Study

Curated
Auer et al., 2020
Olfactory receptor and circuit evolution promote host specialization
[10.1038/s41586-020-2073-7]

Description

Responses of the Or22a/b (ab3A) olfactory neuron to six noni esters and the solvent were recorded in females of 3 DGRP lines. DGRP_303 and DGRP_304, which share an OR22a variant with D. mauritiana, had D. mauritiana-like responses, with weaker responses to ethyl esters.

Comments from curator

Phenotyping data comes from Supplementary Table 7 ("Spike counts for electrophysiological experiments", 41586_2020_2073_MOESM4_ESM.xlsx) of the paper (journal page, also on PMC), block "Extended Data Figure 11g/h" (rows 229-234), which gives the mean, SEM and n of each strain and odour shown in Extended Data Fig. 11g. The paper is about the olfactory adaptation of D. sechellia to noni fruit. To test the effect of natural Or22a variation, the authors selected 3 DGRP lines whose Or22a sequences they confirmed (Extended Data Fig. 11f): DGRP_303 and DGRP_304, which share with D. mauritiana an amino-acid difference at OR22a position 59, and DGRP_324.

Design: single-sensillum recordings of ab3 sensilla in females; responses of the Or22a/b (ab3A) neuron to six esters present in noni (ethyl octanoate, ethyl hexanoate, ethyl butanoate, methyl octanoate, methyl hexanoate, methyl butanoate; diluted in paraffin oil at 10-2 v/v, except ethyl hexanoate at 10-4 and methyl hexanoate at 10-6, as in the table headers "Ethyl hex-4" and "Methyl hex-6") and to the solvent (paraffin oil, PO). A response is the number of spikes in a 0.5 s window at stimulus delivery minus the spontaneous spikes in a 0.5 s window before stimulation, multiplied by two (spikes s-1, uploaded with the unit Hz); the odour responses shown in the figures are solvent-corrected (minus the response to the solvent). n = 6 neurons for DGRP_303 and 5 for DGRP_304 and DGRP_324 (at most three sensilla per fly).

Only these line means and SEMs are published: the individual neuron responses appear only as points in the boxplots of Extended Data Fig. 11h, and other data are "available from the corresponding authors upon request". The study therefore has a summary dataset only (sex F, 3 lines, values copied as printed): mn_Or22a_<odour> (mean) and se_Or22a_<odour> (standard error of the mean) for EthOct, EthHex, EthBut, MetOct, MetHex, MetBut and PO.

Paper's result: compared with the D. melanogaster strain BER (pairwise Wilcoxon tests), the response profiles of DGRP_303 and DGRP_304 (much lower responses to ethyl octanoate and ethyl hexanoate than BER and DGRP_324) resemble that of D. mauritiana, suggesting that their shared polymorphism at position 59 modifies OR22a response properties. No DGRP line with a polymorphism only at the key position 93 was found.

Not uploaded: the D. melanogaster BER strain, D. mauritiana and D. sechellia rows of the same block, and all other experiments of the paper (other Drosophila species, mutant and transgenic strains).

3 DGRP lines 3 genotyped

DGRP_303 DGRP_304 DGRP_324
Back to studies