Study

Rejected
Massey et al., 2019
Pleiotropic Effects of ebony and tan on Pigmentation and Cuticular Hydrocarbon Composition in Drosophila melanogaster
[10.3389/fphys.2019.00518]

Description

Rejected: no new per-line data. The DGRP part reuses published pigmentation and CHC data of 155 lines; the new qRT-PCR of ebony and tan in females of 23 lines was never published per line.

Comments from curator

Rejected: no per-line phenotype data are available for this study.

The bioRxiv preprint (10.1101/538090) of this study was published in Frontiers in Physiology 10:518 (2019), 10.3389/fphys.2019.00518 (PMC version). Most experiments were done on ebony and tan mutants, RNAi knockdowns and drug-fed flies, not on DGRP lines. On the DGRP, the authors:
- reused published data: the female abdominal pigmentation scores (A5 and A6 tergites) of Dembeck et al. 2015a and the female cuticular hydrocarbon (CHC) profiles of Dembeck et al. 2015b, for the 155 lines that have both, to compare the CHC chain-length profiles of dark, intermediate and light lines (Figure 4 and Supplementary Figure S6). These data are already in DGRPool under studies 10 and 11.
- measured ebony and tan expression by qRT-PCR (normalized to Act57B and Rp49) in headless bodies of virgin females collected within 1 h of eclosion, with 3 biological replicates per line, in 23 DGRP lines. The Methods list 24 lines (RAL-208, 303, 324, 335, 357, 358, 360, 365, 380, 399, 437, 517, 555, 705, 707, 714, 732, 774, 786, 799, 820, 852, 861 and 892), while the text and the Figure 5 groups count 23.

The per-line expression values are not published. Figure 5 only shows the CHC differences of groups of lines with low, intermediate and high expression (cut-offs at the mean ± 0.5 SD), without line names or expression values. The supplementary material holds only Supplementary Table S1 (CHC names and formulas) and Supplementary Figures S1-S6 (mutants, knockdowns, drug feeding and the A6 pigmentation groups), the bioRxiv preprint has the same supplements, and no data repository is cited. So there is nothing to upload.

2 categories

Appearance Metabolism

No phenotype

No data

DGRP lines

None

Datasets

Back to studies