Study

Curated
Chandler et al., 2020
Sexual Selection Does Not Increase the Rate of Compensatory Adaptation to a Mutation Influencing a Secondary Sexual Trait in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1534/g3.119.400934]

Description

Sex comb defects caused by the X-linked mutation scd1 (sex combs distal) were scored on F1 males from crosses of scd1 females to 14 DGRP lines: primary comb teeth and defects, and the ectopic comb on the second tarsal segment, whose penetrance and expressivity varied with the background.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the authors' file scd_RAL_data_final.csv, in the supplementary material on GSA figshare and in the authors' GitHub repository given in the Data Availability statement (DworkinLab/Chandler_etal_G3_2020, data/). It has the sex comb scores of each male of the genetic-background experiment (Figure 3), and the authors' analysis is in scripts/Figure3_plot_RAL.R. The two copies have the same values, but a spreadsheet converted 11 of the 20 slide dates of the GitHub copy, so the figshare copy was used. The rest of the paper (duplication mapping of scd1, fitness and experimental evolution in the outbred FVW population) does not use DGRP lines and is not uploaded.

These are F1 phenotypes, not phenotypes of the inbred DGRP lines: virgin females of the Bloomington stock 5070 (y1 scd1 ras1 v1 f1), which carries the spontaneous X-linked mutation sex combs distal (scd1), were crossed to males of 14 randomly chosen DGRP lines. The F1 males are hemizygous for scd1 (their X chromosome comes from the mother) and heterozygous for the DGRP autosomes, so recessive modifiers of the DGRP lines are not detected. scd1 causes an ectopic sex comb on the second tarsal segment (T2) of the male prothoracic leg, with incomplete penetrance. The adult F1 males were fixed in 70% ethanol, and their prothoracic legs were mounted in 70% glycerol and scored. Each value is assigned to the DGRP father line, and the cross is given in the phenotype names (_xscd1).

The raw dataset (raw_1) has one row per F1 male (sex M), 11 to 44 males per line (380 males):
- T1Teeth_xscd1: number of teeth of the primary sex comb, on the first tarsal segment (T1).
- T1Gaps_xscd1 and T1AbnTeeth_xscd1: number of gaps and number of abnormal teeth in the primary sex comb.
- T1ExtraComb_xscd1: extra (partial) sex comb on T1, 1 = present (2 DGRP males).
- T2Teeth_xscd1: number of teeth of the ectopic sex comb on T2 (0 = no ectopic comb).
- T2Comb_xscd1: 1 if the male has an ectopic comb on T2 (T2Teeth_xscd1 > 0), 0 otherwise. Its line mean is the penetrance of scd1 (Figure 3A).
- T2TeethExpr_xscd1: T2Teeth_xscd1 of the males that have an ectopic comb (NA for the others). Its line mean is the expressivity (Figure 3B).
T2Comb_xscd1 and T2TeethExpr_xscd1 are recodings of the t2_teeth column, made for DGRPool as in the authors' script, so that DGRPool's line means give the two traits of the paper. SlideDate_xscd1 (dissection date, YYYY-MM-DD, decoded from the M-D-YY dates of the file) and MaleNum_xscd1 (number of the male in the file, unique within a line and date) are design columns, kept as obsolete phenotypes.

Excluded males: 17 DGRP males have no primary comb tooth count (t1_teeth NA). The authors' script removes every male with a missing value (na.omit) before both analyses, so these males are left out here too. 16 of them have 0 ectopic teeth, even in lines where every other male has an ectopic comb, so their legs were probably not scorable. Keeping them would lower the penetrance of 8 lines (by up to 0.13, for DGRP_852).

With these exclusions, the line means computed from the raw dataset equal the authors' penetrance and expressivity estimates for the 14 lines, and the file reproduces the paper's statistics (penetrance: χ2 = 127.6, P = 5.3 × 10-19; expressivity: χ2 = 259.0). The paper gives df = 18, but its P value corresponds to 17 df (18 backgrounds minus one). These tests also include 4 backgrounds that are not DGRP lines and are not uploaded: the progenitor stock 5070 itself (the lowest penetrance, 0.47) and the F1 males of crosses to Oregon-R, Samarkand and the outbred FVW population. Pure wild-type males of these three strains (not crossed to 5070) are in the file too and are not uploaded. In the DGRP crosses, the penetrance ranged from 0.67 (DGRP_399) to 1 (6 lines) and the expressivity from 1.06 (DGRP_399) to 4.09 ectopic teeth (DGRP_021). There was no GWAS.

Other external data available

10.25387/g3.8343863 GSA figshare supplementary material (per-male sex comb data scd_RAL_data_final.csv and R scripts; also on GitHub DworkinLab/Chandler_etal_G3_2020)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 7 phenotypes
T1AbnTeeth_xscd1 T1ExtraComb_xscd1 T1Gaps_xscd1 T1Teeth_xscd1 T2Comb_xscd1 T2TeethExpr_xscd1 T2Teeth_xscd1
14 DGRP lines
DGRP_021
DGRP_026
DGRP_208
DGRP_301
DGRP_304
DGRP_315
DGRP_362
DGRP_399
DGRP_437
DGRP_517
DGRP_639
DGRP_765
DGRP_774
DGRP_852
Download
Back to studies