Comments from curator
Rejected: no per-line phenotype data are available for this study.Neither the
article nor its
Supplementary Data (Files S1-S9) give per-line values: the 139 line means are only shown in Figure 1, a scatterplot of larval and adult survival without line labels. No data repository (Dryad, Zenodo, figshare) was found.
Design (Methods of the article): 139 vigorous DGRP lines kept at Kansas State University, reared at 25 °C. Five serial replicate vials per line and stage (offspring laid on days 2 to 6).
Larvae: third-instar feeding larvae (120 h after egg laying), floated out with 20% sucrose, 20 per food vial, exposed for 1 h to -5 °C in a bath; survival is the proportion of adults that eclosed within 9 days (pupation gave similar results).
Adults: flies 5-7 days after eclosion, 10 males and 10 females per replicate in separate empty vials, 1 h at -5 °C; survival is the proportion able to walk and fly 24 h later. -5 °C was chosen from survival curves after 1 h at -8 to -2 °C (larvae, 28 lines) and -7 to -1 °C (adults, 36 lines) (Supplementary Files S2 and S3).
Results: mean survival was 0.73 in adults and 0.60 in larvae; broad-sense heritability was 0.44 (adults, sex as a fixed effect) and 0.22 (larvae), with no genetic correlation between stages (r
g = 0.085). The GWAS (BSLMM, GEMMA) used the larval survival and the residuals of adult survival after a sex effect.
Related DGRPool study from the same group:
105 (Freda et al. 2019, 39 of these lines, cold at -6.5 °C and heat, reared at 18 or 25 °C).