Study

Rejected
Morgante et al., 2020
Leveraging Multiple Layers of Data To Predict Drosophila Complex Traits
[10.1534/g3.120.401847]

Description

Rejected: no new phenotype measured on DGRP lines. Starvation resistance, chill coma recovery and startle response of about 200 DGRP lines (Mackay et al. 2012, studies 21 and 24) were predicted per sex from genotypes, whole-fly gene expression and Gene Ontology annotation.

Comments from curator

No phenotype data: this study was rejected because no new phenotype was measured on DGRP lines.

This is a genomic prediction study. It was first posted on bioRxiv (10.1101/824896, 2019) and published in G3 in 2020 (10.1534/g3.120.401847; PMC version). The authors compared how well three kinds of data predict three traits in females and males, using 30 replicates of fivefold cross-validation:
  • DNA variants (GBLUP; 1,908,995 variants with MAF > 0.05 and call rate > 0.8).
  • Whole-fly gene expression (TBLUP; RNA-seq of 200 DGRP lines from Everett et al., 2020).
  • Combinations of the two, with or without Gene Ontology annotation.
The three traits are the line means of starvation resistance, chill coma recovery time and startle response published by Mackay et al., 2012. Of the lines with expression data, 198 had starvation resistance, 172 chill coma recovery and 199 startle response. The analysis code adjusts these means for Wolbachia infection and the five major inversions. The traits are already in DGRPool:
  • Study 21 has the line means (mn_StarvationRes, mn_ChillComaRec, mn_StartleRes).
  • Study 24 has the per-fly data of about 200 lines (StarvationRes, ChillComaRec, StartleRes).
The paper does not publish any per-line values:
  • The supplementary material on GSA figshare holds only the supplementary figures and two tables listing the genes in the three most predictive GO terms (Tables S1 and S2).
  • The analysis code on GitHub reads the per-sex phenotype files but does not include them. For all trait data, the paper points to the DGRP2 website (http://dgrp2.gnets.ncsu.edu).
All results (prediction accuracies, variance components, predictive GO terms) are given per model, trait, sex or GO term, never per DGRP line, so there is nothing to upload to DGRPool.

The RNA-seq data are in GEO GSE117850.

Other external data available

GSE117850 RNA-seq of whole young adult females and males of 200 DGRP lines (Everett et al. 2020), used as predictors

3 categories

Resistance Behaviour Locomotion

No phenotype

No data

DGRP lines

None

Datasets

Back to studies