Study

Curated
Arbuthnott et al., 2016
The impacts of Wolbachia and the microbiome on mate choice in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.1111/jeb.12788]

Description

Female attractiveness, male mating rate and choosiness, and female body mass were measured in 10 DGRP lines, untreated or tetracycline-treated to remove Wolbachia (with or without microbiota restoration). Microbiome disruption altered attractiveness line-specifically; Wolbachia did not alter mating.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data come from Table 2 of the paper (female body mass; journal page, author manuscript on PMC4744502) and from the authors' Dryad deposit (per-trial mating data).

Design: 10 DGRP lines (DGRP_085, 181, 256, 313, 338, 362, 371, 399, 555, 738), chosen to cover several Wolbachia/mitochondrial haplotypes: 6 are naturally infected with Wolbachia (181, 256, 338, 362, 555, 738) and 4 are not (85, 313, 371, 399), as the authors confirmed by PCR and qPCR. Each line was tested in three forms: U, untreated flies; T, tetracycline-treated flies (0.08 mg/mL in the food for three generations, then four generations without antibiotic; this removes Wolbachia and perturbs the other microbiota); TC, treated-and-crossed flies (T females crossed to U males of the same line, to restore the microbiota without Wolbachia). T flies of DGRP_256 did not produce enough offspring and were not tested. Flies were reared on molasses-cornmeal food at room temperature. T and TC flies have the genotype of their DGRP line, so the treatment is a condition, given as a suffix of the phenotype names (_U, _T, _TC).

Summary dataset (Table 2): mn_BodyMass_U/_T/_TC and se_BodyMass_U/_T/_TC, mean and standard error of the mass of one virgin female (mg, 3-5 days old; 4-6 females were weighed together and the mass per female was recorded for 4-10 pools per line and treatment). Values as published (2 decimals), sex F, 9 lines: DGRP_256 is not in Table 2, although the Methods say mass was recorded in all lines and treatments. Two values are about half those of the other treatments of the same line (DGRP_085 U, 0.56 mg; DGRP_555 TC, 0.57 mg); they are kept as published. The paper found a line effect on mass and a treatment × infection interaction: infected lines were lighter after the T and TC treatments (mean of the line means 1.13 mg U, 1.02 T, 1.04 TC), uninfected lines were not (0.88, 0.97, 0.94).

Raw dataset 1 (raw_1), female attractiveness (Dryad: female attractiveness.csv; female attractiveness replicate.csv for the _A2 phenotypes, a repeat of the assay on 4 lines, DGRP_085, 181, 313 and 555, 10 weeks later, not in Figure 1): in each 2-h choice trial, one treated (T or TC) and one untreated (U) virgin female of the same line, marked with red or green fluorescent powder (balanced), competed for one virgin Canton-S male (uninfected). One row per trial, sex F, 10 lines; trials of different treatments are independent (row k holds the k-th trial of each treatment of the line). Assay 1: 365 trials (18-20 per line and treatment, no T trials for DGRP_256), 297 with a mating, in two blocks one day apart (AttrBlock_T/_TC, obsolete); repeat assay: 193 trials (23-25 per line and treatment), 142 with a mating, no block column. TrtMated_T/_TC (and _A2): 1 if the treated female received the mating, 0 if the untreated female did, NA if no mating occurred within the 2 h (the authors excluded these trials from their analyses); the line mean is the proportion of matings won by the treated female, as in Figure 1 and Table 1 (0.5 = no effect). The raw data reproduce the 16 values of Table 1 (4 lines, T and TC, both assays; mean and binomial SE). Mating_T/_TC (and _A2): 1 if a mating occurred, 0 if not (in the authors' file, not analysed per line in the paper). The authors modelled the complement (the untreated female received the mating) as a binomial response, with line and block as fixed effects.

Raw dataset 2 (raw_2), male mating rate and choosiness (Dryad: male choosiness.csv): in each 2-h trial a virgin male of the line and treatment was given one DGRP_362 female (the more attractive line, Wolbachia-infected) and one DGRP_774 female (uninfected), marked with fluorescent powder. One row per trial, sex M, 10 lines: 509 trials (8-20 per line and treatment, no T males of DGRP_256), 394 with a mating (the paper's "394 trials"), in two blocks (ChoiceBlock_U/_T/_TC, obsolete). Mated_U/_T/_TC: 1 if the male mated, 0 if not (the line mean is the mating rate). Chose362_U/_T/_TC: 1 if it mated the DGRP_362 female, 0 if the DGRP_774 female, NA if it did not mate.

Microbiome disruption (T) changed female attractiveness in a line-specific way that was not repeatable 10 weeks later, while Wolbachia had no effect on female attractiveness or on male mating rate and choosiness.

Not uploaded: the Wolbachia infection status of the lines (a DGRP annotation, not measured by this study).

Other external data available

10.5061/dryad.75ph1 Dryad data of the paper (per-trial female attractiveness, repeat assay and male choosiness trials)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 6 phenotypes
mn_BodyMass_T mn_BodyMass_TC mn_BodyMass_U se_BodyMass_T se_BodyMass_TC se_BodyMass_U
9 DGRP lines
DGRP_085
DGRP_181
DGRP_313
DGRP_338
DGRP_362
DGRP_371
DGRP_399
DGRP_555
DGRP_738
Download
Raw dataset #1 8 phenotypes
Mating_T Mating_TC Mating_TC_A2 Mating_T_A2 TrtMated_T TrtMated_TC TrtMated_TC_A2 TrtMated_T_A2
10 DGRP lines
DGRP_085
DGRP_181
DGRP_256
DGRP_313
DGRP_338
DGRP_362
DGRP_371
DGRP_399
DGRP_555
DGRP_738
Download
Raw dataset #2 6 phenotypes
Chose362_T Chose362_TC Chose362_U Mated_T Mated_TC Mated_U
10 DGRP lines
DGRP_085
DGRP_181
DGRP_256
DGRP_313
DGRP_338
DGRP_362
DGRP_371
DGRP_399
DGRP_555
DGRP_738
Download
Back to studies