Study

Rejected
Palu et al., 2020
Decoupling of Apoptosis from Activation of the ER Stress Response by the Drosophila Metallopeptidase superdeath
[10.1534/genetics.119.303004][FBrf0245428]

Description

Rejected: no new phenotype measured on DGRP lines; its only DGRP data are the F1 eye sizes of study 150. Mechanistic study of the metallopeptidase superdeath (CG14516), which promotes ER stress-induced apoptosis in the Rh1G69D retinal degeneration model.

Comments from curator

No phenotype data: this study was rejected because no new phenotype was measured on DGRP lines. This paper did not measure any new phenotype on the DGRP lines. Its only DGRP per-line data (Figure 1A and 1C) are the eye sizes of the Rh1G69D model of ER stress and retinal degeneration in 173 DGRP backgrounds, published earlier by the same lab in Chow et al. 2016, Human Molecular Genetics 25(4):651-659 (DGRPool study 150). The Figure 1 legend states: "Raw data for (A) and (C) were taken from Chow et al. 2016 and Huang et al. 2015".

Design of the reused data (Chow et al. 2016): the flies are not DGRP flies but the F1 progeny of crosses between virgin females of a donor strain carrying GMR-GAL4 and UAS-Rh1G69D on the same chromosome 2 (backcrossed to w1118) and males of each DGRP line, so half of their genome comes from the DGRP line. The left eye of at least 10 F1 females per cross, aged 3 days, was imaged and its area measured in pixels with ImageJ (males were measured only for a subset of lines, because of male larval lethality). The GWAS of Chow et al. used the median eye size per line.

What this paper does with it: eye sizes are plotted by allele of the SNP 3R:24966022 (dm3) in the first intron of CG14516, renamed superdeath (major A allele: 21,922 ± 2,279 pixels, N = 136 lines; minor T allele: 19,863 ± 2,873 pixels, N = 32; P = 2.24 × 10-5), and correlated with CG14516 expression in adult females from the DGRP expression data of Huang et al. 2015 (r = -0.25, N = 167 lines, P = 0.0013).

The per-line eye sizes are in the Supplementary Material of Chow et al. 2016 (PMC4743685; Table S1: eye size of the 173 DGRP crosses; Table S2: body weight of a subset of F1 females; Table S3: eye size of male F1 progeny for a subset of lines). These data belong to Chow et al. 2016, which is now DGRPool study 150 (added on 2026-11-10), where they are stored. The same eye sizes are also reused by DGRPool study 117 (Amstutz et al. 2022), rejected for the same reason.

The other experiments of the paper (RNAi knock-down of superdeath in the Rh1G69D model, tunicamycin survival of larvae, apoptosis, JNK and UPR markers, S2 cells; Supplemental Material on figshare) were not done on DGRP lines and are not included.

2 categories

Organ Size Anatomy

No phenotype

No data

DGRP lines

None

Datasets

Back to studies