In 13 of them, egg and adult offspring production over 5 days of mated females infected with Providencia rettgeri or sham-infected, and survival to 120 h after infection, were measured. Ovariole number predicted neither fecundity nor survival.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the authors' GitHub repository, given in the Data Availability statement of the paper, and from the S1 File of the Supporting information (pone.0333046.s001.docx):
- Egg_offspring_count_data.csv: number of females, eggs and adult offspring per tube and day, used for raw dataset 1.
- Survivorship_data.csv: number of infected females found dead at each daily check, or alive at 120 h, per line and block, used for raw dataset 2.
- S1 Table and S2 Table (S1 File): mean ovariole number per line, and the per-line difference in egg production between sham-infected and infected females, used for the summary dataset.
- Egg_offspring_count.Rmd: the authors' analysis script, which holds the per-line survival proportions used for Fig 2B and 2C (summary dataset).

Design: 13 DGRP lines were chosen from Lobell et al. 2017 for low (DGRP_382, 395, 397, 646, 776, 786, 837) or high (DGRP_129, 370, 443, 486, 737, 799) ovariole number. Only females were phenotyped. Flies were reared at about 24 °C (12:12 h light:dark) on Cornell cornmeal-sucrose medium. Females 4-6 days old were mated for 24 h and then infected by pricking the thorax with a 0.15 mm pin dipped in Providencia rettgeri (A600 = 1.0), or sham-infected with a sterile pin. Phenotype names end in _Prett (infected) or _Sham (sham-infected).

Raw dataset 1 (one row per tube): groups of up to 5 females (kept with 8 males until infection) were moved to fresh food every 24 h for 5 days. Eggs were counted daily, and the adult offspring of each daily vial were collected until 48 h after the first eclosion and counted. There were 3 blocks of 3 tubes per line and treatment (9 tubes). The infected and sham tubes are different tubes, stacked on the same row (same block and tube number). As in the paper, the egg and offspring counts are divided by the number of females alive in the tube at the start of each day:
- EggsD1-D5 and OffsprD1-D5: eggs and adult offspring per female on each of the 5 days after infection (S4 Fig shows the eggs per day; the offspring per day are not shown in the paper).
- Eggs5d and Offspr5d: their sums over the 5 days, the per-tube values the authors analysed (Fig 1, Fig 3, S1-S3 Fig, S2 Table). The design is balanced, so DGRPool's line means equal the authors' estimated marginal means: the sham minus infected differences of the line means reproduce S2 Table (mn_Eggs5d_NIminusI) for all 13 lines, and the Spearman correlations with ovariole number reproduce the paper.
- NFemD1-D5 (obsolete): the number of females alive in the tube at the start of each day (the denominator), with the obsolete design columns EggBlock and EggTube.

Raw dataset 2 (one row per infected female): after infection, females were kept in vials of 10 (those that did not recover from anaesthesia were discarded) and checked daily until 120 h, in 3 blocks of about 30 females per line (72-95 per line). The authors' file pools the vials of a block (SurvBlock is kept as an obsolete column). DeathTime_Prett is the check (24 to 120 h) at which the female was found dead; females alive at 120 h keep 120, as in the authors' file, where they are censored. Alive_Prett is 1 for the females alive at 120 h and 0 otherwise, so its line mean is the proportion surviving. The sham-infected females of this assay (59 females, 53 alive at 120 h) are recorded as one 'Sham' group without a line, so they are not uploaded.

Summary dataset:
- mn_OvarioleNum: mean number of ovarioles per ovary (both ovaries of 10 females per line counted, total divided by 20; S1 Table), for 14 lines: DGRP_315 was counted but not used in the other assays. The per-female counts are not available. S1 Table also lists the means of Lobell et al. 2017 for the same lines, which are in DGRPool as study 174 (not uploaded here); the two correlate at Spearman ρ = 0.94, as in the paper.
- mn_Alive_PrettAuth: the authors' proportions of infected females alive at 120 h, used for the correlations of Fig 2B and 2C (ρ = −0.044 with ovariole number, ρ = 0.18 with egg number). They equal the line means of Alive_Prett for 10 lines but differ for 3: DGRP_129 (0.392, i.e. 31/79 females, vs 38/79 alive in the survival file), DGRP_395 (0.295, i.e. 28/95, vs 26/95) and DGRP_443 (0.397, the value of DGRP_737, vs 53/90). With the survival file, the two correlations are ρ = 0.11 and ρ = 0.19 (still not significant).
- mn_Eggs5d_NIminusI: S2 Table, the sham (NI) minus infected (I) contrast of the estimated marginal means of the eggs laid per female over 5 days (13 lines; significant for DGRP_837, 382, 776, 129 and 486 in the paper). It equals the line mean of Eggs5d_Sham minus that of Eggs5d_Prett (raw dataset 1). The same difference for the adult offspring is not published per line; it can be derived the same way from Offspr5d_Sham and Offspr5d_Prett.

Of note: in 6 sham tubes (3 of DGRP_443, 2 of DGRP_486, 1 of DGRP_837) the number of females increases from one day to the next, and only 4 females are recorded on day 1 in 29 sham tubes and 1 infected tube. One sham tube of DGRP_395 (block 3, tube 2) has 212 eggs from 4 females on day 5 (53 per female), against 21-89 eggs on days 1-4. All values are kept as published.

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 3 phenotypes
mn_Alive_PrettAuth mn_Eggs5d_NIminusI mn_OvarioleNum
14 DGRP lines
DGRP_129
DGRP_315
DGRP_370
DGRP_382
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_443
DGRP_486
DGRP_646
DGRP_737
DGRP_776
DGRP_786
DGRP_799
DGRP_837
Download
Raw dataset #1 24 phenotypes
Eggs5d_Prett Eggs5d_Sham EggsD1_Prett EggsD1_Sham EggsD2_Prett EggsD2_Sham EggsD3_Prett EggsD3_Sham EggsD4_Prett EggsD4_Sham EggsD5_Prett EggsD5_Sham Offspr5d_Prett Offspr5d_Sham OffsprD1_Prett OffsprD1_Sham OffsprD2_Prett OffsprD2_Sham OffsprD3_Prett OffsprD3_Sham OffsprD4_Prett OffsprD4_Sham OffsprD5_Prett OffsprD5_Sham
13 DGRP lines
DGRP_129
DGRP_370
DGRP_382
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_443
DGRP_486
DGRP_646
DGRP_737
DGRP_776
DGRP_786
DGRP_799
DGRP_837
Download
Raw dataset #2 2 phenotypes
Alive_Prett DeathTime_Prett
13 DGRP lines
DGRP_129
DGRP_370
DGRP_382
DGRP_395
DGRP_397
DGRP_443
DGRP_486
DGRP_646
DGRP_737
DGRP_776
DGRP_786
DGRP_799
DGRP_837
Download
Back to studies