Study

Curated
Kutzer et al., 2018
Genotype and diet affect resistance, survival, and fecundity but not fecundity tolerance
[10.1111/jeb.13211]

Description

Females of 9 DGRP lines on an added- or reduced-yeast diet were injected with Lactococcus lactis, Pseudomonas entomophila or Ringer's solution; bacterial load, fecundity and survival were measured 24 h later. Resistance varied among lines, fecundity tolerance did not.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data come from the authors' Dryad deposit (doi:10.5061/dryad.t9q61, CC0), file DGRP_data.xlsx (six sheets), the data of the paper (journal page).

Design: ten genotypes, nine DGRP lines with variable fecundity (DGRP_208, 350, 367, 373, 375, 379, 406, 509 and 765) and the locally collected population 1_4WS (not a DGRP line: its 104 females and its survival counts are not uploaded). Virgin females (F2 of each stock, reared at controlled larval density) were mated in groups for 30 min at 5-6 days of age and then kept individually on an added-yeast diet (AY: sugar-yeast-agar medium with live baker's yeast granules, ad libitum yeast) or a reduced-yeast diet (RY: 25% of the yeast of that medium). About 26 h later they were injected (Nanoject, 18.4 nL) with Lactococcus lactis (Ll, about 1,840 bacteria), Pseudomonas entomophila (Pe, about 92 bacteria) or Drosophila Ringer's solution (Rg, injection control). Randomized block design: in each of 7 independent experimental replicates (numbered 2-8 in the file), 3 females (blocks 1-3) per genotype × diet × injection group, i.e. 21 females per group. Survival was scored 24 h post-injection (hpi); the bacterial load of the surviving L. lactis- and P. entomophila-infected females (colony-forming units, CFU, in a whole-fly homogenate) was measured at 24 hpi; fecundity is the number of adult offspring a female produced before injection (pre-infection, in the about 26 h between mating and injection) and in the 24 hpi (post-infection). Because of the high mortality, the authors left the P. entomophila-infected females on RY out of all analyses except survival: the file has no fecundity or load for them.

raw_1 (sheets Fecundity, L. lactis resistance_tolerance and P. entomophila resis_tol, joined by fly ID): one row per line × replicate × block (189 rows, 9 lines, sex F). Each row holds the female of that replicate and block in each of the 5 groups (different females; the design columns Replicate and Block are obsolete). FecPre_* and FecPost_*: adult offspring before and in the 24 h after injection; CFU_*: total CFU of the female at 24 hpi. Suffixes: _Rg, _Ll, _Pe (Ringer's, L. lactis, P. entomophila) and _AY, _RY (diet). 903 females (Rg_AY 186, Rg_RY 186, Ll_AY 185, Ll_RY 183, Pe_AY 163); NA: no female of that group in the file for that replicate and block (dead or missing). When a plate had too many colonies to count at the highest dilution (about 2% of plates), the authors gave the female the highest count of its genotype/treatment group; the file does not flag these values.

raw_2 (the three survival sheets): one row per line × replicate (63 rows, sex F): Alive24h_* and Dead24h_*, the number of the 3 injected females of the replicate alive and dead at 24 hpi, for the 6 groups (including P. entomophila on RY), as in the file; SurvReplicate obsolete. The survival of a line (Figure 1) is the sum of Alive24h divided by the sum of Alive24h and Dead24h: the authors' binomial models use the alive and dead counts per replicate, and this reproduces their mean survival of 98.8% after Ringer's and 98.6% after L. lactis (P. entomophila: 88% on AY, 22% on RY).

Not uploaded: the authors' percent change of post-infection fecundity relative to the Ringer's controls (sheets 2 and 3), a derived value: 100 × (FecPost of the infected female − mean FecPost_Rg of the same line and diet) / that mean. Fecundity tolerance (slope of this percent change on the load) and resistance (inverse of the load) come from the authors' models and are not given per line. The authors' exploratory GWAS used the median P. entomophila load per line on AY (the median of CFU_Pe_AY), with no significant association (nine lines only).

Inconsistencies in the file (kept as published unless stated): female 1339 (P. entomophila, AY, replicate 8, block 2) is DGRP_367 in the Fecundity sheet but DGRP_375 in the P. entomophila sheet; it is uploaded under DGRP_375, because no DGRP_367 female of that replicate survived (survival sheet: 0 alive) while the block-2 female of DGRP_375 is otherwise missing. Replicate 4, block 1 has two P. entomophila females of DGRP_367 (fly IDs 571 and 574; both uploaded under DGRP_367, on two rows) and none of DGRP_373: one of them is probably DGRP_373, but which one is unknown. Four P. entomophila females on AY (DGRP_208 twice, DGRP_375 and one 1_4WS) have fecundity but no load. In the L. lactis survival sheet, DGRP_208 RY replicate 3 has 2 alive, 0 dead and a total of 3. The number of survivors and the number of females in the Fecundity sheet differ by one or two in 11 of 350 replicates.

Four of the lines (DGRP_350, DGRP_367, DGRP_379 and DGRP_765) were chosen from this experiment for the follow-up study Kutzer, Kurtz & Armitage 2019 (J Anim Ecol 88:566-578, doi:10.1111/1365-2656.12953, PMC6487967; data on Dryad doi:10.5061/dryad.9kj41f0), on immune priming in these four lines (not in DGRPool).

Other external data available

10.5061/dryad.t9q61 Dryad deposit of the paper (DGRP_data.xlsx, the per-fly data of the six analyses of the paper)

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Raw dataset #1 13 phenotypes
CFU_Ll_AY CFU_Ll_RY CFU_Pe_AY FecPost_Ll_AY FecPost_Ll_RY FecPost_Pe_AY FecPost_Rg_AY FecPost_Rg_RY FecPre_Ll_AY FecPre_Ll_RY FecPre_Pe_AY FecPre_Rg_AY FecPre_Rg_RY
9 DGRP lines
DGRP_208
DGRP_350
DGRP_367
DGRP_373
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_406
DGRP_509
DGRP_765
Download
Raw dataset #2 12 phenotypes
Alive24h_Ll_AY Alive24h_Ll_RY Alive24h_Pe_AY Alive24h_Pe_RY Alive24h_Rg_AY Alive24h_Rg_RY Dead24h_Ll_AY Dead24h_Ll_RY Dead24h_Pe_AY Dead24h_Pe_RY Dead24h_Rg_AY Dead24h_Rg_RY
9 DGRP lines
DGRP_208
DGRP_350
DGRP_367
DGRP_373
DGRP_375
DGRP_379
DGRP_406
DGRP_509
DGRP_765
Download
Back to studies