Study

Rejected
Gerken et al., 2015
Constraints, independence, and evolution of thermal plasticity: Probing genetic architecture of long- and short-term thermal acclimation
[10.1073/pnas.1503456112]

Description

Rejected: no per-line data. Survival after acute and chronic cold, with or without rapid cold hardening, was measured in both sexes of about 184 DGRP lines reared at 25 or 18 °C, but per-line values are only shown in figures.

Comments from curator

Rejected: no per-line phenotype data are available for this study.

The article has no per-line table: Figure 1 shows the survival of 30 unnamed example lines and the distribution of RCH capacity, and Tables 1-3 give correlations between traits, functional enrichments and tests of mutants (w1118 background). The SI Appendix (Figs. S1-S5, Tables S1-S2) and Datasets S1-S2 (GWAS SNPs, linkage disequilibrium, mutant tests) were checked as well: Figs. S1-S5 plot survival and acclimation scores without line labels, Tables S1-S2 give correlations, and the Datasets list GWAS variants, linkage disequilibrium and mutant tests. No Dryad or Zenodo deposit was found.

Design (article, Methods): all 192 DGRP lines, from the Bloomington Stock Center. Five males and five females of each line laid eggs for 3 days at 25 °C or at 18 °C (developmental cold acclimation, DACC: rearing at 18 °C through the whole life cycle). The offspring were sorted by sex and aged 5-7 days, and three replicate vials of 10-20 flies per line and sex were exposed, without food, to: chronic cold (0 °C for 16 h; flies reared at 25 °C), acute cold (-6 °C for 1 h; flies reared at 25 °C or 18 °C) and, for flies reared at 18 °C, -8 °C for 1 h; the acute exposures were done with or without a rapid cold hardening (RCH) pretreatment of 2 h at 4 °C. Flies were counted alive (coordinated movement) after 24 h of recovery on food at 25 °C. Survival proportions were averaged over the replicates, for each sex and for both sexes combined, and three acclimation capacities were computed from the line means as survival with acclimation minus survival without: RCH at 25 °C (-6 °C), DACC (-6 °C, reared at 18 °C vs 25 °C) and RCH at 18 °C (-8 °C). The analyses (heritabilities, correlations, GWAS for each sex and for both sexes combined) used about 184 lines (paired t tests with 183-184 df).

2 categories

Resistance Evolution

No phenotype

No data

DGRP lines

None

Datasets

Back to studies