Study

Curated
Duneau et al., 2025
A within-host infection model to explore tolerance and resistance
[10.7554/eLife.104052]

Description

Survival and bacterial load upon death (PLUD) of males of 4 DGRP lines injected with Providencia rettgeri (or PBS), with or without a prior thorax wound. The wound reduced survival and increased the PLUD in all lines, with no significant difference among lines.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from the authors' Zenodo archive (10.5281/zenodo.14451399, record 14451400), files wound_SURVIVAL.csv and wound_CFU.csv of data.zip. The R analysis of these files is in HR_PLUD.pdf of the same record (section 'Wounds increase both susceptibility to infection and PLUD'). The other files of data.zip (ABAB, Drs_Sk1, RNAi) are AMP mutants and RNAi lines, not DGRP lines.

Design (Fig. 7 and Appendix 7 of the paper): mated males of 4 DGRP lines (RAL-559, 584, 630 and 818, all with the same Diptericin A S69 allele), 5-8 days old, reared on glucose-yeast food at 24 °C, were either pricked in the thorax (wound) or not, then injected in the abdomen with 23 nL of Providencia rettgeri (about 900-2,200 bacteria) or of PBS. Dead flies were collected every 30 min from 12 to 24 h after injection and homogenised one by one in 250 µL of PBS; dilutions were plated as 5-µL drops and the colonies counted. Survival was then followed for up to about 7 days. The experiment was run on 6 injection dates (the authors' random block); PBS controls only on 15/09/2021.

Raw dataset (raw_1), one row per fly (2,765 males; sex M): the columns of a row are filled only for the fly's own condition (P. rettgeri or PBS, wound or no wound; the other columns are NA).
- SurvTime_<Pr|PBS>_<NoWound|Wound> (hours): column t of wound_SURVIVAL.csv, the time from injection to death, or to censoring for a fly that did not die. Dead_...: column Censor (1 = died, 0 = censored). As in the authors' Cox models (Surv(t, Censor)), censored flies keep their censoring time: the end of observation of their block (about 136-187 h, but 40 h for the 17/02/2021 block), 10.45 h for 23 wounded infected RAL-584 flies of 15/09/2021, and about 136 h for 40 unwounded infected flies sampled alive for the set-point load (SPBL; their counts are not in the files). The DGRPool mean of SurvTime therefore mixes death and censoring times; the mean of Dead is the proportion of flies that died.
- PLUD_Pr_<NoWound|Wound>: log10 pathogen load upon death of the infected flies that died and were plated (389 flies). It is computed from the drop counts of wound_CFU.csv exactly as the authors' script does: CFUfit::loadEstimate(BACTERIA, 1/(4*Dilution), Volume, sample_ID, maxCFU = 50, ignoreAboveMaxCFU = FALSE, logbase = 10). No drop has more than 50 colonies, so this maximum-likelihood estimate is log10(total colonies / sum over drops of Volume/(4 × Dilution)), written at full precision (R's uniroot stops at a tolerance of about 10-4). It is on the authors' scale (Fig. 7B, 'log_10 PLUD'). Dead flies without drop counts (32) are NA. The authors flagged low PLUD values as outliers with a Rosner test per line and wound treatment (14 flies: 8 unwounded, 6 wounded) and analysed the data with and without them; all values are uploaded. Fly-to-sample matching: 24 sample_IDs (wells of plates 64 and 65) are given to two flies each in wound_SURVIVAL.csv; the counts were assigned by sample_ID, line, wound treatment, injection date and death time, which identifies one fly each (the first one, as in the authors' match()).
- InjDate, Replicate, Inoculum (obsolete design columns): injection date written YYYYMMDD (the authors' block, Day_of_injection), replicate number within date (none for 15/09/2021), and the estimated number of viable bacteria injected per fly on that date (CFU_injected; NA for PBS).

Summary dataset (sex M): the authors' per-line wound effects of Fig. 7C, as printed in HR_PLUD.pdf (d.lHR.lPR). hr_log_Wound: natural log of the hazard ratio of wounded vs unwounded flies, coefficient Line:Treatment of coxme(Surv(t, Censor) ~ -1 + Line + Line:Treatment + (1|Day_of_injection)) fitted on all flies of the file (P. rettgeri and PBS pooled, as in the script). PLUDlogRatio_Wound: log10 ratio of the PLUD of wounded vs unwounded flies, coefficient Line:Treatment of a Gaussian mixed model of the PLUD (weights 1/SE2, random injection date) without the outliers. The bootstrap 95% CIs are in the PDF and are not uploaded.

Checks: the uploaded data reproduce the authors' outputs exactly: the proportion of dead flies per line, dose and wound treatment (HR_PLUD.pdf p. 1), the numbers of infected flies per line (Fig. 7A legend, e.g. 584: 231/315), the numbers of PLUD estimates per line and treatment (36/52, 74/67, 45/47, 40/28) and per line (Fig. 7B: 141, 88, 68, 92).

The paper is mostly a theoretical model of within-host infection dynamics; the AMP-mutant, Catalase RNAi and simulation parts do not use DGRP lines. Wounding sharply reduced survival in all lines and increased the PLUD (significant only in RAL-630 when the lines are tested separately), with no significant line x wound interaction.

4 DGRP lines 4 genotyped

DGRP_559 DGRP_584 DGRP_630 DGRP_818

Datasets

Dataset Phenotypes DGRP lines
Summary dataset 2 phenotypes
PLUDlogRatio_Wound hr_log_Wound
4 DGRP lines
DGRP_559
DGRP_584
DGRP_630
DGRP_818
Download
Raw dataset #1 10 phenotypes
Dead_PBS_NoWound Dead_PBS_Wound Dead_Pr_NoWound Dead_Pr_Wound PLUD_Pr_NoWound PLUD_Pr_Wound SurvTime_PBS_NoWound SurvTime_PBS_Wound SurvTime_Pr_NoWound SurvTime_Pr_Wound
4 DGRP lines
DGRP_559
DGRP_584
DGRP_630
DGRP_818
Download
Back to studies