Comments from curator
Rejected: no per-line phenotype data are available for this study.The phenotype measured on the DGRP is the
eclosion of larvae exposed to p-xylene. First-instar (L1) larvae were transferred to grape juice agar plates containing either 1.068 mM p-xylene or the DMSO control, in triplicates of 25 larvae per line. The number of adults that eclosed within 16 days (2 weeks) was counted, with sexes not separated. The p-xylene dose is the LC
50 the authors estimated on seven randomly chosen DGRP lines (RAL-832, RAL-38, RAL-41, RAL-882, RAL-509, RAL-859 and RAL-181;
Table 3, pooled values only). The panel was assayed in batches, with RAL-38 repeated in every batch as a batch control. Of the 200 lines assayed, 56 produced no adults at all, in the control or on p-xylene. The other 144 lines were analysed. The authors define performance as the mean difference in eclosion between the control and p-xylene media. Their GWAS (DGRP2 web pipeline) used the line means of eclosion on p-xylene and, in a second analysis, this difference.
Per-line values are only shown as bar plots of the mean eclosion per 25 larvae for the 144 lines, in
Figure 3 of the
paper (
PMC version). Following DGRPool rules, they were not digitised. The only
supplementary file (Data Sheet 1, also on
figshare) contains:
-
Supplementary Tables 1A and 1B: the genome-wide association results (allele counts and P-values per variant).
-
Supplementary Table 2: the 38 top variants.
-
Supplementary Table 3: annotations of the candidate genes.
-
Supplementary Figure 1: probit dose-response curves for
w1118 adults and for the pooled DGRP lines.
None of them has per-line phenotype values. The data availability statement only refers back to the article and its supplement, and no repository is cited.
The other experiments of the paper were done on
w1118, not on DGRP lines: the acute toxicity of benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and the three xylene isomers to adults, the effect of these compounds on larval development, and the apoptosis and mitosis in wing imaginal discs of larvae exposed to benzene and p-xylene.