Comments from curator
Phenotyping data comes from
S1 File of the paper (
pone.0185090.s003.zip, "Compressed archive of the raw data files"):
-
Table1_raw_data.xlsx: activity of each vial of 10 flies in the Rotating Exercise Quantification System (REQS), basal or rotation-induced (data of Fig 2 and Tables 1 and 4). Used for raw_1 (one row per vial).
-
Table2_raw_data.xlsx: distance travelled by each fly in the video-tracking assay, basal or after tapping (data of Fig 3 and Table 2). Used for raw_2 (one row per fly).
- Table4A_raw_data.xlsx and Table4B_raw_data.xlsx hold the basal and induced rows of Table1 and were not used.
Design: virgin males and females, 3-7 days old, of DGRP lines 48, 73, 100 and 181, reared at 25 °C. REQS: 10 vials of 10 flies per line and sex in a Trikinetics LAM25H activity monitor mounted on a rotating arm; laser-beam crossings of each vial were recorded from 11 am to 12 pm with the vials upright and still (BasalAct_REQS), then from 12 to 2 pm while the monitor rotated at 4 rpm (InducedAct_REQS). Both are crossings per vial per hour (the induced value is the 2-h total divided by 2). Video tracking: 10 single flies per line and sex on an agar plate, filmed for 10 s at rest (BasalDist_Video) and for 10 s right after tapping the plate (InducedDist_Video); distance travelled in mm (Tracker software).
Layout: the files give no vial or fly identifier. Within line and sex, the k-th basal value and the k-th induced value are put on the same row. For the REQS they are the same vial (the order matches the vial numbers of study 78, and the paired values correlate, r = 0.57); for the video they are presumably the same fly (r = 0.27).
Checks: the data reproduce the sums of squares of the paper's ANOVAs (Tables 1, 2 and 4) and the means quoted for line 100 (165 and 790 crossings per hour). The ranking of Table 3 is reproduced, except for basal video activity: in the data line 100 (mean 118.4 mm) is above line 48 (100.3 mm), while Table 3 ranks line 48 second and line 100 third.
Related study: the REQS recordings of these 4 lines are also part of DGRPool study 78 (Watanabe et al. 2020,
10.1534/g3.119.401034, 161 lines, in crossings per 5 min). The induced values here are study 78's 2-h totals divided by 2 for all 80 vials; the basal values come from the same vials but are 4-14% lower than study 78's (probably a different recording window). Study 78 has no basal data for line 48.
Not uploaded: the comparison of continuous and interval exercise regimes (Fig 4, DGRP lines 307, 315 and 852) is only shown in a figure, and the S1 File has no data for the correlation of basal and induced activity over 130 lines quoted in the text.